You really shouldn't have the same price

[Eightball]

As Baldur's Gate. Seriously. This isn't even comparable yet you are asking ALMOST the same price. But the level of quality and polish is not even remotely comparable.

I tried not to compare this game to BG3, to give it a chance and take it for what it is, but it definitely is no BG3 and you should not be charging the same price as a clearly superior product.

This game is £25 at best. Not £45. You might want to spend some of that undeserved profits on voice actors and level designers.

And this is coming from a hardcore 40k fanboi, i'm heavily biased to enjoy 40k games.

Edit: I should be grateful it's not the £59.99 that POS game Starfield wants. I wouldn't touch that one with someone elses. But I still know which of these 3 games i'd tell people to buy.

[Eightball]

Origineel geplaatst door (-STAR-) GrugIsRock:

Origineel geplaatst door Eightball:

For what? Not being intelligent enough to understand the English language? Not sure that one is reportable i'm afraid as much as i'd like to report stupidity.

yawn. Is this truly your best?

Not really, i'd need someone with a few brain cells they can skip around to bring that out in me. You are easy mode.

[GrugIsRock]

Origineel geplaatst door Summersong:

Origineel geplaatst door XartaX:

Cope harder, son.

Says the guy trying to drag BG3 on characters and writing. You need to stop getting your opinions from 4chan, your midwit taste is showing when you mald.

BG3 writing was awful tho. The plot after act 1 falls off hard. The only interesting characters is the fish and Minthara.

[Eightball]

Origineel geplaatst door ender_void:

Origineel geplaatst door Eightball:

But you can't say this game is the same value as BG3.

Why? BG3 has only better graphics, the writing and gameplay is much better in Rogue Trader.

BG3 is objectively better in every way. Google objectively before you respond because apparently most people have no idea what it means. There are ways to objectively measure this, and BG3 wins hands down every time.

If the game does not want objectively measured against BG3, then don't charge the same price. Simple as.

[Summersong]

Origineel geplaatst door XartaX:

Origineel geplaatst door Summersong:

Says the guy trying to drag BG3 on characters and writing. You need to stop getting your opinions from 4chan, your midwit taste is showing when you mald.

Yeah he does. Because the characters and writing in BG3 is atrocious. It's really, really bad.

They're both great. Sorry you react to games based on trying to be nonconformist.

[Summersong]

Origineel geplaatst door (-STAR-) GrugIsRock:

Origineel geplaatst door Summersong:

Says the guy trying to drag BG3 on characters and writing. You need to stop getting your opinions from 4chan, your midwit taste is showing when you mald.

BG3 writing was awful tho. The plot after act 1 falls off hard. The only interesting characters is the fish and Minthara.

Sounds like you just ran out of brainpower after the simple bits.

[GrugIsRock]

Origineel geplaatst door Eightball:

Origineel geplaatst door ender_void:

Why? BG3 has only better graphics, the writing and gameplay is much better in Rogue Trader.

BG3 is objectively better in every way. Google objectively before you respond because apparently most people have no idea what it means. There are measures to objectively measure this, and BG3 wins hands down every time.

Thankfully, this is untrue. Rouge trader has more soul than BG3.

[Eightball]

Origineel geplaatst door Summersong:

Origineel geplaatst door XartaX:

Yeah he does. Because the characters and writing in BG3 is atrocious. It's really, really bad.

They're both great. Sorry you react to games based on trying to be nonconformist.

I agree both games can be great in their own ways, but they are objectively not the same value and should not be the same price is my problem, personally. I'm the OP and not once have I said this game is 'bad' by any metric, my problem comes from the fact they are both basically charging the same price, but one has objectively massively more value than the other.

[Eightball]

Origineel geplaatst door (-STAR-) GrugIsRock:

Origineel geplaatst door Eightball:

BG3 is objectively better in every way. Google objectively before you respond because apparently most people have no idea what it means. There are measures to objectively measure this, and BG3 wins hands down every time.

Thankfully, this is untrue. Rouge trader has more soul than BG3.

Mate you need a dictionary to learn what objectively means. You clearly don't understand. I'd feel bad even insulting someone with this low of an IQ, it's like taking candy from a baby.

[GrugIsRock]

Origineel geplaatst door Summersong:

Origineel geplaatst door (-STAR-) GrugIsRock:

BG3 writing was awful tho. The plot after act 1 falls off hard. The only interesting characters is the fish and Minthara.

Sounds like you just ran out of brainpower after the simple bits.

act 3 was legit unfinished plot wise. You cant possibly defend it on release.

[ender_void]

Origineel geplaatst door Eightball:

Origineel geplaatst door ender_void:

Why? BG3 has only better graphics, the writing and gameplay is much better in Rogue Trader.

BG3 is objectively better in every way. Google objectively before you respond because apparently most people have no idea what it means. There are ways to objectively measure this, and BG3 wins hands down every time.

If the game does not want objectively measured against BG3, then don't charge the same price. Simple as.

Thats not how a market and prices work. A product doesnt have to be objectively better to be be able to ask a higher/ the same price.
And then i'm still missing arguments why BG3 is objectively better.

[GrugIsRock]

Origineel geplaatst door ender_void:

Origineel geplaatst door Eightball:

But you can't say this game is the same value as BG3.

Why? BG3 has only better graphics, the writing and gameplay is much better in Rogue Trader.

Origineel geplaatst door XartaX:

Origineel geplaatst door Summersong:

Says the guy trying to drag BG3 on characters and writing. You need to stop getting your opinions from 4chan, your midwit taste is showing when you mald.

Yeah he does. Because the characters and writing in BG3 is atrocious. It's really, really bad.

watch out guys, hes going to report you now.

[GrugIsRock]

Origineel geplaatst door ender_void:

Origineel geplaatst door Eightball:

BG3 is objectively better in every way. Google objectively before you respond because apparently most people have no idea what it means. There are ways to objectively measure this, and BG3 wins hands down every time.

If the game does not want objectively measured against BG3, then don't charge the same price. Simple as.

Thats not how a market and prices work. A product doesnt have to be objectively better to be be able to ask a higher/ the same price.
And then i'm still missing arguments why BG3 is objectively better.

BG3 is better because of le bear sex, and the shadowcuck with halsin.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uog9atFDdfY

[XartaX]

Origineel geplaatst door Summersong:

Origineel geplaatst door XartaX:

Yeah he does. Because the characters and writing in BG3 is atrocious. It's really, really bad.

They're both great. Sorry you react to games based on trying to be nonconformist.

Nope, they are incredibly bad. If you think they are good you are automatically disqualified from having any of your opinions on the matter of character & writing taken seriously.

[XartaX]

Origineel geplaatst door (-STAR-) GrugIsRock:

Origineel geplaatst door ender_void:

Why? BG3 has only better graphics, the writing and gameplay is much better in Rogue Trader.

Origineel geplaatst door XartaX:

Yeah he does. Because the characters and writing in BG3 is atrocious. It's really, really bad.

watch out guys, hes going to report you now.

Thanks for reminding me, he has actually posted things that are banworthy :)

[Geist]

Eh. I know which game I like better. It's not even a fair comparison really.