[Spoilers] "UNDERWORLD" Inheritance quest outrage

[Godsworn]

How dare they make killing the pirates and giving the little girl the inheritance mutually exclusive.
- When they're all dead and you press 'there's still the matter of the inheritance', the option is no longer present.

They really have the gall to make you listen to how these guys happily slaughter innocents on the daily, and make you say 'it's all in the past, there's no need for bloodshed' to get to the iconoclast option, as if these career criminals were regret-filled retired geezers.
They ain't.

[=DeadShot=]

Look at your ship was run before. In slavery conditions for most of the crew. Look at servitors. Also depending how you introduced you can slaughter most of the guys and still give the inheritance to the girl or servitor(Fixellio)

[REhorror]

You are killing her damn father. What do you think?

Anyway, I got the inheritance.

[Godsworn]

Originally posted by =DeadShot=:

Look at your ship was run before. In slavery conditions for most of the crew. Look at servitors. Also depending how you introduced you can slaughter most of the guys and still give the inheritance to the girl or servitor(Fixellio)

I announced my arrival so I guess I don't have the option then?
As my original post states, I am currently faced with-
If you give it to the girl, the servitor is also taken care of by the priest.
However if you kill the pirates, only the servitor is taken care of.
[Issue being, they should not be mutually exclusive. I should have the option to punish the pirates for what they did to the woman and give the inheritance to the grand-daughter.]

Originally posted by REhorror:

You are killing her damn father. What do you think?
Anyway, I got the inheritance.

If you choose to kill them you get the option to leave the girl and her father out of it because her father isn't actually a pirate.

[REhorror]

Originally posted by Godsworn:

Originally posted by =DeadShot=:

Look at your ship was run before. In slavery conditions for most of the crew. Look at servitors. Also depending how you introduced you can slaughter most of the guys and still give the inheritance to the girl or servitor(Fixellio)

I announced my arrival so I guess I don't have the option then? Unaware that incognito users get to have their cake and eat it too as you suggest?

Originally posted by REhorror:

You are killing her damn father. What do you think?
Anyway, I got the inheritance.

If you choose to kill them you get the option to leave the girl and her father out of it because her father isn't actually a pirate.

Yes, the game even advises you to go icognito.

Anyway, you can kill the 1st mate, and then give the money to the girl with her father.

I still think it's a stupid thing to do because you give like millions of dorrars for a 12 year old girl. Anyway, it probably has a nice ending slide but I'm not taking any chances.

[Harukage]

Her father is no less ♥♥♥♥ then anyone around. The only person caring about girl is Chaplain, who is also a damn former pirate as well as former captains executioner. However he really co care about the girl, and is poroper Drusian who repents and seek ways to pay for his past deeds. The good ending is too give the girl inheritance and leave her with Chaplain who will rise her into a famous merchant in the epilogue.

[Godsworn]

Originally posted by Harukage:

Her father is no less ♥♥♥♥ then anyone around. The only person caring about girl is Chaplain, who is also a damn former pirate as well as former captains executioner. However he really co care about the girl, and is poroper Drusian who repents and seek ways to pay for his past deeds. The good ending is too give the girl inheritance and leave her with Chaplain who will rise her into a famous merchant in the epilogue.

Yes, I want to do this. I also want to kill the pirates though. It doesn't feel right hearing them make light of what they did to the Repentance & its crew and disregarding it. Especially since 'its in the past' is a lie- the chaplin is the only one who's retired, unless the first mate and his crew are stopped what happened to the servitor woman is only going to continue.

Someone said that you can get the good ending and kill the pirates if you arrive incognito, although I'm still not certain that is the case, he could have just been confused as to what I was trying to accomplish.

[corisai]

Originally posted by Godsworn:

If you choose to kill them you get the option to leave the girl and her father out of it because her father isn't actually a pirate.

Let me say that her father is absolutely NOT better then a pirate. You will see why if go for that achievement ;)

[corisai]

Originally posted by Harukage:

The good ending is too give the girl inheritance and leave her with Chaplain who will rise her into a famous merchant in the epilogue.

Or killing the pirates for me.

We don't know the future and father of that girl is already @#$% jerk so I have 0 trust to that family.

[Godsworn]

Originally posted by corisai:

Originally posted by Godsworn:

If you choose to kill them you get the option to leave the girl and her father out of it because her father isn't actually a pirate.

