Ghost of Tsushima DIRECTOR'S CUT

Ghost of Tsushima DIRECTOR'S CUT

Ver estadísticas:
Marcothy 5 JUN 2024 a las 10:18
1080 GTX vs 4070 Super
Needless to say, I've been on a 1080 GTX for a long time. Never really justified the spend on upgrading it as it still ran most games well enough maxed out or at least on High.

Just updated to a 4070 largely for this game. Holy smokes-night and day difference on even the rendered quality. Its insane
< >
Mostrando 16-30 de 50 comentarios
longjohn119 6 JUN 2024 a las 12:27 
There is most definitely an improvement in rendering for instance shader write compression is much better and more accurate in the latest generations compared to 6 years ago especially on the AMD side (Nvidia's was already good) Shader pipelines are also better. Another area that has shown improvement is DCC (Delta Color Compression) which is not only faster but more accurate
Marcothy 6 JUN 2024 a las 12:44 
Publicado originalmente por Weird Potato:
Publicado originalmente por Marcothy:
Rendering may be a divisive word to use. As well as it can get complicated when you take older games that don't leverage the different aspects as well. Yes-the GTX couldn't access features like DLSS, and nor does it support ray tracing. From a texture standpoint, the main thing that jumps out is the lighting and the way that interacts with textures. GTX there were features in the graphic and display settings I couldn't get to. With the 4070 they are now accessible. And its a drastic difference to the eye as I have everything maxed out and turned on.

So I will agree its not really apples to apples in terms of the render. But the 4070 can get to a place the GTX couldn't. Heck, with the GTX, this game would crash at start up with HDR turned on. I got 8 years out of that GTX though so not complaining.
Good god, It appears I'm still not being understood. Im not talking about DLSS or ray tracing. The OP implied image quality is better just by the simple use of the new card vs older one, not talking about DLSS etc. Not talking about everything maxed out. He implied if you change nothing except the gpu.
You realize I am the OP....
Marcothy 6 JUN 2024 a las 12:53 
Publicado originalmente por Donaldo Trumpado:
OP has discovered that technology changes over time. Better late than never i suppose
Honestly, I've mostly focused on the benchmark comparisons. Almost upgraded to a 3070 last year when I overhauled motherboard and cpu. But the gains just weren't there in the benchmarks to justify it. 4070-S that doesn't hold true anymore and it can get to a very noticeable different place that the GTX can't with certain games, such as GoT.
Weird Potato 6 JUN 2024 a las 13:52 
Publicado originalmente por Marcothy:
Publicado originalmente por Weird Potato:
Good god, It appears I'm still not being understood. Im not talking about DLSS or ray tracing. The OP implied image quality is better just by the simple use of the new card vs older one, not talking about DLSS etc. Not talking about everything maxed out. He implied if you change nothing except the gpu.
You realize I am the OP....
Wups?
Do you get it now then?
Marcothy 6 JUN 2024 a las 19:02 
Publicado originalmente por Weird Potato:
Publicado originalmente por Marcothy:
You realize I am the OP....
Wups?
Do you get it now then?
Sounds like you are looking for a win here...theres not one for you. You think Ray Tracing and DLSS don't matter when it comes to rendering. I never implied changing nothing. More sounds like an assumption on your part.

I will put it to you another way. 35 MPH is 35MPH. You can dumb down a ferari to top out at 35MPH and that doesn't mean it fires the same horsepower as your toyota corolla.

In your 1st response, you attributed it all to better framerate. Framerate has zero to do with quality of textures or visual experience. It will affect stutter, smoothness of scenes changing or how quickly you can see fast movements or changes.

On the GTX -everything was turned up, but certain setting had to be turned off to avoid the game crashing. And with these items turned on-its a very notable difference in the quality of what you see. Lighting or textures.

This is what the better card allowed me to enable without crashing:
HDR
Upscale DLSS (Set to quality)
Anti Aliasing (DLAA)
Frame Generation (DLSS)
Texture Filtering (upped from 2x to 16x)
Ambient Occlution (SSAO Quality)
Water Caustics (On)
Rest of Settings UNCHANGED.

All of those had to be turned off to avoid crashing with the 1080 GTX.

