Expeditions: Samurai

Expeditions: Samurai

View Stats:
 This topic has been pinned, so it's probably important
Jonas  [developer]
3
2
2
Jun 11 @ 5:07am
About our art direction
Hello everyone! We've been following discussions since our announcement, and it's clear that you have some thoughts on the way our characters look in Expeditions: Samurai.

First, let me assure you that we're not done working on this aspect of the game. More improvements will be made to facial expressions, lighting, and poses of the characters from now until our Early Access release, and we will continue to improve textures, models, and animations during Early Access. Being able to adjust and improve things based on feedback is the whole point of Early Access in the first place!

One thing I would like to explain right off the bat is that the characters you see in dialogue in Expeditions: Samurai are not static images as they were in previous Expeditions games. This time they are the characters' actual 3D models. It has been a consistent criticism of Expeditions that your character creation choices were not reflected in the portraits, and that's a major reason why we decided to make this change. Now, with your actual 3D character appearing close-up in dialogue, we've put lots of work into adding more character creation choices, such as eye colour, facial details (make-up, scarring, dirt), tattoos, and lots of beard options for the men. You can even customise your character's height.

There are more advantages than just seeing your real character, though; the characters' expressions now change dynamically to match the emotion of the dialogue, and all characters will show up in the actual outfit you give them, so if you put on a priest's robe, you will see your character dressed as such in dialogue. The advantage I'm personally most excited about is that every character now shows up in dialogue. Many characters in Rome or Viking were too insignificant to merit a portrait, and instead showed up as immersion-breaking silhouettes; those are now a thing of the past.

From digging into your reactions and talking to you on Discord, a recurring criticism is the "dead-eyed" or expressionless look of the characters. Not to worry, we're under no illusions that those are good enough to ship! The character poses you currently see in the trailer and in screenshots are placeholders that will be refined even before the Early Access release, including adding more natural and expressive poses.

As mentioned, the lighting will also be improved, and our art department is already in the process of going over the textures to bring them up to scratch. As we've refined the new art direction over the past year or so, we've improved on our character textures in many ways. Now we just have to make sure the assets we made to begin with are brought up to the level we've since achieved. This process of updating textures and adding more details to them will continue during Early Access.

Overall I'm very proud of the art direction we've landed on. Our levels are more readable, our textures less noisy, and we're still making use of all the bells and whistles of the Unreal Engine. When I look back on Conquistador and Viking, as much as I love the art in those games, their realistic style now looks very dated. We decided to go with a stylised art direction because we believe it will age better.

On a final note, if you worry that our pivot towards stylisation might indicate a loss of some depth or complexity in the narrative, I assure you that your fears are unfounded. As the creative director of every Expeditions game, it has always been my narrative sensibilities that define the tone and complexity of our stories, and in that regard, nothing has changed: Samurai is every bit as political, conflict-filled, and sometimes harrowing as any of its predecessors.

We're really excited to share more information about the story we've written over the next few weeks.

Regards,
Jonas
< >
Showing 1-15 of 90 comments
Hello Jonas,

The art style is expressive and makes it easier to distinguish between characters on the smaller screens, such as Steam Deck. I am strongly in favour of this style, as opposed to the grey-on-grey of the 00's shooters - the "realistic" "high-fidelity" illegible mess makes the use of accessibility options (e.g., character highlights) mandatory in order to see anything.

Knowing that the character model and the portrait now will match (which was not an option in Rome at all) is welcome as well.

I also hope to see more approachable system requirements (closer to Vikings than Rome) and I look forward to the game.
Realistic style is not dated at all and looks way better than fortnite-like 3D models.
Samurai, the warrior cast, looks unmanly and childish.
I understand your reasoning for changes and hopefully it will improve throu EA to acceptable levels, but I won't participate as it's way too ugly for me to play for now.
I hope new game won't disappoint.
Originally posted by Jonas:
all the bells and whistles of the Unreal Engine
Does this include infamous lumen and nanite thing, making older PC users to skip UE5 games? :philosophizing:
Jun 11 @ 8:57am 
Originally posted by PVA:
Does this include infamous lumen and nanite thing, making older PC users to skip UE5 games? :philosophizing:
Please see the minimum and recommended specs on our Steam store page to find out if your computer will be able to run Expeditions: Samurai :)
For me it's not only the cartoonish characters but the overall artstyle which doesn't suit your games. It's too Fortnite, too League of Legends, too Overwatch, too Disney+. Realistic style isn't dated and Expeditions Rome still looks fine today.

Don't sugoarcoat this cartoonish artstyle with "we have animated characters and lots of character customization options". Your game can have so many depth and options and this and that but with this artstyle you scare away many of your fans.
Originally posted by Jonas:
Please see the minimum and recommended specs on our Steam store page to find out if your computer will be able to run Expeditions: Samurai :)
Those looks good for me. It's either UE4 then or some genius coders at CFC.
IMO the formula of Expeditions Rome was GREAT
And I'm waiting since years the same patern as Expeditions Rome for another era/localization

Why are you waisting time and ressources for something people don't care, Expeditions Rome is a top rated game, just do the same don't do some useless changes
Coherence between your character's look in-game and in-portrait, as well as every character having their own portrait are both appreciable features. I can certainly understand using the in-game model for everything, it is an efficient solution.

