For people who agree with Crowbcat's video

[Beblin]

I just wanna say especially for those people who lack some critical thinking that it's not hard to play both games and then draw your own conclusions instead of blatantly believing what Crowbcat trying to show in his lame edited video. He is pushing his false narrative and it works, because more clicks mean more money for his YouTube channel. Resident Evil 4 Remake is really trending right now so why not do it, right?

Nevertheless, the video itself didn't communicate well and it wasn't clear what he was trying to show there. Showing false comparisons and fooling his audience in such a pathetic way. Such as skipping the full intro scene with Leon in the car and Ganado. Same for the Regenerator, which he literally ignored the whole intro lab part. I can name so much more. He blatantly lies about the audio, deleting YouTube comments, and changing the title with the description of his video back and forth like a coward.

Both games have their own strengths and weaknesses and different direction, which doesn't mean "new game bad old game good reee". And speaking of people ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ RE4 Remake, those are the same RE "purists" who bashed the original Resident Evil 4 when it was released in 2004 for abandoning the classic survival horror and fixed camera angles and the game was labeled as "the death of a series". Now suddenly the same people think that the RE4 Original is their masterpiece and treat every other RE game as some kind of pile of ♥♥♥♥ for not replicating the same nostalgic experience. They are just a bunch of hypocrites who push the narrative and you monks follow them like some buggy NPCs. Play those games and compare them by yourselves. I love both games, but there's no need to insult other people because of this game or that game.

Crowbcat could have done the exact same video about RE3 Remake which is the most soulless Remake ever. He didn't even bother to make a video about Fallout 76, Battlefield 2042 or even GTA Trilogy Remastered...

Just think for yourselves.

[cikame]

No one complained like this about his Back 4 Blood comparisons.

[Lupo89]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von -iD-:

they follow the popular vote. 97% of the people dont agree with him. it generates clicks to see why their favorite influence thinks something is bad or whatever.
its the oldest trick in the youtube book.

97% wtf you taking about? his video right now has 35k up votes and 28k down votes.

[Lupo89]

I agree with Crowbcat. He makes rare and well detailed videos.

[[-iD-]]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Lupo89:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von -iD-:

they follow the popular vote. 97% of the people dont agree with him. it generates clicks to see why their favorite influence thinks something is bad or whatever.
its the oldest trick in the youtube book.

97% wtf you taking about? his video right now has 35k up votes and 28k down votes.

as if youtube bots are even something to go by.
at least on steam you have to purchase the game.

[Lupo89]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von -iD-:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Lupo89:

97% wtf you taking about? his video right now has 35k up votes and 28k down votes.

as if youtube bots are even something to go by.
at least on steam you have to purchase the game.

Ok that made no sense.

[[-iD-]]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Lupo89:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von -iD-:

as if youtube bots are even something to go by.
at least on steam you have to purchase the game.

Ok that made no sense.

in other words everyone who has bought the game, loves the game.
if he thinks its soulless then thats his take not really the overall temp of the reception made.

[Beblin]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von GoldInfinit7:

He’s trolling you guys really good and you guys letting him and making such trolling quite rewarding in terms of YouTube ad revenue. Probably giving ideas to others about making copycat YouTube about the next popular game. Maybe someday how GTA6 is soulless compared to GTA5.

Lol it already happened with GTA 4 being better than GTA 5.

[Apox]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von -iD-:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Apox:

where do u take this random number ?

store page.

sure and we all know there are no fanboys, boomer with nostlagic feelings , or buyed reviews very good way to study numbers

[[-iD-]]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Apox:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von -iD-:

store page.

sure and we all know there are no fanboys, boomer with nostlagic feelings , or buyed reviews very good way to study numbers

oh so now they are paid reviews? copium much?

you cant usually get 97% of the people to agree on anything, but in this case they all agree the game is good. none of them are paid and even if 1000 of them were paid it wouldn't change the numbers.

two things we know for a fact, the sales are extremely good and steam users think the game is better than the old one.

[psychedelic000]

Why is it fanboys can never critique the things they like?

crowbcat's premise is correct (not the soulless part) the ost in new re games is quit af. that doesn't make it bad its just some people like the old osts of re games. for me i will always remember re1,re2,re3, and cvx as the best osts in re franchise history.
The newer re games (ost wise not gameplay) are disappointing. The only time i remember hearing an ost in Re4r is the generic action music and the save theme.(which is quiet af.) Re2r is the same. Very quiet most of the original sounds were just deleted.

Overall i like re4r much better than re4og but that is because of the gameplay and not the ost.

[Beblin]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von psychedelic000:

Why is it fanboys can never critique the things they like?

crowbcat's premise is correct (not the soulless part) the ost in new re games is quit af. that doesn't make it bad its just some people like the old osts of re games. for me i will always remember re1,re2,re3, and cvx as the best osts in re franchise history.
The newer re games (ost wise not gameplay) are disappointing. The only time i remember hearing an ost in Re4r is the generic action music and the save theme.(which is quiet af.) Re2r is the same. Very quiet most of the original sounds were just deleted.

Overall i like re4r much better than re4og but that is because of the gameplay and not the ost.

There are no such games that aren't open to criticism and RE4R is one of them. Any game can be critiqued whether you're a fanboy or not regardless of any franchise. But it doesn't mean he must push this "new game bad, old game good" narrative which doesn't work always. The main issue with his video is cherry-picked blatantly edited comparisons that don't represent the reality of the game. And it's obvious that he clearly labels RE4R as "soulless" which is quite far-fetched.

[Draza]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von cikame:

No one complained like this about his Back 4 Blood comparisons.

You figured the reason it's happening now. Usually he goes after games that everybody already hates or are in a big controversy at the moment (B4B, CP2077) so everyone agreed with him because his videos had the coldest takes imaginable while saying very little.

Thing is, people actually like RE4R, so this time it was much easier to figure out the nature of his style of videos.

[Diabolical Taco]

It's funny. I never knew who this nub was until these couple threads, yet some of you act like this dude is somehow an authority on games. Meanwhile, I've been comfortably gaming for almost 38 years being extremely content with my game choices while disregarding game journos and so-called youtube stars left and right, and somehow continuing to enjoy the hobby.

If you hate garbage like this, the only sensible thing is don't click on the vids nor articles backed by ad revenue. The more you click and argue, the more exposure ppl like Crowbcat you empower to continue; which side you're personally on doesn't really matter. Want to win? Starve toxic nonsense like this out by ignoring it.

[Beblin]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Seraphiel:

Who the hell is Crowbat and why does anyone care what he/she has to say?

He's a YouTuber who posts videos about the gaming industry. Mostly full of criticism, compilations, comparisons, and analyses.

[Beblin]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Diabolical Taco:

It's funny. I never knew who this nub was until these couple threads, yet some of you act like this dude is somehow an authority on games. Meanwhile, I've been comfortably gaming for almost 38 years being extremely content with my game choices while disregarding game journos and so-called youtube stars left and right, and somehow continuing to enjoy the hobby.

If you hate garbage like this, the only sensible thing is don't click on the vids nor articles backed by ad revenue. The more you click and argue, the more exposure ppl like Crowbcat you empower to continue; which side you're personally on doesn't really matter. Want to win? Starve toxic nonsense like this out by ignoring it.

I like your comment a lot!

Indeed a lot of people label him as the king of the video game industry critic. I used to watch this guy because he brings very good in-depth comparisons and analysis of video games and their industry. He hasn't been posting a lot recently, while we had so many fiascos goin' on. But instead, he chose to "compare" the Remake, while there're so many other games that deserve more compilations.