And for the record, Ray Tracing did not exist in the GTX line-but Nvidia allowed the cards to utilize Ray Tracing via driver, but at a major expense cost to the performance of the card.

GTX = Giga Texel Shader eXtreme
RTX = Ray Tracing X

Ray Tracing-the thing you says does not matter to rendering-is a MAJOR component to rendering (www.google.com). Framerate however has zero impact to rendered quality.

GTX 1080 is Tier 1B only to the 1080 Ti of that generation. 4070 S is Tier 3d.

To your original point, "going from 1 GPU to another doesn't affect quality?" Thats dead wrong. But you are right, I can hit 35 MPH and have the same poor graphics in the RTX4070 S if I match the settings with just still better lighting and framerate.

https://gpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Nvidia-RTX-4070-S-Super-vs-Nvidia-GTX-1080/4154vs3603
Última edición por Marcothy; 6 JUN 2024 a las 19:10
Weird Potato 6 JUN 2024 a las 19:34 
OMG you arent the brightest bulb in the pack are you lmao.

I suggest you reread what I've said. Sloooooowly.
You arent schooling me, thanks for the long winded write up though. Take a second and consider you may have TOTALLY misunderstood what I said.

If you meant the new card lets you enable settings not possible before, and /or turn up quality settings and have a good frame rate, well the confusion is on you for your poor choice of wording. For the final time, you implied you get better graphics SIMPLY BY THE PHYSICAL ACT OF CHANGING GPUS. You said the rendering quality was better. "rendering quality". I mean ya....




Edit LOLOL he linked Userbenchmarkl!! Someone wanna tell him?
Última edición por Weird Potato; 6 JUN 2024 a las 20:06
Marcothy 6 JUN 2024 a las 20:32 
Publicado originalmente por Weird Potato:
OMG you arent the brightest bulb in the pack are you lmao.

I suggest you reread what I've said. Sloooooowly.
You arent schooling me, thanks for the long winded write up though. Take a second and consider you may have TOTALLY misunderstood what I said.

If you meant the new card lets you enable settings not possible before, and /or turn up quality settings and have a good frame rate, well the confusion is on you for your poor choice of wording. For the final time, you implied you get better graphics SIMPLY BY THE PHYSICAL ACT OF CHANGING GPUS. You said the rendering quality was better. "rendering quality". I mean ya....




Edit LOLOL he linked Userbenchmarkl!! Someone wanna tell him?
I suggest you understand what an asshat is. First, you come on here assuming I meant just GPU changing alone enabled better rendering rather than the different achievable renders by the two. Could I have framed it more clearly for an asshat that wants to make assumptions or jump to a conclusion? Thats a lowest common denominator problem-and so far you are the LCD. Again-you spoke to me like I wasn't the OP. So definitely one of us struggles with assumptions and details.

This game doesn't support Ray Tracing. But it most definitely uses DLSS-which uses AI to upscale rendered images. While GTX can get to Ray Tracing via drivers-it cannot get to DLSS which is exclusive to RTX cards. Again, a specific example of how going from 1 gpu to another can improve rendering.

Which Mr Potato Head again asserted that neither Ray Tracing or DLSS impact rendering capability. As such-you can get the same quality render from a GTX in this game as you could an RTX. Which is complete BS. My decision to upgrade or not, mainly been on the % gain in frame rate and overall performance. And up through RTX3___ series, the gains were mostly marginal from a performance standpoint and didn't warrant a spend.

Main point in posting this was more of the aha that its far more than performance if you are GTX anything and getting into the RTX line. The RTX4 gen definitely warrants it on both ends of performance, but also wtf it can do.
Última edición por Marcothy; 6 JUN 2024 a las 20:34
Weird Potato 6 JUN 2024 a las 20:38 
Publicado originalmente por Marcothy:

Which Mr Potato Head again asserted that neither Ray Tracing or DLSS impact rendering capability.
LMAO!!
THAT'S JUST IT!!! I did no such thing! I REALLY don't know how to make my self any clearer.
YOU are the one that swapped GPU's and then came here all " wow the rendering quality is better. Like wait a second, the "redendering quality" is better just because you changed gpu's?
I'm done with you lol, jesus dude.
Última edición por Weird Potato; 6 JUN 2024 a las 20:39
Marcothy 6 JUN 2024 a las 20:43 
Publicado originalmente por Weird Potato:
Publicado originalmente por Marcothy:

Which Mr Potato Head again asserted that neither Ray Tracing or DLSS impact rendering capability.
LMAO!!
THAT'S JUST IT!!! I did no such thing! I REALLY don't know how to make my self any clearer.


