Mabinogi

Mabinogi

查看统计:
此主题已被锁定
Dead-Wolf 2012 年 12 月 15 日 下午 11:47
Not worth playing
IMO this game isnt worth playing. The game doesnt really give you any direction on where to go or how to get there... Your left on your own to figure out where to go and what to do.

The worst thing about this game is that for what ever reason it "loses" your attacks (for bow). Basically you have to time and wait for your attacks... you do this by pressing the button and waiting as the % to hit does up and when it gets up to the % that you want to release your attack (with bow), but for whatever reason the game makes you miss, even if your %to hit is 100%

The mobs are so overpowered that they can take you out in one cycle of attacks that you cant stop if you let it hit you the first time... and the game lags you so that even if you use melee and knock it down... the mob has time to get up and attack you and not let you hit it when you should be able to as the game makes you run around like an idiot before swinging your weapon... and that allows the mob to attack you first because IT doesnt lag.

There is no real difference between melee and ranged as normal mobs will attack you as soon as you target them. I always thought that ranged would allow you to attack them before alerting them... but I guess in this game why do that as its easier to make it so that all attack types are the same.

The controls are junk as well as you cannot select a target with the mouse as if you do the game will automatically start attacking it with the basic attack, and if you do try to fix the controls so that it doesnt auto attack, then it totaly changes how the attack is made.

So say you target it by left clicking on a target... then pressing 2 for attack... well if you left click it.. then it will auto attack it.. and if you press 2 then it will stop the first attack then switch over taking about .5 seconds then it will start up the counter for 2 attack.

And when you turn the auto attack off... then pressing the buttons no longer work... so you can target a mob without starting the attack... but pressing 2 wont start up the attack anymore.

All in all its a free game... but not worth downloading as the controls / UI sucks and the game ignores the fact that ranged attacks (only tried the bow) even at 100% somehow fails to do anything at all other then show a gfx of your attack going off and makeing a sound of a bow being fired... but the enemy getting no damage at all.
最后由 Dead-Wolf 编辑于; 2012 年 12 月 16 日 上午 12:00
< >
正在显示第 16 - 30 条,共 601 条留言
Kai 2012 年 12 月 18 日 上午 12:26 
引用自 Saltkirby
This is same thing I here when people I know talk about why they don't like Monster Hunter.

So to tl;dr this....

This game has a steeper learning curve than most games I play.

Not most, but some.

A lot of kids these days don't really know the difficulty curve of games a long time ago, and I'm not old enough to even say I played some back then.

I sorta understand why the older gamers gets fed up with the younger ones. >_>

Wanna know another old fashioned game I still have memories of?
Dransik and the 2d RPG with similar freedoms like Mabinogi. Now Ashen Empires with microtransaction and such, it's still crappy because they seem to restrict you somewhat and the server is annoyingly laggy with lag spikes (worse worse worse worse than mabinogi).

I liked the farming, blacksmithing, cooking, alchemy, magic, tailoring, combat - part of the game in that, since you rank up exp by doing actions (like shooting a cow with a arrow ranks up archery and bow proficiency).

The game had a faction and criminal system so if you get killed by town guards, you teleport to jail... Or just die within 1 hit or something because you are a noob.

It actually had a 'atmosphere' like the elder scrolls come to think of it.
Night time shrinks your vision and you need torches to venture thru dungeons, etc.
Graphically is like ultima online, but slightly better and more updated graphics and better animations.

With ultima online i've played private shards, the housing and construction is neat, not many games that offers free access lets you build a house in any shape and lets you craft furnitures and put them where ever you want in the house.
最后由 Kai 编辑于; 2012 年 12 月 18 日 上午 12:34
Kai 2012 年 12 月 18 日 上午 12:28 
引用自 majikero
My review fell off the front page and people now complains about not understanding the game. Learning the game is half the fun. Experimentation and finding out what works and what doesn't is good fun.

This game is not like any other mmo. Don't use any experience of other mmo as a basis to play this one. Leave everything you know about mmo's before you play this game. It's how different it is.

Monsters are not over-powered. Your just really weak. If your trying to kill wolves when you just started the game, you will die. There are foxes in town of a reason.

Battles are are fast paced and high risk for both you and the monster. It can kill you with one combo and you can kill it with one combo but you have to use other skills to win. Defense, counterattack and windmill will be your defense. You have to observe the monster and watch out for what it does so you can react accordingly.

But yeah, Lag does mess up that flow in battle. There's double rainbow right now and its only in limited time so expect lag during those times.

I'm okay with this game not because I sank money on this game. I'm okay with this game because there is nothing else like this game. If you find me some other game that's like this but better, I'll gift you any game of your choice.

I'd say that Megumi Tensei mmo thing where they try to mimic Mabinogi's combat style but fails...

