Is this game better than Honkai Star Rail?

[Patrick Wayne]

HSR was inspired by this game and is doing very well. Since I enjoy HSR I was wondering if I should get Persona 5. Is it on the same level as HSR or even better?

[Apollyon]

both of them are better, but p5r is the best one (in my opinion)

before that, do you like heavy dialogue with a lot of cutscene JRPG? i dont know how you play HSR and i dont know if you skip the dialouge in HSR but if you hate that, then dont download this. Its pretty annoying for dumb people like that who complaint about the game without research

ANNNNDDD THE OBBBBVVVIOUSSSSSS DIFFERENCE IS P5R doesnt HAVE A FKING GACHA WHERE YOU HAVE TO SPEND MORE THAN 1000$ FOR ONE 5* CHARACTER

[Lunlian]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Patrick Wayne:

HSR was inspired by this game and is doing very well. Since I enjoy HSR I was wondering if I should get Persona 5. Is it on the same level as HSR or even better?

for short:
this game isnt like HSR but the game is worth it for sure, i like both hsr and genshin and i love p5r so yea go for it, play it first before P5 Strikers or P5 tactics since P5R is like the starting point and the rest are like continuation

For long:
if u have a decent pc then go for it, this game isn't the same as HSR but it has some amazing feature such as the "time feature" where you are limited to do 3 things a day and have tons of stuff you wanna do on that day for example working on urself or hanging out with one of the characters in the game or going to school or working to gather money, and more, the story also makes you feel like you don't have much time since you will also be going to palaces a lot but the story is 100% worth it, for the fighting mechanism its the same but also not, you have persona's to catch or to fuse and create new persona's, these persona's help you defeat enimes and some can be supporters and some can be attackers and each one has it's own "elements" fire, water, etc, pulling isnt something here and if you want more characters you need to progress in the game, if you want to start persona i would recommend persona 5 royal or the og persona 5, they are the same except the royal is a remake and has more stuff to do and i think an extra character

in the end if you think it's better or not then it depends on you, some people would prefer this over HSR or the other way, i love both so i would recommend this

[Sandy]

I would say HSR.

[собачий вантуз]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Lunlian:

Początkowo opublikowane przez Patrick Wayne:

if u have a decent pc

Isn't the game runs on potato perfectly too? I mean original P5 was released on PS3, and P5R came out even on Nintendo Switch

[Just end trashbag.]

Początkowo opublikowane przez собачий вантуз:

Początkowo opublikowane przez Lunlian:

Isn't the game runs on potato perfectly too? I mean original P5 was released on PS3, and P5R came out even on Nintendo Switch

Only runs if you have avx and sse 4.2. No avx and sse 4.2 sega give middle finger and "i dont care" to your face.

Still hate the avx btw. Waste of my patience back then.

[alumlovescake]

Yes because it doesn't cost 2 THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR ONE CHARACTER

[Johnathon Fortnite]

Początkowo opublikowane przez alumlovescake:

Yes because it doesn't cost 2 THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR ONE CHARACTER

As an avid hsr disliker how bad are you that you had to spend 2k for one character

[Dimitron]

You are comparing two very different games. Yes both are turn based JRPG but HSR is also a gacha game. Persona's story and gameplay is much better than hsr, also the graphics are more stylized and I personally prefer them. HSR's graphics are great too, but they have to be st the level that phone can run the game. Also it's combat is imo much more simple and boring compared to P5r's, more monote and boring except some team comps. Persona had the best turn based system for many reasons, but it's so much more fun than hsr. And for asking which one is better, persona ofc. It's story it's more impactful and every character is developed and has its own arc, almost. Plus social links helps them grow. HSR can't have the same level of character development due to its growing cast and it's story is much weakier compared to persona's. HSR's story has to go for many more years compared th P5r's, it's not similar. I heavily recommend persona, I think you'll love it

[Zura]

Might be late but it honestly depends in what you're looking for, but in general P5R clears so bad its not even funny.

