Store Page
Ib
All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews
Ib > General Discussions > Topic Details
karya Apr 11, 2022 @ 10:16am
garry doesn't accept the handkerchief
WHY DOESN'T GARRY ACCEPT MY HANDKERCHIEF I'M ON MY SECOND RUN TO SECRET ENDING AND HE DOESN'T TAKE IT EVEN THOUGH I GIVE IT TO HIM I'M ABOUT TO DO SOME BAD THINGS TO THIS MAN

edit. you can check the solution below

i also did these for extra
- said i had a nightmare in the safe room
- talked with him every room by pressing e a lot
- i didn't agree with mary about the bunny picture ( but did every other thing to make a good relationship with her )

and on my first play the ring was behind the human statue, on my second and third play which he didn't accept the handkerchief the ring was behind the tree statue and on my forth play which he finally accepted the handkerchief the ring was behind the skeleton statue ,, i don't know if it was a sign of the true process but i wanted to share
Last edited by karya; Apr 14, 2022 @ 4:20am
The author of this topic has marked a post as the answer to their question.
Click here to jump to that post.
Originally posted by yon_shi:
GUYS, Garry accept handkerchief in my 3rd attempt! So having slap definitely not important (in this time I was won in doll room). So what I do:

1. Going to the blue rooms and talking with him in every room at least once (in different part in the same room dialog can change)
2. Read some art name
3. Garry having slap from hiding woman in hide-and-sick room :D
4. Talkin' with ant and 4-legged stand
5. Asking Garry for touching niddle cat before me
6. Don't use "................" answer for his questions
7. Continued talking in every room and checking some staff (like book's shelf, manekens. ets)
8. Make with Mary good relationship (said than I want go with her, we be okay without Garry, ets)
9. Don't break anything
10. Give him coat, talking in safe room and under sun, talking about pudding)
11. Give him handkerchief.

Maybe Ib should more talking with him by press E? I not sure what thing important. Going to start it's the only thing than I didn't di in my second attempt (And Garry refused, eh)
< >
Showing 1-15 of 25 comments
yon_shi Apr 11, 2022 @ 11:41am 
Are you talking with him enough? like 6-8 time in room where you can give him his coat and under sun in Mary sketchbook. For now i can't exactly say what kind of act make your friendchip with him stronger, but talking defenitely important
#1
karya Apr 11, 2022 @ 1:19pm 
Originally posted by yon_shi:
Are you talking with him enough? like 6-8 time in room where you can give him his coat and under sun in Mary sketchbook. For now i can't exactly say what kind of act make your friendchip with him stronger, but talking defenitely important
yes i talked to him in the room he gave us candy like 15+ times and under the sun i talked to him at least 6 times surely ,, i even played again from the beginning to talk to him more but he didn't accept the handkerchief HE SAID IT'S IMPORTANT AND I SHOULD KEEP IT .. LIKE the first time i played he accepted and now he's being a killjoy
#2
Remiru Saiki Apr 11, 2022 @ 1:43pm 
kill his family and everyone he loves
#3
Ennashad Apr 11, 2022 @ 3:33pm 
1. talk many (not sure but originally affects)
2. give him coat and talk(when ib fell and wake up)
3. choose proper answer(like when doll, when blackout, when hurt)
4. talking from sun(sketchbook)

and also stop garry break something may affects too.
#4
MakKoeda Apr 11, 2022 @ 5:33pm 
SAMEEEE, I BEEN HOURS LOOKING FOR ANSWERS AND NOTHING
#5
Ennashad Apr 11, 2022 @ 5:59pm 
not sure but, more thing can affects i concern,

1. first time meet garry, can go back to room before you meet garry has conversation.
2. that needle neko block door. garry tell Ib choose name. me choose first one. and also
you can choose garry trying to touch needle neko.
#6
karya Apr 11, 2022 @ 10:51pm 
Originally posted by nekomiru:
kill his family and everyone he loves
i'll give him one last chance and if doesn't take my handkerchief again that'll be exactly what i am gonna do
#7
karya Apr 11, 2022 @ 10:54pm 
Originally posted by Ennashad:
1. talk many (not sure but originally affects)
2. give him coat and talk(when ib fell and wake up)
3. choose proper answer(like when doll, when blackout, when hurt)
4. talking from sun(sketchbook)

and also stop garry break something may affects too.
believe me i did everything you said .. i did this route on the first game countless times and even in this version he accepted it on my first play but now he doesn't take it ??
#8
karya Apr 11, 2022 @ 10:55pm 
Originally posted by Ennashad:
not sure but, more thing can affects i concern,

1. first time meet garry, can go back to room before you meet garry has conversation.
2. that needle neko block door. garry tell Ib choose name. me choose first one. and also
you can choose garry trying to touch needle neko.
i never tried that needle neko block door thing before ,, well i'll try it on my next play thanks
#9
karya Apr 11, 2022 @ 11:01pm 
Originally posted by MakKoeda:
SAMEEEE, I BEEN HOURS LOOKING FOR ANSWERS AND NOTHING
REALLY ?? YOU'RE ON YOUR SECOND RUN TOO ??? HE JUST MADE ME ANGRY EVEN MORE I USED TO LIKE THIS MAN .. AND I THOUGHT LIKE MAYBE IN THE SECRET ROOMS THE CREATORS ADDED SOMETHING NEW AND SOMETHING WILL HAPPEN AGAIN causing garry getting wounded so we can give the handkerchief to him this time but nope .. and like i'm not japanese and i played this game for three freaking times
#10
yon_shi Apr 12, 2022 @ 3:44am 
What about talking with him by pressing E? I did it in every room actually in first try. And yeah. after replaing he didn't want take it. Hmm...
Last edited by yon_shi; Apr 12, 2022 @ 4:49am
#11
karya Apr 12, 2022 @ 7:15am 
Originally posted by yon_shi:
What about talking with him by pressing E? I did it in every room actually in first try. And yeah. after replaing he didn't want take it. Hmm...
i guess the only answer is that garry is a jerk in this game
#12
supergod7777 Apr 12, 2022 @ 1:50pm 
have you tried slapping garry in the boue doll room? that did the trick for me
#13
karya Apr 13, 2022 @ 2:54am 
Originally posted by supergod7777:
have you tried slapping garry in the boue doll room? that did the trick for me
HOW CAN WE SLAP HIM.... WHICH ROOM EXACTLY ??
#14
karya Apr 13, 2022 @ 2:57am 
Originally posted by 📂:
Originally posted by supergod7777:
have you tried slapping garry in the boue doll room? that did the trick for me
HOW CAN WE SLAP HIM.... WHICH ROOM EXACTLY ??
wait a minute you mean the room he needs to find a key ?? i never failed in that room before ..
#15
< >
Showing 1-15 of 25 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Ib > General Discussions > Topic Details
Date Posted: Apr 11, 2022 @ 10:16am
Posts: 25

Discussions Rules and Guidelines