Idol Showdown

Idol Showdown

Rally Rat 2023 年 5 月 8 日 上午 10:51
7
2
2
garbage Kusoge
this is a 2 touch game with combos that you have to sit thru and have only a mediocre burst as the only defense option, as instant block does nothing to help the defender. hitboxes and balance are completely busted to the point where most matchups are not even worth trying in (botan/ ayame are too dominant).

There is no room for intelligent play and with a magic series system, identifying times to take your turn back either are nonexistent or immensely ambiguous. This leads to the attacker continuously taking turns over and over without ever having to return to neutral or deviating from their flowcharts.

The modes are also terribly implemented. Whatever form of rollback is in here is embarrassing to see and matchmaking and lobbies are a sad display. Training mode also has many issues, without neccessary information being not included or tucked away in menus.

I applaud the team for making a game that is visually beautiful and their passion for the Hololive talents is evident, but the game needs a deep and thoughtful look into its systems in order to make it into a piece that evokes more than a facepalm the moment you go against another player.
< >
正在显示第 16 - 30 条,共 33 条留言
Eilanzer 2023 年 5 月 9 日 下午 11:33 
Amazing when a bad player try to justify stuff in a f.ing F2P game....F2P! F 2 P !!!!!!!~
Just have fun or gtfo ¬¬
Tyrone Biggums 2023 年 5 月 10 日 上午 12:42 
引用自 Rally Rat
this is a 2 touch game with combos that you have to sit thru and have only a mediocre burst as the only defense option, as instant block does nothing to help the defender. hitboxes and balance are completely busted to the point where most matchups are not even worth trying in (botan/ ayame are too dominant).

There is no room for intelligent play and with a magic series system, identifying times to take your turn back either are nonexistent or immensely ambiguous. This leads to the attacker continuously taking turns over and over without ever having to return to neutral or deviating from their flowcharts.

The modes are also terribly implemented. Whatever form of rollback is in here is embarrassing to see and matchmaking and lobbies are a sad display. Training mode also has many issues, without neccessary information being not included or tucked away in menus.

I applaud the team for making a game that is visually beautiful and their passion for the Hololive talents is evident, but the game needs a deep and thoughtful look into its systems in order to make it into a piece that evokes more than a facepalm the moment you go against another player.

im assuming your trolling or this is your first FG or both
sakuya #てへぺりんこ 2023 年 5 月 10 日 上午 2:22 
Thanks for the copypasta and scrubquotes material
EcchiSketch 2023 年 5 月 10 日 上午 2:34 
引用自 bloodreddragon6
What's more confusing is that the burst can only be recharged by getting hit instead of having it recharge during the course of the match on top of getting hit.
This and the lack of a push block are probably my biggest issues with the game's defense systems.

As for the balance issues, it's a small team and this is a passion project no way were they gonna have this decently balanced on launch.
Hell, even fight game devs with bigger teams still release heavily unbalanced stuff, and fix it as time goes by. It's hard to test for all the possible crazy interactions.

That said the devs have been releasing many small hotfixes and are working on it as fast as they can.
最后由 EcchiSketch 编辑于; 2023 年 5 月 10 日 上午 2:49
MechaDeka 2023 年 5 月 10 日 上午 5:12 
"I applaud the team for making a game that is visually beautiful "
Why does everyone keep saying this? Have you seen Korone's baby's first Mugen character idle animation?
jaxter0987 2023 年 5 月 10 日 上午 10:19 
"this is a 2 touch game with combos that you have to sit thru"
What a terrible way to open up your post even if you do have some legitimate criticisms later. From what I've seen, its more a 3 touch game and this is TYPICAL of anime fighters. Strive is basically a 3 touch game unless you're Chip. In fact, most anime fighters are roughly 3 touch games so actual skill issue. Clearly anime fighters are not for you. Play Street Fighter or some other fighting game where the emphasis is on footsies instead.

"combos you have to sit thru"
Once again, this is standard fare for anime fighters. Long combo routes with lots of scaling damage is normal. I don't think the combo lengths in this game are egregious anyway. The top tier combo routes I've seen are just average in terms of duration when compared to other anime fighters.

"identifying times to take your turn back either are nonexistent or immensely ambiguous"
Mostly a skill issue. I won't deny the possibility that some characters are just ridiculously stronger than others but this is a freaking 5 day old game at this point. It's more likely a skill issue that you can't identify when to attempt to take back turns. You can't possibly argue that most match ups in this game are so lopsided that its a character balance issue rather than a skill issue.

Now for actual valid criticisms, the defensive options do seem to be lacking as IB doesn't seem rewarding enough and burst only refilling on getting hit doesn't make sense. Burst should be slowly regen'd over time and also regained faster as you get hit.

Training mode is indeed lacking. Stuff being tucked away in menus is fine but the menus for Training mode itself is pretty horrible to navigate.
Sutera 2023 年 5 月 10 日 下午 3:41 
Show your fighting game hours
pseudo 2023 年 5 月 10 日 下午 6:18 
引用自 Eilanzer
Amazing when a bad player try to justify stuff in a f.ing F2P game....F2P! F 2 P !!!!!!!~
Just have fun or gtfo ¬¬
ngl man f2p games can do bad things but still have players invested in them so much that they can't leave but are compelled to moan about it
*cough* league *cough*

Definitely doesn't apply to this game tho.
最后由 pseudo 编辑于; 2023 年 5 月 10 日 下午 6:18
orange dog 2023 年 5 月 14 日 上午 5:13 
You have burst, use it.
76561199398365904 2023 年 5 月 14 日 上午 6:48 
Some valid complaints but your expectations are way too high from the handful of devs who made this and aren't making money off of it. They might add more defensive mechanics later. Balancing and bug fixing should be easy and quick with the small roster. They might even intentionally make things unbalanced if that's their vision, who knows.
Valy 2023 年 5 月 14 日 上午 7:23 
Its a meme game, and it being a kusoge is part of the joke. But the punchline is that the game is actually well made
sinkpisser 2023 年 5 月 14 日 上午 9:46 
who cares game is free just like you
KingDragoon 2023 年 5 月 14 日 上午 10:31 
who cares game is free just like you
Finally some common sense lmao
76561199187943745 2023 年 5 月 14 日 下午 2:56 
who cares game is free just like you
You do because you don't want it to die.
pseudo 2023 年 5 月 14 日 下午 3:05 
引用自 HeadshotMaker69
Its a meme game, and it being a kusoge is part of the joke. But the punchline is that the game is actually well made
^
this the real common sense right here
< >
正在显示第 16 - 30 条,共 33 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

发帖日期: 2023 年 5 月 8 日 上午 10:51
回复数: 33