Keeping Yrliet as dogmatic

[BrotherG]

I can justify keeping Jae as a dogmatic zealot, but how would you justify not shooting the elf on sight ?

[Von Herbst]

On the same way you justify mutants and the heretics from mars; Shes a necessary evil in your mission against the enemies of mankind.

[Taifun_Vash]

You could see her as the lesser evil.

Jae is worse then Yrliet, one is a lone xenos the other trades with them and brings xeno artifacts to humans, some that can be really dangerous.
But Jae can be converted and the only good xeno is a dead xeno, for dogmatic.

[Daidre]

True dogmatic would never keep her around. There are like three [dogmatic] options to kill Yrliet - so no special exception in "Kill xenos, heretic and mutant" for that particular xenos.

She was a willing participant in planet-wide xeno-conspiracy meant to sabotage and destroy human colony. That is a death sentence for any puritan.

[Green Knight]

Originally posted by BrotherG:

I can justify keeping Jae as a dogmatic zealot, but how would you justify not shooting the elf on sight ?

First playthrough:

I refused to taker her in.

Then she's with the rebel/eldar portal party, proving she's a vile xenos AND a vile traitor, so she died. Had Argenta run up to her and unload.

The Emperor doesn't just protect - he smites.

Great stuff!

[BrotherG]

Originally posted by Green Knight:

Originally posted by BrotherG:

I can justify keeping Jae as a dogmatic zealot, but how would you justify not shooting the elf on sight ?

First playthrough:

I refused to taker her in.

Then she's with the rebel/eldar portal party, proving she's a vile xenos AND a vile traitor, so she died. Had Argenta run up to her and unload.

The Emperor doesn't just protect - he smites.

Great stuff!

You conviced me. I shall do that too.

[Green Knight]

Suffer not the Xenos to live!

[~ Fabulous ~]

Malcador have pet elf that he keep cloning to be his friend.

[hilburnashua]

Who doesn't want their own pet Space Elf?

[oddball]

Originally posted by BrotherG:

I can justify keeping Jae as a dogmatic zealot, but how would you justify not shooting the elf on sight ?

It's simple: I shot the elf on sight. Twice, because the first time I apparently missed. Not so much the second time.

[Trombe!]

Why would you keep a xeno scum on board of your sacred ship outside of interrogation cell in the first place?

[Toaster Maximus]

No real reason for a zealot to keep a xenos around once they serve their purpose once she leads you to the others finish the job and put her down

[Snuggles]

It's not Heresy if you say "For the Emperor!" first. Simple as.

[Dragon Master]

She can be a sanctioned xenos. There is precedent of Rogue Traders having Xenos in their retinue. She clearly hates chaos and wants to fight it and just helped kill her own people, whom she was actively working for until she realized Slannesh was involved and her people were helping a chaos god so they started trying to kill her.

Not saying the dogmatic rogue trader should 100% trust her but she is useful.

[LArc7thHeaven]

You can either be rational dogmatic like Bobby G and Cawl or stupid dogmatic like everyone else in the imperium OR Chaos "dogmatic" like calcazar. It's your choice