Spellbound quest

[Silentbird66]

So I already gave all the real copies of the tombs to the old mage guy for his rewards.

I have 5 copies, but I have been told if you give the 5 copies to the girl her quest fails and you can get the rewards? Is this true, or is that just what people say?

Im ♥♥♥♥♥♥ either way right?

[Sengralon]

I've read that she won't properly learn magic with the forgeries and thus lock you out of her better rewards.
However, I've found two real copies of Nation's Death Knell so far, as well as an NPC that will trade one grimoire for another on the list. I believe she wanted a Fulminous Shield and offered a Howling Blizzard.
You might be able to give that NPC a forgery to get a real grimoire.

Edit: What I'm trying to convey is: You might not be totally screwed. There may be more originals out there

Also, Locations:
Nation's Death Knell: Inside the castle of the Ancient Battleground N/W of Checkpoint Rest Town AND in the Waterfall Cave, which is the cave entrance where your Griffin Taxi crashed after the intro (prepare for a fight)

Grimoire trader: One of the NPCs in the Nameless Village

[Silentbird66]

So you need at least three real books, I have two real books but am missing the third.

Anyone find copies of Fulminous Shield, Towering Earth, Let There Be Light?

[Silentbird66]

Originally posted by Sengralon:

I've read that she won't properly learn magic with the forgeries and thus lock you out of her better rewards.
However, I've found two real copies of Nation's Death Knell so far, as well as an NPC that will trade one grimoire for another on the list. I believe you needed a Fulminous Shield to get a Howling Blizzard.
You might be able to give that NPC a forgery to get a real grimoire.

yup did that, I have a real copy of Death Knell and Howling blizzard...just need one more but cant find anything about a copy of the others.

[Drenaeus]

As far as I know from a little bit of research into these two specific quests previously, you only need to give each of them three tomes to fulfil the requirements for the rewards, there are also not enough books in the world to fulfil the full five for both unless you did one or two NG+ runs and did it that way.. if you've already given all five to Myrddin then you've most likely locked yourself out of Trysha's quest as I don't believe there are extra copies of Let There Be Light, Fulminous Shield and Towering Earth.

I'd also like to mention that there are two copies of Nation's Death Knell and at least three copies of Howling Blizzard with one of those three being a unfavourable trade in Nameless Village for Fulminous Shield but I've not tested forgeries, this last part is purely based on my experiences in acquiring the tomes.

[Rebol]

If you want all of both worlds, Myrrdin can have all forgeries. Trisha can have real ones for her next quest which means you're going to need go to new game plus or ask around for someone to give you those.

[Zanza21]

Originally posted by I'd also like to mention that there are two copies of Nation's Death Knell and at least three copies of Howling Blizzard with one of those three being a unfavourable trade in Nameless Village for Fulminous Shield but I've not tested forgeries[/quote:

I tested it, and she accepted a fake copy

[Toffe]

Rewards I got from giving her 5 (true) tomes:

Turquoise Ring

After second part of the questline:

Conjurer's Jottings (Meteoron), Cast Stone (Mage staff)

also Enchanter's Almanac (Celestial Paean) (from her granny).

[AirOne13]

does the ring do anything ?

[[-iD-]]

Originally posted by AirOne13:

does the ring do anything ?

its for Myrddin if you already got the spells from trysha before handing in 3 books to him.

[DaBa]

If you've already given the real tomes to Myrrdin, you've screwed out of the other quest as the little girl NEEDS the real tomes to finish the quest properly.

So if you've done that and don't want to get locked out of two mesiter spells, the best way to get these back would be a mod. Or a NG+ run I guess.

[Azraeil]

Just completed both these quests last night, it's time consuming and expensive to forgery the tomes, but worth it as the Tornado spell and the Meteor spell are amazing, the whole quest chain is just more of a time sink than some of the others but worth doing carefully, I messed up once and did not the get the tome from the Magistrate because I didn't realize you needed Spellbound to trigger the tome, lost an hour and then finished it the right way upon resetting at inn.

[Tacticle]

Can someone please gift me a Howling blizzard or it’s forgery? I need it so badly.

[P3ssimistic]

This quest is godawful, expensive in both the forgery and the fast travelling not to mention time consuming if you don't want to fast travel at all, this quest is a pain in the ass and what the ♥♥♥♥ is Capcom thinking with this quest design, almost like they are tempting or forcing you to buy those DLC ferrystone, sorry for venting I'm just low in cash in the game so there's no way I'd be able to do this ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ quest as of now..

[dodger]

I made forgeries of 3 of the grimoires, but when I went to Myrddin, they were all gone from my inventory. I had already turned in the real copies to Trysha. Now I'm screwed.

[malprave3]

Don't give up. I want to say I found two copies of 3 out of 5. Nations Death Knell for sure has two copies. Check every traveling merchant you run across. Especially the ones in bizarre places. I bought Dullahan bones and other rare materials form a guy wandering the Ancient Battlefield.