Are Dungeons like P4G or P5R?

[Smokey The Bear]

I started this series with P4G and I was loving it until the later dungeons. They are all procedurally generated square rooms & hallways, which I was fine with until the backtracking parts where you run into a locked door and have to go back down 3 floors to find a key then go up 4 floors and need to backtrack again to find another key all the while enemies are respawning cause you changed floors multiple times. I never actually finished P4G cause I found that one aspect so annoying and tedious, even though I was really invested in the story & I wish I could've seen it to the end.

P5R is one of the best games of all time IMO but I don't want to dive into another Persona game if the dungeons are designed like P4G.

[Pastel TJ]

Essentially, P3 only has one major dungeon in the form of Tartarus, think of it like Mementos in that it has a randomized layout every time you visit

[MreE]

no they are randomly generated, more like p4 but even more blocky, you have to go floor by floor until you get to the end and the next month lets you go further. there is only 1 dungeon in the game and you do it across the entirety of the runtime

[Bender]

And outside of that one massive dungeon you periodically go to other locations to fight bosses.