Ranking the mainline games, which is the best?

[Lois Griffin]

I love them all but probably 5 for me

[Chopsteak]

Are we talking only Persona games or can we include SMT games with it?

[Ivas]

If we're talking Persona and not SMT then P5>P4>>P3

[Chopsteak]

If only Persona 3 is my favorite, if we include Persona and SMT together it is currently a tie between SMT 4 and Nocturne.

[Evangelion]

P3 > P4 > P5

I do think P5 is prob the best overall game, mainy because it's the largest in scale and has the best social sim aspect, but p3 is far superior with it's narrative and characters. P4 second, since P5's story and characters are somewhat underwhelming compared to 3 and 4, but at least 5 gets carried because it has the best dungeon and social sim format for the avg player

[Haruspex]

Best characters Perofella 3
Best secondary villain Perofella 4 with Adachi
Best consistent visuals Perofella 5

[Paradoxical]

I've always loved P4. Probably because original P4 was my first persona game. Love P5 and P3(now that I'm playing it, have a copy of FES unopened, never got around to it) but playing them isn't the same.

Probably an unpopular opinion considering how big P5.

[r1ver]

Definitely Persona 4. It has the best group of characters and is probably the most light-hearted game in the Persona series. This game is filled with funny and great moments that make it truly enjoyable.

In second place is Persona 5, which also has great characters. The story in Persona 5 is a bit more complex, and it boasts the best visuals and gameplay in the series. However, it lacks some of the charm that made Persona 4 so lovable.

I'll talk about Persona 3 Reload instead of the original version because they have the same story and characters, but the Reload version has nicer visuals and gameplay. However, the characters in Persona 3 are my least favorite. Most of them are uninteresting or lame, and the only one I really care about is Aigis, who is cute and funny at times.

[Ivas]

Цитата допису Paradoxical:

I've always loved P4. Probably because original P4 was my first persona game. Love P5 and P3(now that I'm playing it, have a copy of FES unopened, never got around to it) but playing them isn't the same.

Probably an unpopular opinion considering how big P5.

I think, most people consider their first Persona game the best Persona game

[mdesaleah]

4>5>2EP>2IS>3>1

5 does have much better combat and the dungeon designs are a big improvement. But it really falls in terms of story consistency and character. So I put 4 as overall higher for being more consistent.

[Haze]

They all have certain aspects better than the others... I think I'd like P2 most if it got the remake treatment that this game did. P3 has the better story, P4 has the most charm and P5 has the coolest art style imo

[LaSaia]

2, and the rest don't even come close.

[LouisKM124]

5 is the best overall. 3 has the best main story but most social links are very boring. 4 shares similar gameplay to 3, generic main story but with great characters.

[Aka must die]

P3 > P5 > P4

[Yürei]

P3>P5>P4

[Kustogg]

Persona 2 especially Eternal Punishment