Strongly... messed up ? (bug)

[Heartwing Daraco]

In Chapter VII, when Caerlin ask for a drink "strong and powerful", I served the "Southern Brawler" (the only right choice at that point), and she said that I have a "Messed up definition of strong".

And when I serve a "bad drink", the dialogue appeared to be the right decision

Is that a mistake ? (I play on the switch version)

[76561199547383072]

Originally posted by Heartwing Daraco:

In Chapter VII, when Caerlin ask for a drink "strong and powerful", I served the "Southern Brawler" (the only right choice at that point), and she said that I have a "Messed up definition of strong".

And when I serve a "bad drink", the dialogue appeared to be the right decision

Is that a mistake ? (I play on the switch version)

This isn't a bug, it depends on the relationship you have Caerlin thus far and how she generally reacts to you. For example on your screen should be the Rogue as well, right? In the one were she reacts positive, the Rogue is missing.

I hope that helps.

Cheers,
Tommy 💜

[Bi_Jedi]

Thanks so much for asking this!
I just hit the same issue and restarted the day in a panic wondering what I'd done wrong.

[of_Myths_and_Monsters]

It's reassuring to know I wasn't the only one freaked out. Thought I had missed something or the game was bugged.

Though I am still a little confused. Is she just joking with us? Or did I manage to get on her bad side? Cause I thought I had a pretty good relationship with her up to that point.

Then again, since the Rogue is missing in the positive response version, isn't it more likely the result of the branching narrative rather than our answers to the various benign dialog options (Vampire vs. Werewolf, etc.)? I'm planning on replaying the game anyway to see all the quest results, but it would be kinda nice to know/get a hint how to get a positive reaction from her.