Publicado originalmente por Weird Potato:
"rendering quality" does not change gpu to gpu. I hope you mean you were able to turn up quality settings and have a higher frame rate.
I mean literally its written right here. If you want to say it doesn't exist within the RTX line, I'd say you are right. But literally it's in the title, GTX 1080 to RTX 4070 S. And specifically in this case, going from that GPU to this GPU will change the rendering quality. You are trying awfully hard to come in and prove how much you know...and really you have just proven to be an ass.

The GTX 1080 cannot hit the same rendering. And its not limited by its ability to framerate, its limited by its access to feature sets. In this case DLSS.
Última edición por Marcothy; 6 JUN 2024 a las 20:46
Chesterrtm 6 JUN 2024 a las 20:51 
Publicado originalmente por Marcothy:
Needless to say, I've been on a 1080 GTX for a long time. Never really justified the spend on upgrading it as it still ran most games well enough maxed out or at least on High.

Just updated to a 4070 largely for this game. Holy smokes-night and day difference on even the rendered quality. Its insane
Grats man. I have a 3060ti and it still works great. Had a 1070 before and it held its own for around 6 years or so.
Marcothy 6 JUN 2024 a las 21:00 
Publicado originalmente por Chesterrtm:
Publicado originalmente por Marcothy:
Needless to say, I've been on a 1080 GTX for a long time. Never really justified the spend on upgrading it as it still ran most games well enough maxed out or at least on High.

Just updated to a 4070 largely for this game. Holy smokes-night and day difference on even the rendered quality. Its insane
Grats man. I have a 3060ti and it still works great. Had a 1070 before and it held its own for around 6 years or so.
Thanks - The bad thing is a 4070 S costs what I paid for a GTX 1080. Just cannot justify the costs of $1800 for a RTX 4090. Attitude used to be to go the higher end route for longevity. I've done this a long time with computers, I have the money to spend, I'd just throw up in my mouth over ego to have a 4090 over 4070S at over 3x the cost. Maybe I'd have the same eye opener as this, but I cannot imagine it. Just overkill on framerate for the most part would be my guess.
Weird Potato 6 JUN 2024 a las 23:18 
Publicado originalmente por Marcothy:
Publicado originalmente por Weird Potato:
LMAO!!
THAT'S JUST IT!!! I did no such thing! I REALLY don't know how to make my self any clearer.


Publicado originalmente por Weird Potato:
"rendering quality" does not change gpu to gpu. I hope you mean you were able to turn up quality settings and have a higher frame rate.
I mean literally its written right here. If you want to say it doesn't exist within the RTX line, I'd say you are right. But literally it's in the title, GTX 1080 to RTX 4070 S. And specifically in this case, going from that GPU to this GPU will change the rendering quality. You are trying awfully hard to come in and prove how much you know...and really you have just proven to be an ass.

The GTX 1080 cannot hit the same rendering. And its not limited by its ability to framerate, its limited by its access to feature sets. In this case DLSS.
We are going round and around lmao.
You keep pointing out the most brain dead common sense stuff like you're teaching me something.
K, here I will try my best to spell it out for you like you were 5. I'm starting to think you might actually be 5;
If you had a 1080 and you change to a 4070, and CHANGE NO QUALITY SETTINGS IN GAME, the " rendering quality" will be no different.
You implied otherwise. You do realize that right?

Unless you are incorrectly referring to frame rate as " rendering quality". Is that it?? I don't even anymore.
Última edición por Weird Potato; 6 JUN 2024 a las 23:41
Donaldo Trumpado 7 JUN 2024 a las 3:27 
Oh you guys are fighting
Marcothy 7 JUN 2024 a las 18:58 
Publicado originalmente por Weird Potato:
Publicado originalmente por Marcothy:



I mean literally its written right here. If you want to say it doesn't exist within the RTX line, I'd say you are right. But literally it's in the title, GTX 1080 to RTX 4070 S. And specifically in this case, going from that GPU to this GPU will change the rendering quality. You are trying awfully hard to come in and prove how much you know...and really you have just proven to be an ass.