My friend who plays mabi told me to try that game with him and I got fed up with it within a hour.
Dead-Wolf 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 8:01 
Its very funny that you make comments like that and dont even read the post. Learn to read and not just call people noobs.

I dont care if its a bug, if a game says 100% to hit... you shouldn't miss. If they didnt mean for it to not be able to miss, then they simply should not put 100% to hit but something like 95% as there is still that 5% miss chance.

I went into the options and had already turned off the auto attack.

At least monster hunter didnt lose your attacks due to lag or other game bugs. If you swing and hit a mob then you do it damage and not somehow miss at 100% to hit.

I finished the tutorial and had teleported to the town and found that I had trouble killing the grey wolves that is the first thing that you can fight.

Noone wants to play a game that does not allow you to fight back while in combat. I played the tutorial and know the basics of the game and had killed the newbie mobs in the starter area, but during the real combat against some mobs way south of the intro area I noticed that sometimes my attacks were ignored, but when I went to the first area after using the teleport item I found that I would get killed BECAUSE of the game constantly ignoring my attacks.

When you die 5 times in a row in 20 min because of the same bs of while fighting and the attack not registering in the game... then its a crap game and time to quit as its not worth the time or effort and fustration.

I like trying new games and testing them out to see if they are any good or not. Ive tried this game and have found it lacking, and created this post to warn new players that they may not like this game and also put the reasons why I do not like this game as is.

If you dont like that and have a problem with it... then thats on you. I personally wont put anymore time into the game as it just doesnt work (archery char with a sword alt weapon).

I would pull and weaken with a bow shot (I forgot the skill name but it helps to do more damage with melee... then magnum shot it then basic double shoot it, and if it got close switch to melee and counter it, use finish move (or whatever to jump attack a downed enemy) and try to close in and melee it to death.

My char was level 20-21 but didnt have any new armor and or weapons other then the basic bow and wooden sword as I will never put money in a game that hasnt proven itself to me first.

This game doesnt let you know what level mobs are... so you kinda have to just wing it and slap it around to find out if you can take it or not (the game doesnt tell you anything about this as I did go through the battle training and stuff like that, but other then that the game doesnt really give you a direction to go to.

What I was trying to do was to earn a little gold by doing some easy quests that you buy for like 20, but found that you cant even do that very easy, and what makes it even harder to do them is when your attacks dont work or hit even if your charged up to 100%.

@Kai
Im not some kid noob as ive been playing for along time. I just found this game lacking as to me... if it says 100% to hit... then it shouldnt miss. If its a bug or some type of lag glitch then its still not excusible as how can someone play a game if it doesnt give you a chance to fight back? Just try to attack with 80% and miss more then you hit?

Personally when I am learning how to play a new game I play solo so as not to annoy older players so that I at least know how to do the basic fighting and things... and as I made the char up to level 20-21 I dont think that my char was as worthless as it seemed when I was at the first area. If the quest that I bought and was trying to complete was some type of group quest... then I really think that it should have been stated in game as such.
最后由 Dead-Wolf 编辑于; 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 8:07
Seiryu 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 8:22 
To identify how strong something is.. use a bit of common sense. Bears are probably stronger than wolves. Spiders are probably really weak. Hold alt to see some strength rating of them compare to you. Better yet use wiki to identify how strong exactly something is. However nothing you do at this moment have more than like 500 hp. If one basic hit do 50 damage, magnum and other skill will easily kill anything within 5 shots.. NOW assuming you lvled your range attack and bow mastery a little, things like bears will die in 2-3 magnum.

O and did you do any quests? Generation quests are the things that give people direction, since you are complaining about lack of direction... It is in your quest list, something called rescue the villager (this is the start of it).

as someone pointed out... pass lvl 100 total then consider yourself graduated from noob status. Pass 300 lvls, consider yourself somewhat experienced. (20 lvls takes 30-45 minutes, takes 5-10 minutes for an older player who knows what they are doing with sufficiently strong character, maybe if you were really lost and just wandering about aimlessly then it could take you 2-3 hrs to reach it)

Regardless, as a summary of this game that i posted, it is either you can look pass the bugs, lag, and adapting to new combat or not. Since this game have bugs you cannot tolerate then thats it for this game and you, nothing wrong with it.

If more people needs to read through the exact good and bads of this game, read my post "game is not for everyone, decide for yourself" which is just compiling what people said about this game. Truth is, pretty good game and plagued with bugs and lag that breaks it for too many people. People who played a long time are 95% on and off players because of the #10 in the bads section. But since game keep updating fresh materials, a lot of people keeps coming back.
最后由 Seiryu 编辑于; 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 8:48
adobo 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 8:45 
I think you get daily free rebirths and skill reset till you reach total of 300. Can someone please check the accuracy of this. It's been months since I was a newb.

