Is Lavenza romanceable?

[Potato]

Title. I need to know

[DLON]

Publicado originalmente por Icy Wings, Bane of Bootlickers:

Publicado originalmente por DLON:

Then your argument is that Velvet Room attendants are not social links. And that's true. But that no velvet room attendant was romancable is just false.

Which is also false because Margareth is Empress and the Twins/Lavenza is Strenght.

Oh yeah, I forgot about that. Then you are twice as wrong lol

[Xelane]

Publicado originalmente por DLON:

Publicado originalmente por Icy Wings, Bane of Bootlickers:

I say "romanceable" in the way that I think it is like any other Female confidant like Kawakami, Ann and so on.

Then your argument is that Velvet Room attendants are not social links. And that's true. But that no velvet room attendant was romancable is just false.

He's not wrong. There are specific criteria that makes a confidant romancable and Lavenza does not meet these criteria.

You can't choose to spend time with her on Christmas or Valentine's day, for example. She doesn't get the prompt to enter a relationship, for another.

She also doesn't get the heart icon in her confidant menu, which indicates that you're in a relationship.

[DLON]

Publicado originalmente por Xelane:

Publicado originalmente por DLON:

Then your argument is that Velvet Room attendants are not social links. And that's true. But that no velvet room attendant was romancable is just false.

He's not wrong. There are specific criteria that makes a confidant romancable and Lavenza does not meet these criteria.

You can't choose to spend time with her on Christmas or Valentine's day, for example. She doesn't get the prompt to enter a relationship, for another.

She also doesn't get the heart icon in her confidant menu, which indicates that you're in a relationship.

Please read the entire discussion before jumping to claim something is true or false. He claimed that no velvet room attendant was ever romancable in a Persona game. We weren't talking specifically about Persona 5 or Lavenza. Elizabeth from Persona 3 was definitely romancable, and Margaret from Persona 4 had romance elements, too. The fact that it doesn't take the same form as regular social links doesn't change that.

[Xelane]

Publicado originalmente por DLON:

Publicado originalmente por Xelane:

He's not wrong. There are specific criteria that makes a confidant romancable and Lavenza does not meet these criteria.

You can't choose to spend time with her on Christmas or Valentine's day, for example. She doesn't get the prompt to enter a relationship, for another.

She also doesn't get the heart icon in her confidant menu, which indicates that you're in a relationship.

Please read the entire discussion before jumping to claim something is true or false. He claimed that no velvet room attendant was ever romancable in a Persona game. We weren't talking specifically about Persona 5 or Lavenza. Elizabeth from Persona 3 was definitely romancable, and Margaret from Persona 4 had romance elements, too. The fact that it doesn't take the same form as regular social links doesn't change that.

I haven't played 3 all the way through, so I can't comment on Elizabeth, but I don't think Margret meets the criteria either.

She doesn't participate in the Valentine's day event or Christmas (at least I think it was Christmas for P4G, like in 5) either.

Do they have some elements of their relationship that seem similar? Sure. I don't think that makes them relevant to the question as to whether or not they are romanceable.

[DLON]

Publicado originalmente por Xelane:

Publicado originalmente por DLON:

Please read the entire discussion before jumping to claim something is true or false. He claimed that no velvet room attendant was ever romancable in a Persona game. We weren't talking specifically about Persona 5 or Lavenza. Elizabeth from Persona 3 was definitely romancable, and Margaret from Persona 4 had romance elements, too. The fact that it doesn't take the same form as regular social links doesn't change that.

I haven't played 3 all the way through, so I can't comment on Elizabeth, but I don't think Margret meets the criteria either.

She doesn't participate in the Valentine's day event or Christmas (at least I think it was Christmas for P4G, like in 5) either.

Well, I have played through Persona 3 FES, and its Velvet Room attendant, Elizabeth, is romancable. She has her own set of dates with the MC, separate from regular social links, during which she slowly falls in love with the player, and at the end of the game asks to be taken to his room and f*ck, which the player can accept or refuse. Then, after the story ends, she makes it her life mission or whatever to save the player from his fate, abandoning her Velvet Room duties.

I also said Margaret from Persona had romance elements. If you do all her quests, she kisses the player at the end of the game.

A character doesn't have to follow the exact same mechanics as other characters, or participate in the exact same type of events to be romancable.

That other dude said that no Velvet Room Attendant was ever romancable in a Persona game, and that's not true.

[Manager Michael]

You mean the character that looks like a literal child?

[State Line Crosser]

Publicado originalmente por Chambrine:

You mean the character that looks like a literal child?

No, the other metaphorical one.