If you're looking for a short and more simple stories with a bunch of characters that get developped mainly through side quests go for hsr

If you want a much more deep, complex, longer, visually pleasing game that has a lot of depth into its characters and that has genuinely one of the most astounding ost's out there coupled with some of the most well written characters, go for P5R

[Johnathon Fortnite]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Jaker:

Might be late but it honestly depends in what you're looking for, but in general P5R clears so bad its not even funny.

If you're looking for a short and more simple stories with a bunch of characters that get developped mainly through side quests go for hsr

If you want a much more deep, complex, longer, visually pleasing game that has a lot of depth into its characters and that has genuinely one of the most astounding ost's out there coupled with some of the most well written characters, go for P5R

Ngl as good a game p5 is i wouldn't call it deep lol. Or complex. It's pretty surface level for the most part, but that tends to be what is fun about persona.

It's literally just yeah well ♥♥♥♥ YOU i have friends and you're CRINGE: p4/5 protag to villain at the end of the game

Ost on the otherhand 0 arguments.

[Zura]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Johnathon Fortnite:

Początkowo opublikowane przez Jaker:

Might be late but it honestly depends in what you're looking for, but in general P5R clears so bad its not even funny.

If you're looking for a short and more simple stories with a bunch of characters that get developped mainly through side quests go for hsr

If you want a much more deep, complex, longer, visually pleasing game that has a lot of depth into its characters and that has genuinely one of the most astounding ost's out there coupled with some of the most well written characters, go for P5R

Ngl as good a game p5 is i wouldn't call it deep lol. Or complex. It's pretty surface level for the most part, but that tends to be what is fun about persona.

It's literally just yeah well ♥♥♥♥ YOU i have friends and you're CRINGE: p4/5 protag to villain at the end of the game

Ost on the otherhand 0 arguments.

Maybe we see things differently, but that's fine. I think your side of things is pretty intresting :3

[King Of Lolis]

Honkai is a gacha game and those are always bad so

[Lê Quyết Hà Minh Tân]

I might too late for this but 2 games are literally not comparable
HSR is like a fun chinese turn based game for children with gacha mechanic
P5R is harder, more complex and more complicated story than HSR
in other hands, HSR is just a fun game to play when you are bored, but there's absolute no way HSR is better than P5R and why comparing F2P game over a game considered an AAA game title and the one of the most iconic J-RPG title in the history of gaming and it cost $60
I played both games, I got Acheron E3 on HSR with Ruan Mei and Sliverwolf, I took a break from HSR just to play P5R (I'm still playing P5R). And I'm going to say P5R vibe is literally 10 times better than HSR so you should consider buying P5R.

[Lê Quyết Hà Minh Tân]

Początkowo opublikowane przez Arifufu:

HSR is better: endless story, Persona 5 doesn't have gacha. Pom Pom is much better mascot than a talketive cat. HSR also have PvP while Persona 5 doesn't have PvP system.

Sorry but your opinion is outdated you were born in the wrong format Pom Pom is literally annoying me I rather listen to Morgana for 10 straight hours rather than Pom Pom yapping.

[Johnathon Fortnite]

Początkowo opublikowane przez サキューペン・ヘル:

I might too late for this but 2 games are literally not comparable
HSR is like a fun chinese turn based game for children with gacha mechanic
P5R is harder, more complex and more complicated story than HSR
in other hands, HSR is just a fun game to play when you are bored, but there's absolute no way HSR is better than P5R and why comparing F2P game over a game considered an AAA game title and the one of the most iconic J-RPG title in the history of gaming and it cost $60
I played both games, I got Acheron E3 on HSR with Ruan Mei and Sliverwolf, I took a break from HSR just to play P5R (I'm still playing P5R). And I'm going to say P5R vibe is literally 10 times better than HSR so you should consider buying P5R.

Persona and hard don't go in the same sentence lmao