Isn't this Melvor Idle

[LudicrousFox]

Seems similar to a game called Melvor idle

[Super Arthritis ⁧⁧ ⁧⁧Man]

Of all the games you could have copied...

[Actias Luna]

Originally posted by Happy Demon:

Well before going on about the game being way similar to Melvor Idle, one should note Melvor Idle is blatantly copying RuneScape.
Like Melvor Idle flat out copies it's metals, the increasing coal use for smelting higher-tier metals, the trees and the runes. One-for-one copies. Not to mention all of the skills.

Idle Clans at least makes distinct metal names and doesn't flat out copy the full crafting list of equipment. Thievery of specific persons is instead plundering of areas, and it's skill synergies is something not found in Melvor Idle.
Despite the clear inspiration, Idle Clans seems like less of a copy-paste than Melvor Idle is.

Yeah they do it muxh better in melvor, agility by itself is useless in idle clan other than being a support skill for plundering. Seems kinds lazy

[nil]

melvor is offline and single player, idle clans is a multiplayer based game, it literally has "clans" in the name

[Chocbomb]

Why compared to Melvor?
More compared to Idlescape.

[Super Arthritis ⁧⁧ ⁧⁧Man]

Originally posted by Chocbomb:

Why compared to Melvor?
More compared to Idlescape.

Because it looks like a mod of Melvor.

[Chroma]

Originally posted by Happy Demon:

Well before going on about the game being way similar to Melvor Idle, one should note Melvor Idle is blatantly copying RuneScape.
Like Melvor Idle flat out copies it's metals, the increasing coal use for smelting higher-tier metals, the trees and the runes. One-for-one copies. Not to mention all of the skills.

Idle Clans at least makes distinct metal names and doesn't flat out copy the full crafting list of equipment. Thievery of specific persons is instead plundering of areas, and it's skill synergies is something not found in Melvor Idle.
Despite the clear inspiration, Idle Clans seems like less of a copy-paste than Melvor Idle is.

Look who is the publisher of Melvor, it literally Jagex. So of course it is based on Runescape.

[Super Arthritis ⁧⁧ ⁧⁧Man]

Originally posted by Chroma:

Look who is the publisher of Melvor, it literally Jagex. So of course it is based on Runescape.

It was self published for a while, Jagex bought the rights to it. Likely due to how blatantly it copied Runescape.

[Chocbomb]

Originally posted by Super Arthritis Man:

Originally posted by Chocbomb:

Why compared to Melvor?
More compared to Idlescape.

Because it looks like a mod of Melvor.

Have a look at Idlescape, even the information bubbles are ripped from Idlescape.

[76561199487053436]

is it though?

[PainInBrain]

this game already exists

[Enternight]

This game does things differently enough that I can appreciate it and Melvor at the same time.

Games have taken inspiration from other games since the dawn of the gaming industry.

[Ghal Maraz]

Originally posted by Enternight:

This game does things differently enough that I can appreciate it and Melvor at the same time.

Games have taken inspiration from other games since the dawn of the gaming industry.

This should be marked as the answer to this discussion

[WonoBono]

its heavily insprired by old mmos and games like melvor having played more of this than the former i might be baised but i only see a few similar things mainly the art but its just an art style doesnt mean its a copy and sometimes a copy can be as good if not better than the og why hate.

[76561199530288142]

I don't mean to bonk anyone on the heads here folks...but as a webdev, the art style here is literally UTF-8 characters lol. Or at least they look very similar to me.

/throw-hat-into-mix

lol

[Rager]

Well considering this game is better than Melvor. Who cares.