Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4

View Stats:
+theo+ Mar 31, 2023 @ 8:25am
3
BETTER THAN TLOU
story,gameplay,performance all better than tlou. +1 great game



EDIT: thread proves both fanbase are toxic I just said my opinion stop insulting each other and enjoy games you like clowns.
Last edited by +theo+; Apr 1, 2023 @ 12:25am
< >
Showing 76-90 of 112 comments
HEXEN Apr 1, 2023 @ 5:33pm 
Originally posted by Hans ✙:
Originally posted by HEXEN:

Same. I can't understand the TLOU bashing here. We need more survival horror IPs in the RE tradition, not less. And TLOU is exactly that.
TLoU - survival horror? Lol.

Survival horror isn't a badge of honor. It's a game genre.
Flan Apr 1, 2023 @ 5:44pm 
Originally posted by ToveriJuri:

I have a really hard time seeing what makes TLOU combat so great. Naughty Dog has never been particularly good at shooting mechanics and TLOU is no different. Combat doesn't feel tense to me there are really no moments that feel challenging enough to be tense.

It switches between, stealth, active stealth, shooting, cover shooting, and melee at will and fluidly. They have all been done better alone elsewhere but to do them all competently at once with the player deciding freely is quite engaging.
Peelsepuuppi Apr 2, 2023 @ 12:21am 
Originally posted by HEXEN:
Originally posted by ToveriJuri:

I have a really hard time seeing what makes TLOU combat so great. Naughty Dog has never been particularly good at shooting mechanics and TLOU is no different. Combat doesn't feel tense to me there are really no moments that feel challenging enough to be tense. And the below average 3rd person shooter mechanics have absolutely nothing unique or interesting going for them to make it feel awesome.

I don't hate the game, but there is absolutely nothing about TLOU that makes me want to play it again after experiencing it once. It's great "film" experience an entertaining one and done ride, but that's it.

How is the gunplay not good?

How is the middling gunplay any good? It's the most milquetoast boring 3rd person shooter gunplay you could have also at least on console it felt somewhat clunky even after you leveled up your aiming stat or whatever it was called then.

Like compare TLOU combat to what we have in this game. Comparing how engaging RE4 combat is to TLOU combat these gamse might as well be from another planet.

And if it's unfair to compare TLOU to a modern game like RE4 Remake then compare it to RE5. Still loses severely in just how engaging the combat mechanics are in RE5.

It doesn't tick the survival feel from old RE games and it doesn't tick the engaging gameplay mechanics of more modern RE games. It just ticks the. This is an interesting tragic movie feel and thoughts like "these characters have an enjoyable dynamic". Telling a story is the only thing TLOU did well.
Alyx Apr 2, 2023 @ 12:24am 
Originally posted by DasaKamov:
I like Apples, so I'm going to go to the "Oranges" forum and tell them how much better I am for the sake of my ego.
I mean...The oranges did come here in the apples forums first saying that the orange was going to destroy the apples in purchase and player counts...
Arkata Apr 2, 2023 @ 12:37am 
Originally posted by +theo+:
story,gameplay,performance all better than tlou. +1 great game



EDIT: thread proves both fanbase are toxic I just said my opinion stop insulting each other and enjoy games you like clowns.
Never! RE4 Remake and the Original are 2 rubbish compared to TLOU!
Moogal™ Apr 2, 2023 @ 12:43am 
Originally posted by Arkata:
Originally posted by +theo+:
story,gameplay,performance all better than tlou. +1 great game



EDIT: thread proves both fanbase are toxic I just said my opinion stop insulting each other and enjoy games you like clowns.
Never! RE4 Remake and the Original are 2 rubbish compared to TLOU!

Best games ever VS not best games ever. Hard choice.
Kleerex Apr 2, 2023 @ 12:51am 
TLoU has literally same gameplay mechanics as RE4, so it definitely isn't "trash game". Too bad Sony and Naughty Dog are trying to milk TLoU "franchise" as much as possible before it dies off completely. If you want to hate on TLoU, go to TLoU 2 Metacritic page and voice your opinion there. THAT game deserves all the hate it gets and more!
REhorror Apr 2, 2023 @ 12:52am 
TLOU is just RE4 + more cinematic.
xZeik.x Apr 2, 2023 @ 1:06am 
performance RE4= 10 (PERFECT)
performance TLOU= 0 (garbage)
Peelsepuuppi Apr 2, 2023 @ 1:46am 
Originally posted by Kleerex:
TLoU has literally same gameplay mechanics as RE4, so it definitely isn't "trash game". Too bad Sony and Naughty Dog are trying to milk TLoU "franchise" as much as possible before it dies off completely. If you want to hate on TLoU, go to TLoU 2 Metacritic page and voice your opinion there. THAT game deserves all the hate it gets and more!

