Dragon's Dogma 2

Dragon's Dogma 2

View Stats:
Usagi-chan Apr 4, 2024 @ 9:27am
Lore issue
We already kinda knew that from the first game but now it's pretty clear.

It seems, if I understand well, that even if an Arisen fail to defeat the dragon, the dragon will disapear anyway ? So there is no difference about winning or losing against it ?

+ how can there be so much former arisens in this game ? I count at least 6 of them. Are arisen still immortals even if their dragons disappear ?

How can an Arisen fail to defeat his dragon AND still be alive ?
Last edited by Usagi-chan; Apr 5, 2024 @ 6:47am
< >
Showing 1-15 of 47 comments
SadPlatty© Apr 4, 2024 @ 9:34am 
So technically - the dragon doesn't vanish if the Arisen gives up.

DD1 - the King actually took Grigori's barter; go home, leave your betrothed to him, and you both get to pretend you killed him and he will stay away forever. This does in-turn result in the Arisen being immortal.

Grigori however knew that fate is a wheel that always turns, and selected you as a new champion. He wanted you to kill him - and you do in the "true ending" (you can choose the same barter, but it "game overs" after a cut-scene). When you kill Grigori, his Arisen then got their hearts back (King, Dragonforged + you) and they both age into dust basically (king is alive, but on his death-bed now).

The King is well aware you choose to kill the dragon as well - and so he turns on you. The ascension to the Seneschal then can end in one of two ways :
- You lose; you become the next cycles Grigori
- You win; you ascend to the rank of Seneschal, and then attempt to suicide, but again - fate is unescapable and so it fails, and your Pawn absorbs your soul, and then the next cycle begins.

Edit : Hence - in DD2, so many Arisen exist, because they all failed to kill the dragon (ran away, just gave up and stopped trying, took a deal, etc.). Simple as that.
Last edited by SadPlatty©; Apr 4, 2024 @ 9:36am
GetUrAssToMars Apr 4, 2024 @ 9:37am 
From what I understand the dragon can mark multiple as the arisen in a single cycle. Some die. Some run away. It keeps trying till the cycle is "complete"

Its a whole paradoxical mess that DDDA just further adds to the confusion with the seneschal business.
Last edited by GetUrAssToMars; Apr 4, 2024 @ 9:38am
Usagi-chan Apr 4, 2024 @ 9:54am 
Originally posted by SadPlatty©:
So technically - the dragon doesn't vanish if the Arisen gives up.

DD1 - the King actually took Grigori's barter; go home, leave your betrothed to him, and you both get to pretend you killed him and he will stay away forever. This does in-turn result in the Arisen being immortal.

Grigori however knew that fate is a wheel that always turns, and selected you as a new champion. He wanted you to kill him - and you do in the "true ending" (you can choose the same barter, but it "game overs" after a cut-scene). When you kill Grigori, his Arisen then got their hearts back (King, Dragonforged + you) and they both age into dust basically (king is alive, but on his death-bed now).

The King is well aware you choose to kill the dragon as well - and so he turns on you. The ascension to the Seneschal then can end in one of two ways :
- You lose; you become the next cycles Grigori
- You win; you ascend to the rank of Seneschal, and then attempt to suicide, but again - fate is unescapable and so it fails, and your Pawn absorbs your soul, and then the next cycle begins.

Edit : Hence - in DD2, so many Arisen exist, because they all failed to kill the dragon (ran away, just gave up and stopped trying, took a deal, etc.). Simple as that.

But how can the cycle continue in DD1 when there are no Seneschal anymore ? No Seneschal = no dragon = no arisen
gotaa Apr 4, 2024 @ 9:57am 
Been wondering that too, where is the Senechal? Is it the Pathfinder?
Last edited by gotaa; Apr 4, 2024 @ 9:58am
GetUrAssToMars Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:01am 
Originally posted by gotaa:
Been wondering that too, where is the Senechal? Is it the Pathfinder?

Nope. I think its...

The mad king at the bottom of the seafloor shrine
Devitancotia Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:02am 
For DD2, it was mentioned in brief dialog. The oracle old lady, Luz said they all giveup/runaway, for each their reasons.

What is known is only they didn't defeat the dragon.

The way 'their dragon' mentioned is kind of confusing. And why dragon disappeared is not clearly explained.

In DD1/DDDA, can say the dragon is gone for the bargain. But tbh it still always seems not well explained, not very self-cohesive. Like, is one dragon to one worldforged/seneschal? Is the dragon bargained just gone, or return later? Does kill any dragon release all existing arisen? But yea.
Zuruuu Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:03am 
Originally posted by gotaa:
Been wondering that too, where is the Senechal? Is it the Pathfinder?
In DD2, the Seneschal is not even mentioned.
Interesting is that the Pathfinder is known as WorldForged as well
Dareth Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:04am 
Originally posted by gotaa:
Been wondering that too, where is the Senechal? Is it the Pathfinder?
for Pathfinder question check out True Ending.
DD2 is a reboot, so there is no point in using knowledge from DD/DDA, because in DD2 we have Dragons Dogma -> Dragon Dogma2.
Last edited by Dareth; Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:06am
Usagi-chan Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:04am 
Originally posted by gotaa:
Been wondering that too, where is the Senechal? Is is the Pathfinder?

