Which ending did you get for the first time in the Remake? ( SPOILERS thread)

[ViperMan]

I got ,, In water'', the same ending when i first finnished game in 2001. LOL i guess i didn't change my style for 23 years. But i think personally it is the most depresing ending for the first playthrough. 23 years ago it really shocked me, but i found it fitting, and this experience made SH2 one of my favourite games ever. What did you got, and did you like it?

[Zebedee]

Leave. Which also was a repeat from the OG first playthrough - I too have not developed in how I make decisions. D:

I'm not quite sure what to think about that ending - on one level, it's 'good', but on another I'm not really sure James does develop enough for me to justify it. The Maria ending is closer to how I see the 'what next...'.

[Hex: Cuse Me]

I got in water ending and had no damn clue what to do for it or not lol.

[Jellydrake]

I got Leave. I blamed the Man and used the Ripe Apple to mix the points up so I wouldn't earn enough for In Water or Maria endings.

In Water mostly involves letter James suffer when he is hurt. So if you heal up right away, you will usually get Leave. Blaming the man and using the rotten apple in their respective puzzles will also net you the In Water ending.

To get Maria's ending you have to not look at Mary's picture, NOT read the message above the jukebox that says James is going to the Bad Place, blame the woman in the one puzzle, visit her often in the Hospital and the Labyrinth, and use the ripe apple during another puzzle. Among other things but those are big point earners for that ending.

[Karma]

I wanted the Leave ending but got Maria ending

[Jellydrake]

Originally posted by Karma:

I wanted the Leave ending but got Maria ending

Did you blame the woman and use the ripe apple?

[Karma]

Originally posted by Jellydrake:

Originally posted by Karma:

I wanted the Leave ending but got Maria ending

Did you blame the woman and use the ripe apple?

Idk i picked the snake to blame on "Hard" difficulty puzzles i dont really remember what the puzzle even said and i used the ripe apple yeah.

Also listened to her dialogue helped her whenever in trouble i dont think she got any damage, opened doors and visited her on hospital and stuff

[BlueStinger]

Maria, it's the only one I got at the moment and I'm not long into ng+ for second playthrough. I do know for sure that I DID look at the photo and letter of Mary, right at the beginning of the game at the observatory.

[Karma]

Originally posted by BlueStinger:

Maria, it's the only one I got at the moment and I'm not long into ng+ for second playthrough. I do know for sure that I DID look at the photo and letter of Mary, right at the beginning of the game at the observatory.

Yeah i inspected everything too and couple times too probably.

[Kouki]

Leave ending