Let me say that her father is absolutely NOT better then a pirate. You will see why if go for that achievement ;)

Be that as it may I consider it a positive, because he likely won't hurt his little girl if she doesn't suddenly inherit a bajillion dollars. I suspect a lot of people we consider 'good' would kill you if it would set them up as royalty for life.

[REhorror]

Originally posted by Godsworn:

Originally posted by Harukage:

Her father is no less ♥♥♥♥ then anyone around. The only person caring about girl is Chaplain, who is also a damn former pirate as well as former captains executioner. However he really co care about the girl, and is poroper Drusian who repents and seek ways to pay for his past deeds. The good ending is too give the girl inheritance and leave her with Chaplain who will rise her into a famous merchant in the epilogue.

Yes, I want to do this. I also want to kill the pirates though. It doesn't feel right hearing them make light of what they did to the Repentance & its crew and disregarding it. Especially since 'its in the past' is a lie- the chaplin is the only one who's retired, unless the first mate and his crew are stopped what happened to the servitor woman is only going to continue.

Someone said that you can get the good ending and kill the pirates if you arrive incognito, although I'm still not certain that is the case, he could have just been confused as to what I was trying to accomplish.

If you kill the pirates, that include her father (don't care what his current occupation is, he still tries to rob and kill you), that means the girl will just leave in shock.
To get the actual good ending, you need to play icognito and don't play pretend.

I still think the good ending is too good, so I choose the money/profit path.

[corisai]

Originally posted by Godsworn:

Be that as it may I consider it a positive, because he likely won't hurt his little girl if she doesn't suddenly inherit a bajillion dollars. I suspect a lot of people we consider 'good' would kill you if it set them up for life.

Except he did it instantly and even in front of countless witness. I would say such person is rotten to core and should be already violent-crazy.

[Godsworn]

Originally posted by REhorror:

Originally posted by Godsworn:

Yes, I want to do this. I also want to kill the pirates though. It doesn't feel right hearing them make light of what they did to the Repentance & its crew and disregarding it. Especially since 'its in the past' is a lie- the chaplin is the only one who's retired, unless the first mate and his crew are stopped what happened to the servitor woman is only going to continue.

Someone said that you can get the good ending and kill the pirates if you arrive incognito, although I'm still not certain that is the case, he could have just been confused as to what I was trying to accomplish.

If you kill the pirates, that include her father (don't care what his current occupation is, he still tries to rob and kill you), that means the girl will just leave in shock.
To get the actual good ending, you need to play icognito and don't play pretend.

I still think the good ending is too good, so I choose the money/profit path.

When you say he tries to rob and kill you- you're referring to a separate event encountered after the fight? I sent him and his daughter away without issue when the killing started. Are you certain he comes back at a later point to try and rob me?

[REhorror]

Originally posted by Godsworn:

Originally posted by REhorror:

If you kill the pirates, that include her father (don't care what his current occupation is, he still tries to rob and kill you), that means the girl will just leave in shock.
To get the actual good ending, you need to play icognito and don't play pretend.

I still think the good ending is too good, so I choose the money/profit path.

When you say he tries to rob and kill you- you're referring to a separate event encountered after the fight?

Nope, it's about the part when you rejoin the party.
I play the igconity and pretend Fillio part.

Oh wait, before that party already has poisoned wine anyway, they want to kill each other to get the inheritance.

[Godsworn]

Originally posted by REhorror:

Originally posted by Godsworn:

When you say he tries to rob and kill you- you're referring to a separate event encountered after the fight?

Nope, it's about the part when you rejoin the party.
I play the igconity and pretend Fillio part.

Oh wait, before that party already has poisoned wine anyway, they want to kill each other to get the inheritance.

Ah it sounds like an incognito thing then. The quest has concluded and he is alive for me. Thanks for clarifying, was worried there.

[REhorror]

Originally posted by Godsworn:

Originally posted by REhorror:

Nope, it's about the part when you rejoin the party.
I play the igconity and pretend Fillio part.

Oh wait, before that party already has poisoned wine anyway, they want to kill each other to get the inheritance.

Ah it sounds like an incognito thing then. The quest has concluded and he is alive for me. Thanks for clarifying, was worried there.

You can absolutely leave him alive in Icognito too, this is what I did, killing the first m8 but leave the father alive.