IBM 23 or PBM 2023?

[Bobby K. Sunshit]

International Basketball Manager 23 or Pro Basketball Manager 2023,
which game do you prefer? has the IBM 23 a 3D game?

[christendre10]

IBM ....More realist!

[Bobby K. Sunshit]

Originally posted by christendre10:

IBM ....More realist!

alright! but no 3D game?

[mattlemon77]

Originally posted by Bobby K. Sunshit:

Originally posted by christendre10:

IBM ....More realist!

alright! but no 3D game?

Exactly.

PS: Personally, I like both, but the PBM brings a much larger database and with more data on each player's season, it is more complete if you like you like that section. Also the "workshop" of the game makes it worth trying, the current mod is very well done and is updated quite often as well. Cheers!.

[Bobby K. Sunshit]

Originally posted by mattlemon77:

Originally posted by Bobby K. Sunshit:

alright! but no 3D game?

Exactly.

PS: Personally, I like both, but the PBM brings a much larger database and with more data on each player's season, it is more complete if you like you like that section. Also the "workshop" of the game makes it worth trying, the current mod is very well done and is updated quite often as well. Cheers!.

thank you! cheers! 🍻

[Crowder]

No doubt, for me, PBM23!, Full editable and with mods in progress. The playability is x 100 better than IBM23.

[Bobby K. Sunshit]

Originally posted by Crowder:

No doubt, for me, PBM23!, Full editable and with mods in progress. The playability is x 100 better than IBM23.

that makes it crystal clear. the winner is ... PBM 2023! 🙃
thank you!

[Leeroy]

Sincerely, I have played both: PBM and IBM, and IBM is a thousand times better than PBM, both in gameplay and overall quality, and considering that they put the worskshop at Christmas, IBM is even better right now

[Bobby K. Sunshit]

Originally posted by Leeroy:

Sincerely, I have played both: PBM and IBM, and IBM is a thousand times better than PBM, both in gameplay and overall quality, and considering that they put the worskshop at Christmas, IBM is even better right now

puuuuh. i already had my decision ... now everything is different again 🙃
thanks for your opinion. sounds good. i might wait until january and then maybe go with IBM ... a thousand times better you say? but no 3D game ... right? how is a game displayed? 2D topdown?

[Leeroy]

In my opinion it is more important play a good basketball manager game than have 3D

[Bobby K. Sunshit]

Originally posted by Leeroy:

In my opinion it is more important play a good basketball manager game than have 3D:tgrin::tgrin:

that is absolutely right! but a 3D game (like the Football Manager has) adds a lot to the game experience for me. it's not a must ... but it's a good addition! 🙃

[Dievulis]

PBM has same problems as it had on 2017-2018 Editions lol , and everything is very unrealistic u can read my review on PBM 22 i had lost like 300 or more hour on that ♥♥♥♥♥♥ game and PBM 23 just changed a bit dont support that game.

[Dave]

I would go for IBM. PBM is much less realistic and just amateurish. Even tho they have a bigger database, the less popular leagues are a mess. Very inaccurate player ratings, league rules, salaries...basically everything, plus plenty of bugs with transfers and finances. Imo not worth the 20 - 25 euros

[Bobby K. Sunshit]

Originally posted by Dievulis:

PBM has same problems as it had on 2017-2018 Editions lol , and everything is very unrealistic u can read my review on PBM 22 i had lost like 300 or more hour on that ♥♥♥♥♥♥ game and PBM 23 just changed a bit dont support that game.

Originally posted by Dave:

I would go for IBM. PBM is much less realistic and just amateurish. Even tho they have a bigger database, the less popular leagues are a mess. Very inaccurate player ratings, league rules, salaries...basically everything, plus plenty of bugs with transfers and finances. Imo not worth the 20 - 25 euros

it's getting clearer and clearer ... IBM seems to be the winner! 🙃

[orvcz]

Hi, I wonder about choosing IBM or PBM. More leagues are an advantage of PBM, but I know IBM has introduced a workshop. Does anyone know if there are more leagues in IBM by mods now?

[ignaciotf2006]

Originally posted by Bobby K. Sunshit:

Originally posted by Dievulis:

PBM has same problems as it had on 2017-2018 Editions lol , and everything is very unrealistic u can read my review on PBM 22 i had lost like 300 or more hour on that ♥♥♥♥♥♥ game and PBM 23 just changed a bit dont support that game.

Originally posted by Dave:

I would go for IBM. PBM is much less realistic and just amateurish. Even tho they have a bigger database, the less popular leagues are a mess. Very inaccurate player ratings, league rules, salaries...basically everything, plus plenty of bugs with transfers and finances. Imo not worth the 20 - 25 euros

it's getting clearer and clearer ... IBM seems to be the winner! 🙃

I did a test on both and after searching and this is my conclussion:
IBM is a very good game as a base lettings low end pc can play a good management game for phone but if you have the pbm requirements go for it maybe it has problem people says it is less realistic but to be honest their style remember me to a fm which is one of the greatest management games of the market also on pbm discord server the support answer kick and help you faster if you have the chances go for pbm it seems like it has more pontetial, wdk yet how ibm developers will better their game but i feel they will go for the more casual people
In a few words depends of your pc and how much deep you want your Game to be