Only track club, no swimming club?

[MESeele]

I mean, it's just cosmetic.

But why give you a choice of whether to join or not, when there is no alternative in this version...

[Crevan]

Yeah this sucks

[The Spoon Slapper]

No swimming club although the remake puts a big emphasis on water in the UI/menus? Very weird

[Pyro3000]

They also removed the Kendo club, Music, and Photography clubs along with their social links. As you've learned, Chariot is Track Team only now, and Fortune is Art Club only. All to simplify things and also to make it so the male party members could have social links.

You also can't break social links anymore, where you would permanently fail the quest and be unable to progress the S. Link further, and reversing social links basically has to be intentional now. Ignoring a social link that is still growing will just leave it where it is.

It's a shame.

[fender178]

Originally posted by Pyro3000:

They also removed the Kendo club, Music, and Photography clubs along with their social links. As you've learned, Chariot is Track Team only now, and Fortune is Art Club only. All to simplify things and also to make it so the male party members could have social links.

You also can't break social links anymore, where you would permanently fail the quest and be unable to progress the S. Link further, and reversing social links basically has to be intentional now. Ignoring a social link that is still growing will just leave it where it is.

It's a shame.

Yeah it sucks they removed the alternative Social Links for the different arcana however sacrifices had to be made due to the new content. Also I like the idea that you can ignore a Social link for a long time and nothing would happen to it because sometimes you forget all about a social link only for it to be reversed and had to do the steps to fix it unless you were doing a 100% run. P4 has this feature and all current main line Persona titles also had this feature including P3P. I wish they had where you could break the SL meaning you royally screwed up. I mean P4/P4G still has that feature. Not sure about P5 though.

[Pyro3000]

Originally posted by fender178:

Originally posted by Pyro3000:

They also removed the Kendo club, Music, and Photography clubs along with their social links. As you've learned, Chariot is Track Team only now, and Fortune is Art Club only. All to simplify things and also to make it so the male party members could have social links.

You also can't break social links anymore, where you would permanently fail the quest and be unable to progress the S. Link further, and reversing social links basically has to be intentional now. Ignoring a social link that is still growing will just leave it where it is.

It's a shame.

Yeah it sucks they removed the alternative Social Links for the different arcana however sacrifices had to be made due to the new content. Also I like the idea that you can ignore a Social link for a long time and nothing would happen to it because sometimes you forget all about a social link only for it to be reversed and had to do the steps to fix it unless you were doing a 100% run. P4 has this feature and all current main line Persona titles also had this feature including P3P. I wish they had where you could break the SL meaning you royally screwed up. I mean P4/P4G still has that feature. Not sure about P5 though.

Ruining social links and trying to balance them made for a good motivation to do NG+.

I at least wish they had kept the ability to choose between clubs, because I definitely enjoyed the Kendo link more than the Track one. I'd even take the girl from FeMC's sports club route over the track link. I know a lot of people like it, but I really prefer the others.