Jukebox puzzle logic: Why would I want to repair the vinyl?

[Uhtred son of Uhtred]

This is just a detail I was thinking about during the first few hours of gameplay—the jukebox puzzle. There’s a key inside the machine, but why would James want to fix the vinyl? I mean, I don’t remember reading anything that says there’s a key inside the machine, so the game isn’t giving me any motivation to solve it.

I would have liked it more if there had been a note mentioning where the key is. That would have given some logic to James' actions. Actually, is there a note about the key? Let me know your thoughts if you’d like.

[I]

Yeah, the game has a scarry... DESIGN!))) No mate no note. It was smooth till that puzzle, (SPOILERS) Why should I get to that toilet? The MOST logical decision - you entered the room on the 3rd floor, read the note about nothing, ran out of the room and saw the light from the left. The "toilet" roo to the right-straight, no reason to go there as its just a random small toilet many of them. The most logical decision is to go to the LEFT and leave the house. NOOOOO instead you need to go to the TOILET?!? WHY? Do I need to check EVERY toilet now? 2nd WHY should I put my hand in that HOLE? At that moment in the game, I had no idea I needed that button! HOW do I find that button afterwards IN THAT HOLE? LoL

Just if you accidentally miss that TOLILET you are stuck running around with no idea where to find the rest keys

pe Ah, its in the Note "Leaked from above" so you should check WHY the TOILET leaking. Ok, its makes a little bit of sense.

[Bilaterial Newt]

James just want to, he feels that he need to repair it, also he is interested in why man was beating jukebox before. And after all this he hear music that he listened to with his wife. Its Silent Hill town tricks.