neve only one who can not become hero of veilguard?

[CosminCh]

am i missing something or is neve the only one who can have her hero of the veilguard choice disabled? i'm doing my first 100% run of the game and everyone except her became hero of veilguard (mostly because i missunderstood the choice being disabled thing... which only appeared for her apparently), because if it is, that's extreemly annoying since i played alot to get the best ending and it might be ruined...

[Ave]

Whoever is "hardened" from the first big choice in this game CANNOT become veil guard

[Mysteria]

Neve’s hero status didn’t unlock after the mission where I thought it should, but she eventually did get it. Maybe do a few more of her storyline quests, unless you really have none left.

[CosminCh]

Originally posted by Ave:

Whoever is "hardened" from the first big choice in this game CANNOT become veil guard

you lose (which means disabled) the hero choice if you decide to accept the Threads help ,

but i didn't see that possibility of having it disabled on any other chars...which is kind of an annoying game dev decision imo... cause i don't wanna do the game over again just for that singular one wrong choice... ugh

[DaisyRay]

I think you have to just talk to her. I thought this too, but I eventually got it after some quests and talks. Make sure you do all the quests in her home too. Quests still popped up after and I did them all.

[CosminCh]

Originally posted by DaisyRay:

I think you have to just talk to her. I thought this too, but I eventually got it after some quests and talks. Make sure you do all the quests in her home too. Quests still popped up after and I did them all.

my playstyle is to do every side quest before advancing the main story (including going back and forth the light house so more dialogues/quests appear until they dont), i do hope you're right and it'll eventually pop up, fingers crossed

[DaisyRay]

Originally posted by CosminCh:

Originally posted by DaisyRay:

I think you have to just talk to her. I thought this too, but I eventually got it after some quests and talks. Make sure you do all the quests in her home too. Quests still popped up after and I did them all.

my playstyle is to do every side quest before advancing the main story (including going back and forth the light house so more dialogues/quests appear until they dont), i do hope you're right and it'll eventually pop up, fingers crossed

I wish I could fully remember because it just happened. I remember finishing her story and she was the only one who didn't immediately get the veilguard hero logo. I got scared, but I couldn't find any info about it online. So I just kept going through normal missions and checking Minrathous for new quests. When I found them, I brought her with me and kept checking back at the lighthouse to speak to her.

Then after one of our talks she thanked me for the help and bam, she was loyal.

[Zebedee]

Neve was hardened and I accepted the Threads help and she still was a hero before the final mission. She did take longer than others, as Mysteria and DaisyRay had happen too.

[Sythia]

Interesting discussion. I saved Minrathous, and I noticed Lucanis wasn't getting the Hero status after seemingly his last companion quest, so I assumed it was because he was hardened.

I know a few of the other characters didn't get their Hero status until a conversation or outing after their last "real" quest (with combat and such). Maybe that changes for Neve and Lucanis based on the hardening; so maybe there's still hope for him too, who knows - though at this point I've got Hero on all my other companions.

[Arngrim]

You do not need all as hero to get the best ending.
You can get all of them to hero, as long as you do all their quests.
Hardening only forces them into one of the two endings for their personal quets.

[silver_hyena]

I chose Treviso and to work with the Threads and still got Neve her veilguard status. It doesn't happen in the quest where she makes what I assume would be a choice in a playthrough where you chose Minrathous, but after.

[CosminCh]

phew, thank god, i got her to hero aswell, unexpectedly, in a random orange conversation event (which is weird seeing how everyone else got after clearing their personal missions), but pfew, i'm feeling relieved ^^" so don't lose hope ppl

[DaisyRay]

Originally posted by CosminCh:

phew, thank god, i got her to hero aswell, unexpectedly, in a random orange conversation event (which is weird seeing how everyone else got after clearing their personal missions), but pfew, i'm feeling relieved ^^" so don't lose hope ppl

Yay! ;p I'm glad to hear it. Lol I agree, it was really random.

[LoVeSuns]

Yeah, all characters can get the hero status, even the hardened one. As far as I could tell, you just have to do all of their quests (but maybe there are other requirements like a certain relationship level and giving them their gift).

[RiskyBiscuit]

Originally posted by Ave:

Whoever is "hardened" from the first big choice in this game CANNOT become veil guard

Not true, just make sure you go to the lighthouse regularly and talk. It's ridiculous that it's this way but make sure you check in after the mission. It could take a few tries.