Which Silent Hill would you like to see remade next?

[Tremere]

If Bloober Team makes another SH remake, which game would you like them to do? The only possible options for me are the Team Silent games (SH1, SH3 and SH4: The Room).
While I have a favorite I'll be happy with either. I can think of good arguments for all 3 of them to be next.
With that said, I personally prefer if Silent Hill 1 is next!

[burumanet]

Originally posted by Bullett00th:

Originally posted by ꉔꏂ꒐꒒ꇙ:

Definitely. I hate when remakes or so start with 2 or beyond...

Whenever did that happen aside from SH2?

And to be fair, starting with SH2 is completely ok since it's not really connected to 1 in any way

Capcom also started by remaking Resident Evil 2 rather than the first game. Maybe they both chose to skip ahead to more popular titles? Not sure. Not going in order is definitely an odd choice.

[Eastersimulator]

Originally posted by burumanet:

Originally posted by Bullett00th:

Whenever did that happen aside from SH2?

And to be fair, starting with SH2 is completely ok since it's not really connected to 1 in any way

Capcom also started by remaking Resident Evil 2 rather than the first game. Maybe they both chose to skip ahead to more popular titles? Not sure. Not going in order is definitely an odd choice.

DS2 had the first remake in the dark souls trilogy

[sovietreunion]

Sh4 for sure. Fix the second half of that game and I'm in!

[Tiny Trees]

1 - all the way.

[Tremere]

As I said in my original post, I see good reasons for any of them.
Silent Hill 1: The clear favorite in my opinion
- It needs remake the most on a purely technical level
- It is the first in the series and sets the story of the town of Silent Hill
Silent Hill 3:
- While this should have the lowest priority to be next, because it comes after SH1, it is my second favorite Silent Hill after SH2, so that in itself is a good reason for me to want it
Silent Hill 4: The Room:
- While I think this is the worst out of the Team Silent games, it has one of the best stories. It has very good idea behind it, but there are some problems with the execution. The things that need to change in my opinion are. Better monster design. Make Henry Townshend a more fleshed out character, he is extremely bland and uninteresting in the original game. Don't force us to go through the same levels twice, I think they should extend the locations but make us go through each one of them only once.

Whichever comes first (if any) I think with SH1 and SH4 they should take more creative liberties and add/change parts of the game. SH1 because it is really old and has outdated graphics and game design. SH4 because it simply has some weak parts.
With SH3, I think they should do exactly the same as SH2, do mostly a faithful remake, that barely changes small things, and mostly extends and improves what is already there.

[Freeman 2.0]

Well, I would like more a Capcom style strategy and making new games too and not only remakes. Also, the original games need and deserve to be preserved, even more important than a remake.

[Tremere]

Originally posted by Freeman 2.0:

Well, I would like more a Capcom style strategy and making new games too and not only remakes. Also, the original games need and deserve to be preserved, even more important than a remake.

The original games are not going anywhere. No matter what Konami does in the future, There will always be a way to play them.

[BuffedPotato]

Originally posted by Freeman 2.0:

Well, I would like more a Capcom style strategy and making new games too and not only remakes. Also, the original games need and deserve to be preserved, even more important than a remake.

We have "Silent Hill f" upcoming, so there's that

[Freeman 2.0]

Originally posted by Tremere:

Originally posted by Freeman 2.0:

Well, I would like more a Capcom style strategy and making new games too and not only remakes. Also, the original games need and deserve to be preserved, even more important than a remake.

The original games are not going anywhere. No matter what Konami does in the future, There will always be a way to play them.

I know, you're right, but I think they deserve better than "search in internet or emulate it". Also I'm sure there are people who want them in a retail box or in his favourite online store or platform and they want a more simple way to get them. I don't think the avaliable ways right now are complicated, but maybe there are people don't think the same way. And the HD Collection...well, it didn't make 2 and 3 justice. Besides if there are so many recent recopilations of Castlevania, Metal Gear and Contra, why not Silent Hill? I believe Konami can do it.

[cheetah1546]

I think you have to factor in how many years it takes to finish each remake. They need to prioritize each one because if they do all three. They take longer than Capcom and a lot will have changed when the last one is out.

[Powo_FR]

SH1, it's a good game but it aged horribly.
SH3 is ok as it is, I finished it recently in HD PS2 emulation and honestly it looked great and played great (it was extremely short tho).

[Sassy Robot]

Definitely the first game.

[ArchLobster]

Originally posted by Shaelent:

The first Silent Hill game should be remade next because its their oldest game dated 1999, especially because it was released exclusively for PS1.

After that I'd like to see them remake Silent Hill 3 and Silent Hill 4. They could probably remake some of their later SH games after that and make them better from the ground up too if given the potential.

Of the later SH games (games after 3 and 4), only Origins was any good.

[Antus_Manus]

SH1 1000%

[GoldInfinit7]

After they Remake SH1 then SH3, they should Remake SH Homecoming which has a great story but ruined by having technical issues.

It has to be SH1 then SH3 because they are connected sequentially 1 and then 3, but SH2 is an unrelated story. SH4 is available on GOG.