Flora not giving me Chirurgeon item

[Avatorn]

So, I finished Medicament Predicament. I gave Flora the healing item.

I then went to the capital and she spoke to me, introduced me to her father, and then I spoke to her father (who gives me a discount at his store).

I did NOT talk to her the 2nd time (didnt know about Chirurgeon item).

I found her several days later and spoke to her in the capital. She doesnt give me anything.

Anyone else have this issue? Is there another way to get one?

[Penril]

same thing happened to me :/ even had that specializations tutorial pop up but no item

[Braxxas]

Same here

[123]

same thing, and also I ended 'the heel of history' quest, I did NOT get any tomb

[Grimzy]

Originally posted by Avatorn:

So, I finished Medicament Predicament. I gave Flora the healing item.

I then went to the capital and she spoke to me, introduced me to her father, and then I spoke to her father (who gives me a discount at his store).

I did NOT talk to her the 2nd time (didnt know about Chirurgeon item).

I found her several days later and spoke to her in the capital. She doesnt give me anything.

Anyone else have this issue? Is there another way to get one?

I wouldnt say its an issue. I think this is part of the whole design where passage of time affects quests and npc's in the world. You simply might have missed it. It might show up again after a while or not.

[Avatorn]

Originally posted by Grimzy:

Originally posted by Avatorn:

So, I finished Medicament Predicament. I gave Flora the healing item.

I then went to the capital and she spoke to me, introduced me to her father, and then I spoke to her father (who gives me a discount at his store).

I did NOT talk to her the 2nd time (didnt know about Chirurgeon item).

I found her several days later and spoke to her in the capital. She doesnt give me anything.

Anyone else have this issue? Is there another way to get one?

I wouldnt say its an issue. I think this is part of the whole design where passage of time affects quests and npc's in the world. You simply might have missed it. It might show up again after a while or not.

Which is a problem in the quest design when nothing about the interactions clued me in to talk to the girl again.

[Braxxas]

In the meantime I came to believe, that other NPC's have copies of the tomes as well.
For example: I got the tomes for Logistician (Kenndrick) and Forager (Malcolm) shortly after doing the 'Heel of History' Quest. Not immediately after ending the quest, mind you, they walked up to me after a minute or two while I was searching the archive room for stuff and gave me the tomes.
Later on I got the Forager tome again, this time from the the girl in the slums (Daphne) some time after doing 'The gift of giving'. Again, it wasn't part of the quest reward, she just walked up to me later to give it to me.
So maybe lots of NPC's have those tomes at the ready, in case some dashing Arisen comes along and decides to get better aquainted?

[Avatorn]

I didn't realize that's how you got Logistician. I only got Forager from that quest. so, i probably have lost out on Logistician as well.

[Stern lord]

+ same problem

[Honorable_D]

Can you go back to previous specialty? Or once you overwrite one with a new one...that old one is gone?

[Avatorn]

i think it's overwritten.

[Frostwyn]

AFAIK you just have to get the NPC's Likability to max and they'll just hand it over. So just give Flora gifts till she gives it to you. Another NPC, Eino, gives you a specialization that makes your pawn shut up as well.

[SchnakeEyes]

@Frostwyn, I maxed Floras liability, nothing

[Theofratus]

For me, she walked up to me while doing the royal kid with the box, and she gave it to me.

My only suggestion is to walk around the area, see if there's any other quest that requires an NPC to interrupt you, and if not and she's wandering, she might give it up since nothing else is queueing for your attention.

[CookingMaMa]

Originally posted by Honorable_D:

Can you go back to previous specialty? Or once you overwrite one with a new one...that old one is gone?

its a one-time use item.
you cannot select the previous specialization again
So, think before u use, otherwise u need a NG+

[Mutuh]

I had at least 2 random NPC's walk up to me and give me a specialisation scroll, this was despite me already having the first ones I've received stashed in storage.