I saw people talk about "Ahab" being an ID & I'm kinda curious about this.

[Pluzm]

I think some Boss dungeon being an ID need to be death first right? or not because If according to what I'm understand is ID come from extracting the abnormal , death ones, office role.

But the thing is Ahab doesn't even death yet, So she not gonna be an ID till the story more progressing and she death right? I'm I Right or Wronged about this.

[DT]

Did Molar Boat gang all dead yet? I guess wee seeing and talking with undead.

[Demonking]

Well, we have several ids based on people who aren't dead yet. Being dead isn't a requirement, it just happens to be extremely common. Hell, technically we got 2 versions of the chapter 4 boss. One of which very much before she was dead and the next we got access to just after. So, I don't believe dead is a requirement, just that it's a possibility the bus can reach. Ishmeal was pretty close to becoming just like her captain at the end there, so that's absolutely a possibility the bus can reach at this point. We didn't get any ID based on big brother himself likely because there's imply no sinner that even approaches that version of their timeline yet.

[Birp]

IDs are just alternate versions of Sinners from parallel worlds/realities. So there no hard rule that they need to die in the story for the ID to happen.

We could get an Ahab ID, and a different distorted Ahab ID maybe when we fight her again in canto 25 or w/e.

[DT]

Messaggio originale di Birp:

We could get an Ahab ID, and a different distorted Ahab ID maybe when we fight her again in canto 25 or w/e.

Let assume we got new cantos rate is around 2.5/year at best that mean at least 8-10 years before that happen. That is if game server still exist by that time.

[David Bowie Sensei]

My guess is we will get a "Normal" Ahab now and then later we will get GasHarpoon later when we fight her again.
Kinda like how we got Philip in LoR. We got his Unstable Crying Child Page and then his proper Philip Page later.

[Iggy the Unwise]

Messaggio originale di DT:

Did Molar Boat gang all dead yet? I guess wee seeing and talking with undead.

Not to be condescending, but they did die at least one time. Also, i would advice not to hype up the Ahab so it won't turn up as Farmwatch 2.0. If it releases then cool, if not hey you won't be disappointed.

[Kagarita]

I mean we have LCCB Ishmael which iirc is an ID of Saude

[Hel Spites]

Messaggio originale di Iggy the Unwise:

Messaggio originale di DT:

Did Molar Boat gang all dead yet? I guess wee seeing and talking with undead.

Not to be condescending, but they did die at least one time. Also, i would advice not to hype up the Ahab so it won't turn up as Farmwatch 2.0. If it releases then cool, if not hey you won't be disappointed.

Not in any real sense, they didn't. People who "died" in the library were put into stasis. They didn't literally resurrect when the light was released.

[Reptiloid]

It doesn't work like that.

[Ekimmak]

Messaggio originale di Iggy the Unwise:

Messaggio originale di DT:

Did Molar Boat gang all dead yet? I guess wee seeing and talking with undead.

Not to be condescending, but they did die at least one time. Also, i would advice not to hype up the Ahab so it won't turn up as Farmwatch 2.0. If it releases then cool, if not hey you won't be disappointed.

The difference is that Farmwatch belonged to someone with a real world controversy, and they already had enough of that with the Boatworks backlash.

[blindmew]

Nowhere has it been said that an ID, story related or not, has to be based off a dead person.

[gigastar]

Messaggio originale di Iggy the Unwise:

Messaggio originale di DT:

Did Molar Boat gang all dead yet? I guess wee seeing and talking with undead.

Not to be condescending, but they did die at least one time. Also, i would advice not to hype up the Ahab so it won't turn up as Farmwatch 2.0. If it releases then cool, if not hey you won't be disappointed.

That didnt 'die' after they became the Molar Boatworks.

We also have Twinhook First Mate Gregor, based on Smee who we left alive, and two LCCB IDs based on living characters.

And Dongbaek was alive when we got Heathcliffs Sunshower ID.

Also in the preview video Pequod First Mate Yi Sang makes explicit reference to Captain Ishmael.

[Demonking]

Messaggio originale di Ekimmak:

Messaggio originale di Iggy the Unwise:

Not to be condescending, but they did die at least one time. Also, i would advice not to hype up the Ahab so it won't turn up as Farmwatch 2.0. If it releases then cool, if not hey you won't be disappointed.

The difference is that Farmwatch belonged to someone with a real world controversy, and they already had enough of that with the Boatworks backlash.

Ah yes, that's a great theory. The reason we didn't get farm watch was because of the incels. I'm actually running with it whether it's true or not.

[Angela]

A better question will be, when did they tell you that we only get id's from death people?

[Zalgo]

Messaggio originale di Demonking:

Messaggio originale di Ekimmak:

The difference is that Farmwatch belonged to someone with a real world controversy, and they already had enough of that with the Boatworks backlash.

Ah yes, that's a great theory. The reason we didn't get farm watch was because of the incels. I'm actually running with it whether it's true or not.

To be fair, the IRL DongRang is almost universally hated in South KR because he betrayed them to Imperial Japan back when KR and JP were mortal enemies. This hatred is still felt today.