My rating for all 12 Sinner's base identity, doesn't take account of E.G.O

[阿夢EDDyume]

Yi Sang [Slash - Pierce - Slash]
144 HP, 28 Attack , 35 Defend , 4 - 8 Speed
[Rating : BAD]
1. Everyone get a free Yi Sang 000 Identity, who also happen to focus on Slash attack.
2. His skill is bad, sinking is not that useful at the moment.
3. His 2nd skill is weird, by right it should add 1 Sinking, which automatically add 1 count, and then apply + 1 count, making it 2 count. But when I actually use it, it still ended with 1 sinking, 1 count.
Also the effect apply on 2nd attack, which mean before you can add count to the already existed sinking debuff, your first attack will remove that debuff.
Which mean right now the only way to make use of the +1 sinking count is to attack an enemy that already has 2 count of sinking debuff, which is pretty much impossible for base identity.
4. While his 3rd Skill can inflict Fragile, it is not "at the next turn", so it expired at the end of the current turn, well Yi Sang did has a good speed so slower ally can take advantage of that.
The fragile doesn't work on Abnormality as the don't have SP, I tested it.
You learn this skill at the end of Chapter 2, and Slash is bad for Chapter 3.
5. Yi Sang attack stats is bad, so he is bad at clashing.

Faust [Blunt-Blunt-Pierce]
168 HP, 28 Attack, 35 Defend, 2 - 4 Speed
[Rating : GOOD]
1. Faust is the second slowest Sinner, this has it's pros and cons.
The pros being she doesn't need to clash with others often, because the fast Sinner will take most of the clash away, which is good since Faust attack stats is bad, hence she is bad at clashing.
The cons being the paralysis on her 1st attack is pretty much useless, this Paralysis doesn't get apply on next turn, it get apply this turn, mean it just gone at the start of next turn. And she pretty much apply it after all the fight is over.
2. What make Faust so good were her 2nd and 3rd skill. 2nd skill make enemy deal less damage, and 3rd skill reduce enemy power level, her 3rd skill guarantee -1 power on hit and another -1 if she roll head so it goes up to -2 Power. Inflicting -2 on Boss pretty much mean all your Sinner get +2 Power, which is HUGE.
3. Super easy to active passive (2 Pride) that just grant +10% damage most of the time.
4. Being a Blunt focus Sinner mean good unit for Chapter 3.

Don Quixote [P-P-P]
132 HP, 36 Attack, 28 Defend, 3 - 6 Speed
[Rating: BAD]
1. Very aggressive stats, her kit involving winning clash to gain buff, then finish opponent with her 3rd Skill.
2. Her kit build around winning clash, but here is the thing, her 1st and 2nd skill both only has 1 coin, which is so bad for clash, combine with her low health low defense, she get stagger immediately and then just...dead.
3. She focus mainly of Pierce, which is only good for like 3 stage at Chapter 2, and those stage is not even hard.
4. Don
5. Her Passive is good though, giving +10% damage in a winning clash that is easy to active.
6. Her skill has low base coin power, so it's pretty much a gambling to play with her.

RyoShu [S-S-S]
132 HP, 36 Attack, 28 Defend, 3 - 6 Speed
[Rating: GOOD]
1. Same aggressive stats as Don, but her attack skill are more easy to win clash and does more damage easily.
2. Her passive is a double-edge sword that increase damage dealt and damage taken by 25%.
3. Very good during Chapter 2.

MeurSault [B-B-B]
180 HP, 26 Attack, 38 Defend, 2 - 3 Speed
[Rating: BAD]
1. He has the highest health and defense, so he is a tank, but what actually is a tank?
2. Tank need to pull aggro from the enemies, but Meur has the slowest speed, so he can't even pull any aggro, and defensive skill in this game doesn't work like Library of Ruina, in LoR, defensive skill can re-direct enemy attack if your speed is higher. In this game however, you can't re-direct enemy attack with defensive skill even if your speed is higher. In short, Meur skill suck.
3. Tremor is also bad right now, it does have scary potential in the future, but for now it suck. However, Meur slow speed does make him the best Tremor burster, because the fast ally can apply Tremor and Meur Burst it.
4. While I give him a bad rating, he is actually good to use if you take account of his E.G.O. His E.G.O is the best debuff skill against boss, pretty much make the boss harmless if you build your team to spam his E.G.O.

Hong Lu [B-S-B]
132 HP, 36 Attack, 28 Defend, 3 - 6 Speed
[Rating: GOOD]
1. Has same stats as Don and Ryoshu, so an aggressive attacker, which is really strong as long as he doesn't take damage.
2. His kit involving using passive to raise his SP, which raising the chance of getting head, and his skill increase head coin power.
3. Has a chance to inflict Attack Power down with his 3rd Skill, which is powerful.
4. His 2nd skill inflict sinking and proc it immediately with 2nd attack.
5. Good Blunt unit for chapter 3.

