What did you guys think of Troy Baker's Joker?

[Raider]

I personally loved his performance, he could easily be a replacement to Mark Hamill.

[SleepyDroid]

Well it was ok, but getting Hamill back in Arkham Knight was so great

[Buck]

Nothing and no one can "replace" Mark's Legendary Performance as Joker, but Troy's is just utterly superb.

Originally posted by SleepyDroid:

Well it was ok, but getting Hamill back in Arkham Knight was so great

Best performance from him ever IMO, but I think that Troy could have rocked it as well.

[Raider]

Originally posted by Buck:

Nothing and no one can "replace" Mark's Legendary Performance as Joker, but Troy's is just utterly superb.

Well by replace I meant if Mark ever stopped being the Joker.

[Fzero3000]

Personally I thought it was pretty spot on, tbh if I didn't know going in that Troy was voicing the Joker he easily could have fooled me (I barely noticed any difference),

Mark might be slightly better however I don't think that's really fair to hold against Troy given that Mark has been doing the Voice for years and Troy was doing an immitation of a voice that probably didnt come as naturally to him.

definiately would be my first choice to voice Hamil's joker if Mark's unavailable.

[Raider]

Originally posted by Fzero3000:

Personally I thought it was pretty spot on, tbh if I didn't know going in that Troy was voicing the Joker he easily could have fooled me (I barely noticed any difference),

Mark might be slightly better however I don't think that's really fair to hold against Troy given that Mark has been doing the Voice for years and Troy was doing an immitation of a voice that probably didnt come as naturally to him.

definiately would be my first choice to voice Hamil's joker if Mark's unavailable.

Actually, as a complete contradiciton to my original opinion, I don't think Troy will be able to voice a Mark Hamill Joker. Troy's Joker DOES sound very good, but, Mark Hamill usually plays Old/Aged Jokers. Tryo's Joker would only work for a younger Joker (Arkham Origins). Still amazing, however.

[adams_apple]

Originally posted by SleepyDroid:

Well it was ok, but getting Hamill back in Arkham Knight was so great

Thanks for the spoiler jerk. Real nice how you covered up what game you were spoiling so we couldn't avoid it.

[Raider]

Originally posted by adams_apple:

Originally posted by SleepyDroid:

Well it was ok, but getting Hamill back in Arkham Knight was so great

Thanks for the spoiler jerk. Real nice how you covered up what game you were spoiling so we couldn't avoid it.

Let's not turn a civil convesation into an arguement, okay buddy? Besides he appears in the first hour or so of the game, not much of a spoiler.

[CrisWithoutH]

Whenever I hear somebody saying "I thought it was Mark Hamill in Arkham Origins", I want to slap them in the face. The difference is painfully obvious. Troy Baker is in everything right now, so not even for a moment I thought it was the Joker. It was always Troy Baker pretending to be the Joker. I kinda liked his voice during normal dialogues, but his laugh is absolutely terrible.

[CrisWithoutH]

Originally posted by adams_apple:

Originally posted by SleepyDroid:

Well it was ok, but getting Hamill back in Arkham Knight was so great

Thanks for the spoiler jerk. Real nice how you covered up what game you were spoiling so we couldn't avoid it.

Oh yeah, because Arkham Knight's story is sooo good and it's not like everyone already predicted that Joker would be back.

[Buck]

Originally posted by dont be upsetti:

Well by replace I meant if Mark ever stopped being the Joker.

Officially speaking AC was to be his last role, but he's well quoted as stating he would absolutely return to voice Joker for an animated version of "The Killing Joke", which looks like it's finally really going to happen.

http://comicbook.com/2015/07/19/mark-hamill-has-his-fingers-crossed-about-voicing-joker-in-the-k/

[Raider]

Originally posted by Comix777:

Originally posted by adams_apple:

Thanks for the spoiler jerk. Real nice how you covered up what game you were spoiling so we couldn't avoid it.

Oh yeah, because Arkham Knight's story is sooo good and it's not like everyone already predicted that Joker would be back.

Keep it civil, this is about Origins anyways.

[BuFFu]

Originally posted by dont be upsetti:

I personally loved his performance, he could easily be a replacement to Mark Hamill.

Honestlly i think he did a grate job as the joker but Hamill really is the joker. When i think off the joker i instantlly think Mark hamill... I will give Troy some credit he really is talented but i just think Mark is the better joker

[SpatenRundung]

I am a huge fan of Troy Baker and his performance was really awesome.
Mark Hamill was of course great too.