Teddy Jr. (major spoilers)

[klyrner]

Just replayed this (awesome) game for the third time, and this time my plan was to let everyone involved in the coverup die, and save everyone who wasn’t. Went great and seemed the most cinematic, until the end… Of course I want THE most guilty of everybody, Teddy Jr., to bite it, so tried to screw up the interview, and nothing happened, then guessed the wrong location. Dawn kills him.. good, but then Peggy shows up. Despite me holding and mentioning the card, Dawn kills Peggy anyways!! Interesting deviation in that Henry enters the booth to kill me but doesn’t as the police arrive, but this is awful!!

Why the hell is the WORST guy’s fate tied to Peggy’s? That makes no sense to design it that way, to me. What a bummer.

Unless I’m wrong and there’s a way to do this differently? It didn’t seem possible to actually botch the interview.

[Musica_Optima]

I suppose it's a "logical" result of the events. I mean, you can't stop Peggy from leaving KFAM to see Dawn.
And since Dawn kills Teddy in this version, Peggy is an eye witness that has to be disposed of.
At least that's how I would explain it.

[Minemonkey166]

Originally posted by Musica_Optima:

I suppose it's a "logical" result of the events. I mean, you can't stop Peggy from leaving KFAM to see Dawn.
And since Dawn kills Teddy in this version, Peggy is an eye witness that has to be disposed of.
At least that's how I would explain it.

Didn't Marie already admit it was her though, on the radio? I think the lack of an eye witness doesn't really matter at that point

[DarthRL]

Don't know why but in my playthrough, he died and Peggy survived.

[Versalico]

Originally posted by DarthRL:

Don't know why but in my playthrough, he died and Peggy survived.

Same here. Actually Teddy Jr was the only one who died in my playthrough and seemed like a positive outcome.

In order to save Peggy you need to interact with the birthday card in her desktop and I think purposely stall Dawn/Marie conversation rerouting the conversation with minor topics before asking the relevant questions, i.e. asking about how she felt, about Eugene Sharpe, etc

That gives the cops enough time to arrive on the scene and save Peg.

[klyrner]

How much anyone want to bet you can’t recreate my play through and have Peggy survive?