Well i'm pretty sure that the Seneschal in DD2 is the phantom dude that follows us, but he actually influences people and pawn, when the Seneschal is only supposed to be an observer so I dont know. In french, that dude is named "L'Ubique" which is a synonyme of "L'omniprésent/ The omnipresent"
Last edited by Usagi-chan; Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:06am
gotaa Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:07am 
Originally posted by Laan:
Originally posted by gotaa:
Been wondering that too, where is the Senechal? Is is the Pathfinder?

Well i'm pretty sure that the Seneschal in DD2 is the phantom dude that follows us, but he actually influences people and pawn, when he is only supposed to be an observer so I dont know. In french, that dude is named "L'Ubique" which is a synonyme of "L'omniprésent/ The omnipresent"

That certainly sounds like the Senechal in that he's everywhere but no one can see him (just like in DD1 where you can roam around with no one knowing you're there).
Devitancotia Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:07am 
Originally posted by GetUrAssToMars:
Originally posted by gotaa:
Been wondering that too, where is the Senechal? Is it the Pathfinder?

Nope. I think its...

The mad king at the bottom of the seafloor shrine
I think there is some new plot elements in DD2. So Pathfinder is clearly the brine
but also acting like the role of senechal? The mad king is the arisen took the throne but being laugh at by Pathfinder like we would've being.
Devitancotia Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:10am 
Originally posted by Laan:
In french, that dude is named "L'Ubique" which is a synonyme of "L'omniprésent/ The omnipresent"

damn that makes way more sense. wtf is a 'pathfinder' lol
Wonder if Japanese would be close to which
Last edited by Devitancotia; Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:11am
ffrotty Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:11am 
the main piece that's a plot-hole/tbd with expansion/baffling is what completing the unmooed world actually means.

on one hand if you do good/bad ending you are NOT breaking the cycle, so NG+ makes sense

however, if you kill yourself and ultimately kill the pathfinder... the brine is gone and the cycle is broken............. exxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxcept the only option is NG+ AND nothing is different, it seems more like a time warp than a cycle.

so NG+ for good/bad = cycle continues
but what does NG+ for broken cycle mean?

It does the title change which implies the entire game was just "DD" and breaking the cycle = DD2.

What's also vague is what happens to your pawn/yourself when killing the pathfinder, the assumption is "you/your pawn dies too" but that implies the end of the entire series as well, when you kill yourself the pathfinder is still there to deal with you... however actually killing the pathfinder, then what?

But obviously in NG+ the pathfinder is back, you're chosen, etc.

The only game I recall that had the bal.... errr, gumption to do this "ending cycle" the right way was Neir Automata which literally had you deleting your save file.


It is interesting to "realize" that you're the equivalent of a pawn being chosen and expected to fulfill a scripted destiny. And that your free will (kinda bleak that free will = suicide) infected the pawn and enabled you to break the cycle, but is it painting the plot into a corner to say "lol broken cycle" but obviously let the player still play some other cycle.


This would be remedied if NG+ actually had something change once breaking the cycle, but it doesn't... sooooooo it turns the plot into arbitrary mumbo jumbo and frankly undermines this game at all with a fat TBD on an expansion that will clarify things.


They muddied things only to say "and with the next installment it will be clarified (and muddied further) again."

So I'm expecting to see pathfinder clarified / pathfinder's boss / the origins of what started this cycle business in the first place, in the dlc... or, you know, in dragon's dogma 17 released in 2102.


Last edited by ffrotty; Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:21am
GetUrAssToMars Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:12am 
Originally posted by Devitancotia:
Originally posted by GetUrAssToMars:

Nope. I think its...

The mad king at the bottom of the seafloor shrine
I think there is some new plot elements in DD2. So Pathfinder is clearly the brine
but also acting like the role of senechal? The mad king is the arisen took the throne but being laugh at by Pathfinder like we would've being.

well if he took the throne why would arisen go to challenge him? That's the one dead giveaway (atleast to me) since he seems to be responsible for the shards of arisen souls that wash up on the coast that are used to create the gods way.


I think he is a seneschal gone wrong and the Pathfinder is the next level up in management called in the keep things in control.
SadPlatty© Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:16am 
Originally posted by Laan:
But how can the cycle continue in DD1 when there are no Seneschal anymore ? No Seneschal = no dragon = no arisen

Because your original Arisen is the Seneschal - if you play online through the game 2x, your first character is the boss of your second run, and they have your pawn with them.

The first time you fight the Seneschal in NG (don't think the cut-scene plays in NG+ runs, like how the intro with you as the king is a one-time deal), he even removes the Godsbane from his torso, so you finish the game by putting it in yours, hence the cycle never ends.
Last edited by SadPlatty©; Apr 4, 2024 @ 10:17am
< >
Showing 1-15 of 47 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Apr 4, 2024 @ 9:27am
Posts: 47