Question about the story (Spoilers)

[Sweet Tea]

So did Lilli actually kill all those people? Because her reaction of knowing about their deaths kind of made it not seem so. Or were all of those people actually not even real?

[Futaleufu]

Yes, she did. In some cases it was accidental, in some cases, like the girl in the swing or the kid in the heater, very direct.

She reacted that way because she put a coat of pink paint over the bodies.

[Sweet Tea]

Ahh okay. I thought that might be the case, but I wasn't entirely sure. Thanks.

[Rumpelcrutchskin]

She killed entire school, she just blocked it out in her mind with potato gnomes and pink paint. Later in the roleplay game she figured it out hence the meltdown.
Only imaginary characters that existed only in her head were Edna and Garret.

[Sweet Tea]

Garret was a pretty cool character. Maybe in the future they could do a spinoff with him.

[Futaleufu]

Unlikely since he never existed.

[Sweet Tea]

Not if she made him off an image of someone who is real.

[BiggerBoss]

The whole problem with that is that we'll never know if they were never really there, or if Marcel was just effing with Lilli's already twisted psyche for his own gain.

[Milky milkshake]

=￣ω￣=

[steelcoresoviet]

Well, since someone kindly bumped this anyway...

Marcel's explanation doesn't entirely pass the smell test. The actual artifacts of Edna's existence are too hard to wave away. Also note how out of character the apparitions in the last scene are. Would the real Edna really be against murdering the doc?

My interpretation is, Edna and Garret probably exist, but Lilli's view of reality gets more warped the more time she spends in dreamspace.

[GERTY]

doodie buttkiss

[Sweet Tea]

Originally posted by steelcoresoviet:

Well, since someone kindly bumped this anyway...

My interpretation is, Edna and Garret probably exist, but Lilli's view of reality gets more warped the more time she spends in dreamspace.

Yeah I think they might be real people that she has brought into her own world. Cause how else could a little kid be aware of so many things? Mostly Garret. I could buy Edna being made up, but Garret it's a bit too out of the question.

[Futaleufu]

Most likely Lilli's version of Edna is one made up after reading the papers report of her escape. Notice how younger this Edna is compared to the one in the first game.