The GTX 1080 cannot hit the same rendering. And its not limited by its ability to framerate, its limited by its access to feature sets. In this case DLSS.
We are going round and around lmao.
You keep pointing out the most brain dead common sense stuff like you're teaching me something.
K, here I will try my best to spell it out for you like you were 5. I'm starting to think you might actually be 5;
If you had a 1080 and you change to a 4070, and CHANGE NO QUALITY SETTINGS IN GAME, the " rendering quality" will be no different.
You implied otherwise. You do realize that right?

Unless you are incorrectly referring to frame rate as " rendering quality". Is that it?? I don't even anymore.
Wait-I thought you were done "with me" but here you go again for the last word.

Nowhere in my original post did it say no settings were changed. For the most part both cards were run at the high end, and I noted specifically what settings were changed. You came in with a huge ASSumption. Which we know what happens when people ASSume.

I've clarified, I've explained. I've accepted what responsibility I can for what at best is ambiguity.

Your point-"going from 1 GPU to another doesn't improve quality of render". It dismisses everything that exists between a GTX class and an RTX class-which are 2 huge features that affect rendering ability. Yes, the bump improves framerate as well as allowing for more quality, only texture quality wasn't CHANGED.

What is different is getting into the feature set of DLSS largely, along with HDR. Along with increased framerate that allow boosts to texture filtering thanks to better framerate (which framerate does zero to improve textures)-THE GAME IS NOTICEABLY DIFFERENT.

If you have 200+ Hours on a GTX card running this game at max allowable, and then jumped to a 4K RTX of some sort and want to comment how its different-by all means share what you can.

But you are nothing but a nerd trying to show you know more than others when you largely made a big ass assumption, and then can't walk away from it. Have at it dude. I know what I see with my own eyes. AND key point was if you are on a GTX card and debate an upgrade to the 4th gen RTX-IT IS DAMN WELL WORTH IT.
Donaldo Trumpado 7 JUN 2024 a las 19:20 
Publicado originalmente por Marcothy:
Publicado originalmente por Weird Potato:
We are going round and around lmao.
You keep pointing out the most brain dead common sense stuff like you're teaching me something.
K, here I will try my best to spell it out for you like you were 5. I'm starting to think you might actually be 5;
If you had a 1080 and you change to a 4070, and CHANGE NO QUALITY SETTINGS IN GAME, the " rendering quality" will be no different.
You implied otherwise. You do realize that right?

Unless you are incorrectly referring to frame rate as " rendering quality". Is that it?? I don't even anymore.
Wait-I thought you were done "with me" but here you go again for the last word.

Nowhere in my original post did it say no settings were changed. For the most part both cards were run at the high end, and I noted specifically what settings were changed. You came in with a huge ASSumption. Which we know what happens when people ASSume.

I've clarified, I've explained. I've accepted what responsibility I can for what at best is ambiguity.

Your point-"going from 1 GPU to another doesn't improve quality of render". It dismisses everything that exists between a GTX class and an RTX class-which are 2 huge features that affect rendering ability. Yes, the bump improves framerate as well as allowing for more quality, only texture quality wasn't CHANGED.

What is different is getting into the feature set of DLSS largely, along with HDR. Along with increased framerate that allow boosts to texture filtering thanks to better framerate (which framerate does zero to improve textures)-THE GAME IS NOTICEABLY DIFFERENT.

If you have 200+ Hours on a GTX card running this game at max allowable, and then jumped to a 4K RTX of some sort and want to comment how its different-by all means share what you can.

But you are nothing but a nerd trying to show you know more than others when you largely made a big ass assumption, and then can't walk away from it. Have at it dude. I know what I see with my own eyes. AND key point was if you are on a GTX card and debate an upgrade to the 4th gen RTX-IT IS DAMN WELL WORTH IT.
Sorry that happened. Or, like happy for you? I'm not reading all that.
< >
Mostrando 16-30 de 50 comentarios
Por página: 1530 50

Publicado el: 5 JUN 2024 a las 10:18
Mensajes: 50