Same gameplay? lol. Let's look at enemy types, combat scenarios. weapon variety and customization, melee mechanics, knife play and even the new parry. Let's also look at the boss fights.

Yeah "literally" the same gameplay. You are delusional pal.

RE4 isn't just a shooter it borrows a lot from action games in it's combat design. TLOU is just a boring vanilla as hell TPS shooter when it comes to combat and has some melee weapon use too. The flow of combat is completely different.
Last edited by Peelsepuuppi; Apr 2, 2023 @ 1:51am
CupCake Apr 2, 2023 @ 2:36am 
Last of us was always overrated trash anyway pls don't compare this masterpiece to that trash
HEXEN Apr 2, 2023 @ 10:56am 
Originally posted by ToveriJuri:
Originally posted by HEXEN:

How is the gunplay not good?

How is the middling gunplay any good? It's the most milquetoast boring 3rd person shooter gunplay you could have also at least on console it felt somewhat clunky even after you leveled up your aiming stat or whatever it was called then.

Like compare TLOU combat to what we have in this game. Comparing how engaging RE4 combat is to TLOU combat these gamse might as well be from another planet.

And if it's unfair to compare TLOU to a modern game like RE4 Remake then compare it to RE5. Still loses severely in just how engaging the combat mechanics are in RE5.

It doesn't tick the survival feel from old RE games and it doesn't tick the engaging gameplay mechanics of more modern RE games. It just ticks the. This is an interesting tragic movie feel and thoughts like "these characters have an enjoyable dynamic". Telling a story is the only thing TLOU did well.

The only thing I understand from what you said is that you probably never played it. Nothing you said is applicable to TLOU and your arguments against it are so vague that anyone could could turn them around with RE 4 Remake as the subject. I never played the original version since I never owned a Playstation system but Part 1 plays like any modern AAA game I've ever played. I understand you like the gamey-ness and arcade sensibilities of RE 4 but one is not objectively better than the other since the combat in TLOU aims for a completely different flow, as you put it. It plays similar to that of The Evil Within series only much more dynamic, polished and refined. In any case, I'm not debating that TLOU is better than RE 4 since I prefer RE 4 myself (Resident Evil is my all time favorite game series after all) but I think you're seriously overlooking the former's merits.
Last edited by HEXEN; Apr 2, 2023 @ 11:08am
Peelsepuuppi Apr 2, 2023 @ 12:37pm 
Originally posted by HEXEN:
Originally posted by ToveriJuri:

How is the middling gunplay any good? It's the most milquetoast boring 3rd person shooter gunplay you could have also at least on console it felt somewhat clunky even after you leveled up your aiming stat or whatever it was called then.

Like compare TLOU combat to what we have in this game. Comparing how engaging RE4 combat is to TLOU combat these gamse might as well be from another planet.

And if it's unfair to compare TLOU to a modern game like RE4 Remake then compare it to RE5. Still loses severely in just how engaging the combat mechanics are in RE5.

It doesn't tick the survival feel from old RE games and it doesn't tick the engaging gameplay mechanics of more modern RE games. It just ticks the. This is an interesting tragic movie feel and thoughts like "these characters have an enjoyable dynamic". Telling a story is the only thing TLOU did well.

The only thing I understand from what you said is that you probably never played it.

https://psnprofiles.com/trophies/1989-the-last-of-us/ToveriJuri

Didn't read your disingenuous nonsense further.
M4N Apr 2, 2023 @ 12:43pm 
Originally posted by HEXEN:
Originally posted by Hans ✙:
TLoU - survival horror? Lol.

Survival horror isn't a badge of honor. It's a game genre.
FIFA is a fighting game.
HEXEN Apr 2, 2023 @ 1:47pm 
Originally posted by ToveriJuri:
Originally posted by HEXEN:

The only thing I understand from what you said is that you probably never played it.

https://psnprofiles.com/trophies/1989-the-last-of-us/ToveriJuri

Didn't read your disingenuous nonsense further.

3 out of 50 trophies? So you played for 15 minutes? Thanks for proving my point I guess.

In any case, if you had read the rest of my comment you'd have known I was not referring to this version as I've never played it. Many features of TLOU 2 have been ported to Part 1 since it's been remade in TLOU 2's engine. I don't know how both versions compare.
Last edited by HEXEN; Apr 2, 2023 @ 2:01pm
< >
Showing 76-90 of 112 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Mar 31, 2023 @ 8:25am
Posts: 112