G1 quest is in Goddess tab of quest menu. Its a good direction to start with.

Bows have aiming glitches. Monsters can sometimes move away from the bows range and the shot will automatically miss.

The game does let you know how strong mobs are. You will see "weakest", "weak", "strong", "awful", and "boss" besides their name.

If you want to safely practice you bow timing and whatnot, go kill foxes. It like the easiest mobs in the game. If it still kills you, at least you get a title for you troubles. If your gonna kill wolves, don't start with the white ones in the south. At least start with the brown ones neat the moon gate.
Rika 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 8:48 
Sounds like the OP is either trolling or intentionally ignoring everything the tutorial was supposed to have taught him.

Compared to how I learned to play the game six years ago (and yes, I'm well aware it was released in english in 2008, not 2006, thank you very much), these tutorials couldn't be any better at teaching you the basics about skills and how you shouldn't mash the left mouse button until you die (and you WILL die trying that).

That, or this game is just not for you and you can go back to your generic tab target hotkey spam fest.

EDIT: I believe the free unlimited rebirths are until total level 100, which is also when your "aspiring whatever" title goes away. Also, gray wolves are weaker than normal brown dire wolves, though brown dire wolf cubs are probably the weakest of all wolf mobs in the game.
最后由 Rika 编辑于; 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 8:49
adobo 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 8:55 
Right, the gray ones near the moon gate.

If he still can't understand it from observation or trial and error, he's probably doing it wrong or learning impaired.

My guildie from the forum I frequent learned on his own and all I did is answer his questions about what he didn't understand.

Trial and error is part of this game. It's not like you lose anything valuable from dying this early in the game.
Dead-Wolf 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 9:43 
I never saw the game say anything about pressing ALT to see mob strenghs. I was following the quests one at a time each in the sequence that I was given it, while taking time to grind some mobs while exploring the first intro area.

I tried to kill a bear once and got one hit killed and stoped playing with them. I was killing the ghosts or whatever in the intro area and thats how I leveled my char up to 20 or so.

I only had about 10k and was trying to find a way to get more so I took the low 20 gold quest to try to get more cash for that first armor Leather that cost like 60k.

@ raptor
Learn to read... that or take the time to actually read someones posts.

1) My char was level 20-21.

2) I am not button mashing or I wouldnt be talking about the game stating 100% to hit and the game losing my attack.

3) I did the basic training quests that the intro NPC gives you (melee, bow, and the other training about counters/smash skills)

@majikero
Unlike you I dont just try to insult people for no reason. Thats what adults do... try growing up alittle.

If you want to have a discussion like real people then you dont just post snide little snits like you have. Actually try to put in some points on why your view is that way, and not just try to post your little insults.

How can there be trial and error when the game randomly deletes attacks when it states that the attack is at 100%? And this is not when pulling but during combat when attacks have already hit. As stated before in earlier posts (if you bothered to read it) states that I pull using the 3rd bow skill that makes melee damage do more damage, then using mag shot, then depending on how close it is... I pull back before using mag shot again or if its hp is low enough I just use the weaker bow shot.

Maybe due to lag spikes it messed up my shooting... but that doesnt excuse the reason why this game isnt worth playing... it actually supports my reasoning on why this game isnt worth the time to play.

I understand that if you shoot before 100% that you can miss shots and have no problem with that as I was messing around with different timings during attacks... but when I noticed that my 100% to hit shots kept missing when my timing is on... then that points to the system not working as it should.

I even tested by pressing the button before it was quite 100% and getting the lag so that the game reflects my attack right as it hit 100% with a full miss. I found that the game gave me about 0.2 - 0.4 lag as my button presses in real time dont get reflected in game, and trying to time it so that on screen the char would attack when as it reports 100% to hit and it still misses.

The game makes the gfx of char attacking with sound effects but the attack still gets lost.

Ive played a few Nexon games and have found that they all have issues with them. I will most likely just avoid all Nexon games from now on.

I find nothing wrong with wiki... but why should you have to go onto wiki just to learn the basics of a game? I personally did the beginner quests...

I did the weapon training bow and melee... didnt get the magic training as I think you need some type of yellow stone or something to get those.

I went to the other healer type char and did the mount quest thing.

The next quest I got was to use the teleportation item... but didnt do that and started going out and playing around with the foxes and other trash mobs... then went north east of the intro area to look around... then went clockwise to explore... found the ghosts and killed them for a while... then went farther south to find bears and get spanked... at that point I was got around 20 so I figured I should just use the teleport wing looking thing and restart on the basic quests.

I needed money so I tried to do the gray wolf quest and found that my attacks started to not register...

