Ending? SPOILERS!!!

[Vurado88]

I dont get it i beat Nyx and after all that Aigis says she will always be with main character and protect him and then he dies in her legs while others run to roof to meet them o.O ?
Why did he died ? And how come Aigis can cry since she is not human ?

[VavTenZ]

Originally posted by Vakula:

Great, they kept the same ending. Hope they at least change the answer dlc to be more meaningful. Answer was an abysmal grind, leading to a terrible, ♥♥♥♥♥♥ ending worse than the main game.

The fact that they did not change anything in remake, i think they will keep the answer as the same.

[Mescalite]

the journey's ending wasnt controversal as the answers one,
so we can hope they change it a bit

[mdesaleah]

Originally posted by VavTenZ:

Originally posted by Vakula:

Great, they kept the same ending. Hope they at least change the answer dlc to be more meaningful. Answer was an abysmal grind, leading to a terrible, ♥♥♥♥♥♥ ending worse than the main game.

The fact that they did not change anything in remake, i think they will keep the answer as the same.

Good.

The Answer's ending was fine. The only real big issue there is that they wanted to have the team fight each other at some point, but they also split the team into doubles that don't really make sense.

Give a reason for one of them to side with Yukari too and you've fixed its big issue.

But the ending itself leaving the main character as a door that isn't revived instantly makes way more sense. Reviving him is what would actually ruin the point of 3.

[Vakula]

Originally posted by mdesaleah:

Originally posted by VavTenZ:

The fact that they did not change anything in remake, i think they will keep the answer as the same.

Good.

The Answer's ending was fine. The only real big issue there is that they wanted to have the team fight each other at some point, but they also split the team into doubles that don't really make sense.

Give a reason for one of them to side with Yukari too and you've fixed its big issue.

But the ending itself leaving the main character as a door that isn't revived instantly makes way more sense. Reviving him is what would actually ruin the point of 3.

The answer basically makes light of the sacrifice of the protag, cuz he could have just fought Erebus, who is responsible for summoning Nyx to bring about the end of the world. There was no reason for him to become a seal/door. So in essence he has no reason to die and sacrifice himself. Goody... Now he is just a stupid door, but everyone else gets to live happily ever after, especially the emo robot girl.

[Yürei]

Originally posted by Vakula:

Originally posted by mdesaleah:

Good.

The Answer's ending was fine. The only real big issue there is that they wanted to have the team fight each other at some point, but they also split the team into doubles that don't really make sense.

Give a reason for one of them to side with Yukari too and you've fixed its big issue.

But the ending itself leaving the main character as a door that isn't revived instantly makes way more sense. Reviving him is what would actually ruin the point of 3.

The answer basically makes light of the sacrifice of the protag, cuz he could have just fought Erebus, who is responsible for summoning Nyx to bring about the end of the world. There was no reason for him to become a seal/door. So in essence he has no reason to die and sacrifice himself. Goody... Now he is just a stupid door, but everyone else gets to live happily ever after, especially the emo robot girl.

The problem with that is that Erebus always comes back. You literally can't kill him. Also, by the time we cast the great seal, Nyx was already about to end the world. Sealing her off was basically the only choice left.

[mdesaleah]

Originally posted by Yürei:

Originally posted by Vakula:

The answer basically makes light of the sacrifice of the protag, cuz he could have just fought Erebus, who is responsible for summoning Nyx to bring about the end of the world. There was no reason for him to become a seal/door. So in essence he has no reason to die and sacrifice himself. Goody... Now he is just a stupid door, but everyone else gets to live happily ever after, especially the emo robot girl.

The problem with that is that Erebus always comes back. You literally can't kill him. Also, by the time we cast the great seal, Nyx was already about to end the world. Sealing her off was basically the only choice left.

Yeah. You got it.

The whole point is that you can't just stop Erebus without stopping the collective desire for death. Which, thematically won't ever happen for the entire world and the main character will still forever be trapped there.

Its about moving on from him, not bringing him back. And its definitely not a case of "the main character could just have killed Erebus instead" since it can't die.

[Chopsteak]

People are probably going to get mad at this Hee-Ho for saying this, but there was a time where I wondered about at the end of The Answer Aigis took Makoto's place as the seal. That way she could finally protect him and let him live on.

[Yürei]

Originally posted by Chopsteak:

People are probably going to get mad at this Hee-Ho for saying this, but there was a time where I wondered about at the end of The Answer Aigis took Makoto's place as the seal. That way she could finally protect him and let him live on.

Frankly, I'm expecting Elizabeth to take that spot if they ever have the balls to free Makoto.

[Chopsteak]

Originally posted by Yürei:

Originally posted by Chopsteak:

People are probably going to get mad at this Hee-Ho for saying this, but there was a time where I wondered about at the end of The Answer Aigis took Makoto's place as the seal. That way she could finally protect him and let him live on.

Frankly, I'm expecting Elizabeth to take that spot if they ever have the balls to free Makoto.

I really thought about Aigis since she wanted to protect him and though out the story you saw her grow more and more human and she even gained the wild card abilities during The Answer. I really thought that could have been a possibility.

[Haruspex]

Originally posted by Yürei:

Originally posted by Chopsteak:

People are probably going to get mad at this Hee-Ho for saying this, but there was a time where I wondered about at the end of The Answer Aigis took Makoto's place as the seal. That way she could finally protect him and let him live on.

Frankly, I'm expecting Elizabeth to take that spot if they ever have the balls to free Makoto.

Maybe they'll just beat the ♥♥♥♥ out of Nyx with every protagonist and maybe a 6th one.

[Yürei]

Originally posted by Myla:

Originally posted by Yürei:

Frankly, I'm expecting Elizabeth to take that spot if they ever have the balls to free Makoto.

Maybe they'll just beat the ♥♥♥♥ out of Nyx with every protagonist and maybe a 6th one.

Probably not possible. Also Nyx isn't inherently evil.

[Haruspex]

Originally posted by Yürei:

Originally posted by Myla:

Maybe they'll just beat the ♥♥♥♥ out of Nyx with every protagonist and maybe a 6th one.

Probably not possible. Also Nyx isn't inherently evil.

I don't know why you felt the need to mention nyx isn't inherently evil lol. Not like that matters.

[Hauntings]

Originally posted by Arifufu:

he is a nyx seal now, i mean you did cast the great seal, didn't you?

He actually doesn't seal Nyx inside of himself. Basically humanity still longs for the fall and he basically serves as a barrier/block between Nyx and the will of humanity that wishes for death. It's kind of a weird Jesus metaphor I feel like... "we are still sinners but Jesus died for our sins so we don't have to die even if it's what we deserve" I mean the answer literally shows him up on a cross too.

[Yürei]

Originally posted by Myla:

Originally posted by Yürei:

Probably not possible. Also Nyx isn't inherently evil.

I don't know why you felt the need to mention nyx isn't inherently evil lol. Not like that matters.

Because there is no reason to fight Nyx at that point. The issue is Erebus and he can't be killed. If Erebus didn't exist, Nyx would literally do nothing.

[Haruspex]

Originally posted by Yürei:

Originally posted by Myla:

I don't know why you felt the need to mention nyx isn't inherently evil lol. Not like that matters.

Because there is no reason to fight Nyx at that point. The issue is Erebus and he can't be killed. If Erebus didn't exist, Nyx would literally do nothing.

Whole point of Persona is surpassing insurmountable odds heck if not the entire smt games. Can't believe you missed that.