Then again, thinking about Rome, the only characters I remember are the party members and a few others (Cleopatra, Cicero, a couple of bad guys...). Which makes sense: not every character in the game is important to the point of deserving their own art. I don't think giving Generic Tutorial Ally no.6 a portrait really makes him more memorable. Many contemporary cRPG makers follow the same or similar reasoning, too: Owlcat only has portraits for the most important characters and either flat backgrounds or generic ones for the others, as does Iron Tower.

Fewer, high-quality, handmade portraits add much more to the immersion than everyone having the same, generic style, even if that actually corresponds to their in-game look.

And I'm afraid I'm still not sold on the cartoony art style at all. It feels generic, cheap and unsuitable for the drama and gravity of that historical period. The added value it gives by harmonizing the game's visuals is entirely negated by the style itself being the wrong one for the subject matter.

I hope that the improvements made over the course of the development will be such that they will compensate for the shortcomings of the art style, because I don't know if I will be able to enjoy the game otherwise.
Originally posted by Sugandhalaya:
For me it's not only the cartoonish characters but the overall artstyle which doesn't suit your games. It's too Fortnite, too League of Legends, too Overwatch, too Disney+. Realistic style isn't dated and Expeditions Rome still looks fine today.

Don't sugoarcoat this cartoonish artstyle with "we have animated characters and lots of character customization options". Your game can have so many depth and options and this and that but with this artstyle you scare away many of your fans.
I dont think the artstyle isnt going to make the game look childish or fortnite like, its like the man said going to benefit alot of things, this seriers never really focussed on graphics( and for good reasons) hence they werent super good looking, and aged very quickly.

For games where graphics have a lower priority alot of developers decide to go with cartoonish artstyle.

But it wont hinder the experience, look at this Game of Thrones game for example, the artstyle is also cartoonish but it dosnet make it any less serious and gory:
steampowered.com/app/330840/Game_of_Thrones__A_Telltale_Games_Series/
This is a what? A ten-year-old franchise at this point? We’ve had a fairly consistent art direction since the first game—with some minor changes here and there, sure, but always staying strictly within the quadrant of realism to semi-realism. This new art direction, however, goes into a completely different, unprompted direction; one that definitely should have gotten some fan feedback before you went all-in.

I'm not saying the game is going to be bad because of this single factor, but it will undoubtedly exacerbate any additional... grievances that may arise during this game's development cycle in Early Access. I don't know if it's too late to pivot at this point—I have zero experience in the game industry, so I can only provide a customer's perspective—but this genuinely lets down and alienates your core audience, in my opinion.

By trading our established, grounded aesthetic for something so jarringly stylized, you are risking the very identity of the franchise. When a community is already fractured over the visual foundation before Early Access even launches, any balancing issues, bugs, or gameplay hiccups down the line will be magnified tenfold.
I am surprised you moved from a very authentic art style in Rome to this odd 3rd modelling concept. It looks very cheap and not on brand with previous games - basically, ruins the aesthetic entirely. Personally, I don't think any adjustments to lighting and so forth will be able to fix this particular art style. I'll probably pass on the game if this doesn't change.
"Overall I'm very proud of the art direction we've landed on".
Ok, i see... They are not gonna change the artstyle...
It is truly that the gameplay matters the most. But dont be mistaken - first you LOOK at the game, then you deside to buy or not to buy. And what i see i dont like.
Good luck.
Guys we stepped into ai-art era, where you sometimes can't tell result of long expensive work from free instant one. At least with 3d models you may be sure it's a real thing )

I mean look at the new HoMM: Olden Era. Authors claim that all portraits are all handmade and the players insist that most of them are generated :HappyMask:
I think the main issue is that you guys have trouble getting on with change and want everything to be exactly the same as it always was. And now you say you wont play your favourite franchise, because the pictures changed. And I am guessing alot of you would previously say that you love these games because they focus on whats important not graphics xD Thats quite ironic ;p Well now its time you focus on what is important ;p
Originally posted by PIT_DEFENDER:
I think the main issue is that you guys have trouble getting on with change and want everything to be exactly the same as it always was. And now you say you wont play your favourite franchise, because the pictures changed. And I am guessing alot of you would previously say that you love these games because they focus on whats important not graphics xD Thats quite ironic ;p Well now its time you focus on what is important ;p


I think you don't really get the point of the criticism. It's not about that we want more of the same, it's that the overall artstyle (not only the characters) doesn't fit and it scares the people away. Yes, you don't crae but most people do and when so many people are telling the developers that this artstyle will prevent them from buying the game, this should be a warning signal that you can't continue with the "we like our artstyle, you all get it wrong" replies.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 90 comments
Per page: 1530 50