The thing is.. its not constant. Sometimes I hit with 100% sometimes I dont... and that is what is pissing me off. Its too inconsistant maybe due to lag spikes but to keep dieing because of this and not being able to get money with out paying real money is bs.
最后由 Dead-Wolf 编辑于; 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 9:51
adobo 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 9:54 
I try to insult everyone equally so I won't discriminate and hate you all equally. Don't worry, your not really special.

If the bow doesn't work you you try something else. You don't have to force yourself.

Also, if you want armor, go do the Generation 1 quest, at some point, it gives you the official noob armor. Wear it with pride and show Erin your Noobishness!
Dead-Wolf 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 9:58 
Why should I? I already made my post that Im not going to bother with this game anymore nor any nexon game. To me they are all trash games as its just another pay to win game.

adobo 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 9:58 
Pfff, pay to win he says.
Seiryu 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 10:59 
you really can't pay to win... unless you drop 40 dollars for 7 mil by selling reforges. Then again that is almost identical to buying gold you don't need to... What can you do with 7 mil igg, some of the best weapon costs only 500k or so. even then... decent equipment (only thing really matters is weapon... armor are mostly for cosmatics) 6-15 k. new human dual wielding wooden sword or gladius is pretty effective + using leather long bows...(sell holy waters 1.5-2k ea... do some church part time is MUCH easier to get money, all it takes is about 2-3 min of your time every in game day while you can afk do other stuff)

Heres a nice idea for what to do with your first bit of gold.

Human - leather long bow or crossbow + 2 wooden sword.
Giants - Any 2H weapon~15k iish or sword + shield.
Elves - Guardian bow/leather long bow + mace + shield.

Take classes for magic with lassar in tir school for all 3 races, its useful. Total should cost a beginner roughly 20k-30k gold to be set for gears and basic spells. (I do solo ciar int runs with my brand new char starting at lvl 30 with the gears stated above, only skill windmil r8! rest of my skills at rF)

Unless you can only attribute to pay to win... yes you can pay to look rediculously awesome... but really you cannot pay to win. Plz name me one thing in the item shop that you can "pay to win" except for maybe 100 fine reforges used to get 1 of your equipment to the perfect stat (sry i doubt anyone is that extreme yet, even so i got pass without any of those BEFORE they nerfed the crap out of the mobs in the story line quests.. and they are nerfing it again tomorrow lol...). Rest of items are just cause you want to look cooler/progress faster/have more storage.

Sry i cannot overlook people's ignorant comment about pay to win.
最后由 Seiryu 编辑于; 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 11:11
Dead-Wolf 2012 年 12 月 18 日 下午 11:47 
According to the other posters I was already fighting some of the weakest mobs in the area.
I had basic starter gear shirt/chest armor boots and the bow... found a wooden sword... got up to level 20 and grounded up 10k gold, still not enough for any good gear as far as I could tell, and I was trying to earn more cash but would die in one 3 hit combo from the wolves that or I would try to run and they would catch up... I would try to attack but would somehow miss or the game would delete/ignore my 100% attacks maybe due to lag but thats still game problem...

I said pay to win because how else would you be able to earn money with out paying real money if you cant even kill the easier mobs in that area? What keep killiing worthless spiders and getting the webbing and selling a stack of 10 for 1 gold?

BAH Im done with nexon games... they just want to force you to pay them real money so you dont just waste all your time running back and forth from respawn point to hunting point.
NiueCA 2012 年 12 月 19 日 上午 2:00 
dead-boy i was in your situation when i first started and was on the brink of quitting. the only way i managed to actually get somewhere was because i found a good guild that actually supported me and helped me through, otherwise its a nightmare by yourself.
Dead-Wolf 2012 年 12 月 19 日 上午 2:20 
I know that I could make it work... and that I could just delete my char and switch to melee... but why? I already put in so many hours just playing around and learning the game a little.. only to go to a new area with more ppl and finding that the lag makes the game so much harder to play because of the lag spikes...

That was the whole reason why I kept the melee weapon and put that into the mix of playing... but too many times my char would die because of some glitch or bug and I would have to waste so much time healing or getting back to the hunting location that I feel its just a waste of time.

I always play solo due to me not liking to have to deal with other players, such as loot drop and distribution, in fighting, clan/guild disputes due to in game politics... I'm done with that bullcrap.

I thank you for trying to help... but I think its better for me to just get away from nexon type games as it really just feels as if they just want whats in my wallet and not really care about fixing game issues like lag spikes. I cant even tell what the ping is between my computer and the server.

I like solo play and even though it might be harder to play solo then in a group... thats just the way I like playing sometimes.
< >
正在显示第 16 - 30 条,共 601 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

发帖日期: 2012 年 12 月 15 日 下午 11:47
回复数: 601