[SPOIL] Joel and Ellie

[Pytchoun]

Why Ellie is angry against Joel at the end ?

[Drothen]

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

Why Ellie is angry against Joel at the end ?

because all their hard work was for nothing after he took her away from the lab, for no other reason than him needing her.
she did not believe him.

[Pytchoun]

Originally posted by Drothen:

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

Why Ellie is angry against Joel at the end ?

because all their hard work was for nothing after he took her away from the lab, for no other reason than him needing her.
she did not believe him.

need for what ?
he save her life...

[Drothen]

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

Originally posted by Drothen:

because all their hard work was for nothing after he took her away from the lab, for no other reason than him needing her.
she did not believe him.

need for what ?
he save her life...

she was willing to give up her life for the cure

[MishaTX]

Originally posted by Drothen:

she was willing to give up her life for the cure

Thing is, none of the Fireflies, including Dr. Mengele, ever bothered to let her know that they were going to kill her so she could *really* make the choice.

Later, in Part 2, she DOES say that she would have, but nobody asked her then, which makes them utter monsters, in my opinion. And I completely understand Joel's choice. If somebody were to tell me "hey, we're going to kill your child, but it's for the Greater Good. Maybe. If it works", they'd become really well acquainted with my Texan arsenal in a hurry, and not in a good way.

[theSirBartholomew]

The thing is, there's absolutely no way that a vaccine would've been widely distributed. The Fireflies wouldn't give it to anyone in FEDRA, if FEDRA got a hold of it, they would only provide it the people they deemed "worthy" of it. There was no "world saving" choice at the end of the day. Joel acted on emotion and definitely did not think about these points before massacring that hospital but, at the end of the day, his choice ensured Ellie could live a life and that he wouldn't be alone again

[Pytchoun]

Originally posted by Drothen:

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

need for what ?
he save her life...

she was willing to give up her life for the cure

why i didn't see that

[Pytchoun]

Originally posted by MishaTX:

Originally posted by Drothen:

she was willing to give up her life for the cure

Thing is, none of the Fireflies, including Dr. Mengele, ever bothered to let her know that they were going to kill her so she could *really* make the choice.

Later, in Part 2, she DOES say that she would have, but nobody asked her then, which makes them utter monsters, in my opinion. And I completely understand Joel's choice. If somebody were to tell me "hey, we're going to kill your child, but it's for the Greater Good. Maybe. If it works", they'd become really well acquainted with my Texan arsenal in a hurry, and not in a good way.

she can do it later if she want it

[Drothen]

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

Originally posted by Drothen:

she was willing to give up her life for the cure

why i didn't see that

yeah, on the offtopic, glad to see Lara in your avatar, are you excited for the new Tomb raider game ?

[wolfinston85]

She's angry? It's more like she's dubitative. You want to see her angry with him, play the second game.

[J4MESOX4D]

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

Originally posted by MishaTX:

Thing is, none of the Fireflies, including Dr. Mengele, ever bothered to let her know that they were going to kill her so she could *really* make the choice.

Later, in Part 2, she DOES say that she would have, but nobody asked her then, which makes them utter monsters, in my opinion. And I completely understand Joel's choice. If somebody were to tell me "hey, we're going to kill your child, but it's for the Greater Good. Maybe. If it works", they'd become really well acquainted with my Texan arsenal in a hurry, and not in a good way.

she can do it later if she want it

Too bad Joel butchered all the doctors..

[Drothen]

Originally posted by J4MESOX4D:

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

she can do it later if she want it

Too bad Joel butchered all the doctors..

truee

[Pytchoun]

Originally posted by Drothen:

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

why i didn't see that

yeah, on the offtopic, glad to see Lara in your avatar, are you excited for the new Tomb raider game ?

Yes i am. where you see what ellie wanted

[Pytchoun]

Originally posted by wolfinston85:

She's angry? It's more like she's dubitative. You want to see her angry with him, play the second game.

i don't have ps5

[Pytchoun]

Originally posted by J4MESOX4D:

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

she can do it later if she want it

Too bad Joel butchered all the doctors..

what? how ?

[Just Chill]

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

Originally posted by Drothen:

yeah, on the offtopic, glad to see Lara in your avatar, are you excited for the new Tomb raider game ?

Yes i am. where you see what ellie wanted

I remember your cryptic posts already from Hogwarts Legacy hub. ^^
Nice to see you here too and I am glad you enjoy the game.

I've just finished my grounded playthrough and even though I remembered a lot from my PS4-experiences, the enemies felt a lot smarter.
As of getting flanked a whole more often and annoyingly shot from beind. XD

Originally posted by Pytchoun:

what? how ?

When you save Ellie, you must shoot the doctor.
I am not sure about the nurses, but I let Joel make no compromises and shot them too. :O