Heathcliff [B-B-B]
156 HP, 33 Attack, 30 Defend, 2-5 Speed
[Rating: GOOD]
1. Surprisingly he doesn't go all out on attack stats, great blunt unit with a bit of bulk for chapter 3.
2. Smackdown is such a great skill, guarantee buff for next turn.
3. Tremor is really meh for now, can just ignore it.
4. Passive require 5 Envy resonance, which require very specific team building.

Ishmael [B-B-B]
156 HP, 31 Attack, 32 Defend, 5-8 Speed
[Rating: NORMAL]
1. Fastest Sinner on the Limbus, decent health and defend, now this is the real tank that can re-direct enemy attack.
2. All her skill has 1 coin, which is bad, but good thing they have high base power.
3. Her skill effect is interesting but bad, her 1st skill, apply +1 Tremor count. But because she is so fast and she often attack first, you can just read that as "inflict 1 Tremor", pretty much the same.
4. Her 2nd skill can do a little bit of work on abnormality fight, the condition is a bit annoying, not only the enemy has to be attacking and defending at the same turn, you need to actually win a clash to inflict the 3 defense power down, which I have to remind you, all her skill only has 1 coin.
5. Her 3rd skill is interesting with that Blunt Fragility, I'm not sure how much it increase, but it's extra damage, and with Ishmael high speed you can do an unoppossed attack to inflict that blunt fragility first.
6. Her Passive might come in handy in tough situation, it is easy to proc with only 2 Wrath, and it give +1 clash power which is huge, the requirement being under 25% hp.

Rodion [S-S-S]
156 HP, 33 Attack, 30 Defend, 2-5 Speed
[Rating: GOOD]
1. Pretty much Heathcliff but for Slash.
2. Bleed is just some extra damage.
3. Her 3rd skill is a bit hard to use since you often stay at higher than 0 SP, but it's great on first turn and good even without the bonus.
4. Good for Chapter 2.

Sinclair [S-S-S]
120 HP, 38 Attack, 25 Defend, 3-7 Speed
[Rating: GOOD]
1. I didn't even know Sinclair and Outis shared the most Aggressive stats line.
2. He has 2 skill with 3 coin, both with decent base power.
3. He just does a lot of damage, very useful on chapter 2.

Outis [P-S-P]
120 HP, 38 Attack, 25 Defend, 3-7 Speed
[Rating: NORMAL]
1. Her kit is amazing, she is only one whos first skill has more than 1 coin, which she has 3. And her 2nd skill has 2 coin, combine with her highest attack stats among other sinner, she has easy time winning clash.
2. The only thing dragging her rating down is that she is a pierce unit which doesn't give her a lot of place to shine.

Gregor [S-P-P]
144 HP, 31 Attack, 32 Defend, 3-7 Speed
[Rating: BAD]
1. He is pierce unit, and both his 1st and 2nd skill only has 1 coin, with bad base power.
2. The banner currently has his 000 Identity and it's amazing.
3. Most of the skill effect require head coin, basically a do big or nothing character.

[RedCobra]

ryoshu is great character. she hit like a truck even without passive.

her second skill If target previously took damage this turn, deal +30%2x damage,
target mean the enemy, so you need other sinner deal damage to target first then ryoshu deal damage to the same target using her second skill to trigger that juicy 30% damage boost.

her passive does not active all the time you need to chain 3x green to activate it in battle, so you kinda ignore it all the time, there is no danger if the passive not active.

base rodion is free 2 star hongl lu. she deserve S tier, for me, its kinda funny her kit is similar.

[阿夢EDDyume]

Originally posted by RedCobra:

ryoshu is great character. she hit like a truck even without passive.

her second skill If target previously took damage this turn, deal +30%2x damage,
target mean the enemy, so you need other sinner deal damage to target first then ryoshu deal damage to the same target using her second skill to trigger that juicy 30% damage boost.

her passive does not active all the time you need to chain 3x green to activate it in battle, so you kinda ignore it all the time, there is no danger if the passive not active.

base rodion is free 2 star hongl lu. she deserve S tier, for me, its kinda funny her kit is similar.

Wait I put RyoShu at Normal? Okay my bad, I remember putting her at Good, I change the rating, I agree that RyoShu is good.

[Atma]

Originally posted by 阿夢EDDDyum:

4. Don

wut

[Naransolongo Boldbayer]

Any ratings for their support passives? I've gotten surprising use out of base Gregor's Gene code for healing when coupled with the odd Pursuance or Impending day kill

[阿夢EDDyume]

Originally posted by Naransolongo Boldbayer:

Any ratings for their support passives? I've gotten surprising use out of base Gregor's Gene code for healing when coupled with the odd Pursuance or Impending day kill

Yeah that Gene Code is handy when you're using Gloom Team, but no rating for that as Support Passive are kind of independent themselves.
I just focus on if Sinner does well in the battle.

[Fhoenix]

Outis 0 had been my mvp in many Mirror Dungeon until I've uptied Hong Lu 00. She is definitely above normal.

[RedCobra]

Sinking is weird and not working technically because enemies always start at 10 sanity and when get drain red to 0 level never get up / build up to blue again it become useless when vs human. except to abnormality enemies, it become work like other damage buff but make your gloom strong per stack of sinking.