Chest where you free the first Gremlin

[Megalith]

Is it still possible to get this if you freed the Gremlin first before going for the chest? Seems like I've been locked out after the Gremlin hit the switch.

[Ingel Riday]

No, unfortunately. From what I've gathered, the only way to 100% this game's collectibles is to:

A. Do a good paint playthrough (ex: save the gremlin)
B. Do a naughty paint-thinner playthrough (the treasure is mine, gremlin!)
C. A final pass to pick up anything you missed the first two times.

Each playthrough, you get to keep your collectibles from the last run. Personally, I'm just going to assume that I'm not 100%ing this game and enjoy my good-guy paint run.

[Lanani]

You can either free the Gremlin (and get a pin) or get the chest and a concept art. You cannot do both in the same playthrough.

[VengefulJedi]

Both the Gremlin and the Chest are sitting on pressure plates. Opening the chest releases that pressure plate, triggering the catapult to launch the Gremlin. But when you free the Gremlin, it locks the cage back inside that structure. Choices like that... what do they think this is, a Telltale game? (lol)

[Treekicker]

Originally posted by VengefulJedi:

Both the Gremlin and the Chest are sitting on pressure plates. Opening the chest releases that pressure plate, triggering the catapult to launch the Gremlin. But when you free the Gremlin, it locks the cage back inside that structure. Choices like that... what do they think this is, a Telltale game? (lol)

one of the draws when this game came out in 2010 was the moral choice system. it was meant to add a bit of complexity to your playthroughs, it just didnt pan out because they didnt do much with it. also, telltale didnt do the moral choice stuff until the walking dead. which came out in 2012.