Store Page
Lords of the Fallen
All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews

Lords of the Fallen

Store Page
View Stats:
Global Achievements
Wushiba Nov 23, 2023 @ 1:00pm
Dark Souls 2 vs Lords of the Fallen 2
Answer the question whichever way you feel is more appropriate.


a.) Which is the better game? Dark Souls 2 or Lords of the Fallen?

or

b.) Which is the worse game? Dark Souls 2 or Lords of the Fallen?
Last edited by Wushiba; Nov 24, 2023 @ 9:09pm
The author of this topic has marked a post as the answer to their question.
Click here to jump to that post.
Originally posted by D. Flame:
DS1 > BB >= Nioh 2 >= DeS > DS3 >> ER >>> DS2 = LotF
< >
Showing 1-15 of 87 comments
Papa Honecker Nov 23, 2023 @ 1:09pm 
dark souls 3 > dark souls 1 > lord of the fallen > elden ring > dark souls 2
#1
Rena Ichigawa Nov 23, 2023 @ 1:43pm 
Originally posted by Fantastic Pilled:
dark souls 3 > dark souls 1 > lord of the fallen > elden ring > dark souls 2
I agree with this statement. 3 was best refined, just wish the pvp was a lil more active. Ds1 had the best world, and starting experience. LotF is just fun to blitz through with friends, something ER, and ds2 is lacking imo. Thats just me though.
#2
The author of this thread has indicated that this post answers the original topic.
D. Flame Nov 23, 2023 @ 1:57pm 
DS1 > BB >= Nioh 2 >= DeS > DS3 >> ER >>> DS2 = LotF
#3
King Nov 23, 2023 @ 2:00pm 
Dark Souls 2 clears this game, it isn't even close.
#4
BillDrat Nov 23, 2023 @ 2:12pm 
1st Elden Ring/ 2nd Demon's Souls 2009/ 3rd Dark Souls 2/ 4th Lords of the Fallen/ 5th Dark Souls 1/ 6th Dark Souls 3.
#5
PeeGee Nov 23, 2023 @ 2:47pm 
Originally posted by Fantastic Pilled:
dark souls 3 > dark souls 1 > lord of the fallen > elden ring > dark souls 2
Nice list. Elden ring would of been much higher for me if it wasn't open world.
#6
Wushiba Nov 23, 2023 @ 2:53pm 
Originally posted by Rena Ichigawa:
Originally posted by Fantastic Pilled:
dark souls 3 > dark souls 1 > lord of the fallen > elden ring > dark souls 2
I agree with this statement. 3 was best refined, just wish the pvp was a lil more active. Ds1 had the best world, and starting experience. LotF is just fun to blitz through with friends, something ER, and ds2 is lacking imo. Thats just me though.

Lords of the Fallen is better than Elden Ring? I'm curious why. That's really surprising to hear.

Originally posted by D. Flame:
DS1 > BB >= Nioh 2 >= DeS > DS3 >> ER >>> DS2 = LotF

This is the answer I expected.

Originally posted by King:
Dark Souls 2 clears this game, it isn't even close.

What does "clears this game" means? You mean Dark Souls 2 is better than Lords of the Fallen?

Originally posted by BillDrat:
1st Elden Ring/ 2nd Demon's Souls 2009/ 3rd Dark Souls 2/ 4th Lords of the Fallen/ 5th Dark Souls 1/ 6th Dark Souls 3.

5th Dark Souls 1? 6th Dark Souls 3? ... Whaat? Am I suppose to read this backwards? 6th is the best?
Last edited by Wushiba; Nov 23, 2023 @ 3:38pm
#7
Majere Nov 23, 2023 @ 3:14pm 
I will say, as a Souls vet dating back to DeS on Ps3, that I'm finding I prefer LOTF's take on combat and control now (with caveats, dual-wield movesets in LOTF are rough and weapons in general have movesets which are too samey.) I'm sort of dreading going back to ER when the DLC finally drops and having to get used to cycling clumsily through spells and ammo types rather than just hitting a button.

DSII is still the undisputed king of NG+ modes, however. Nothing else has got close, other From games included.
#8
Rena Ichigawa Nov 23, 2023 @ 3:50pm 
Originally posted by Wushiba:
Originally posted by Rena Ichigawa:
I agree with this statement. 3 was best refined, just wish the pvp was a lil more active. Ds1 had the best world, and starting experience. LotF is just fun to blitz through with friends, something ER, and ds2 is lacking imo. Thats just me though.

Lords of the Fallen is better than Elden Ring? I'm curious why. That's really surprising to hear.

Originally posted by D. Flame:
DS1 > BB >= Nioh 2 >= DeS > DS3 >> ER >>> DS2 = LotF

This is the answer I expected.

Originally posted by King:
Dark Souls 2 clears this game, it isn't even close.

What does "clears this game" means? You mean Dark Souls 2 is better than Lords of the Fallen?

Originally posted by BillDrat:
1st Elden Ring/ 2nd Demon's Souls 2009/ 3rd Dark Souls 2/ 4th Lords of the Fallen/ 5th Dark Souls 1/ 6th Dark Souls 3.

5th Dark Souls 1? 6th Dark Souls 3? ... Whaat? Am I suppose to read this backwards? 6th is the best?
My main issues with elden ring. The open world. Once you even remotely know the map, you realize how much useless space was used for weapons, or accessories no one in their right mind will ever use beyond hyper specialized builds. As well as areas that exist to just give you a crafting material you can just farm. Then there is the multiplayer. If not for seamless, its one of the worsts in my opinion. Why allow open world co-op if your going to turn 20 minute travel time int several hours of slowly running around instead? I see no reason to summon except at the boss wall, it just doesnt help. Then there is the general unbalanced nature of status effects. Why not use bleed, or frostbite if all but like 3 bosses get absolutely shredded by it? Also dont me started on the new game run of hours for healing upgrades on subsequent plays. Thats just me, and my opinion though.
#9
Kriss Hietala Nov 23, 2023 @ 4:01pm 
definitely lotfs. I have dropped dark souls II and I'm very happy with my decision. Never going back to that ♥♥♥♥. Scholar of the first sin...more like Scholar of the first ♥♥♥♥.
#10
BillDrat Nov 23, 2023 @ 4:05pm 
Elden Ring is one of the Greatest games ever made. It has problems but they're minor. The overall game is magnificent. Elden Ring could be called the Best game ever made. I could call it that.
If you are a developer, Look at Elden Ring, what they got right. They got a lot right.
#11
D. Flame Nov 23, 2023 @ 4:08pm 
Originally posted by BillDrat:
Elden Ring is one of the Greatest games ever made. It has problems but they're minor. The overall game is magnificent. Elden Ring could be called the Best game ever made. I could call it that.
If you are a developer, Look at Elden Ring, what they got right. They got a lot right.
Elden Ring was a joke,
#12
BillDrat Nov 23, 2023 @ 4:10pm 
whats funny? Tell me whats funny, please. Elden Ring is the game to look up to. Its the game to emulate. Its the best Video Game.
Last edited by BillDrat; Nov 23, 2023 @ 4:11pm
#13
ReflexShift Nov 23, 2023 @ 4:15pm 
Originally posted by BillDrat:
Elden Ring is one of the Greatest games ever made. It has problems but they're minor. The overall game is magnificent. Elden Ring could be called the Best game ever made. I could call it that.
If you are a developer, Look at Elden Ring, what they got right. They got a lot right.

I have to agree Elden Ring for me was a great game. Maybe not greatest of all time but in the top 10. Though I do like all the Dark Souls games also, each is unique and fun to play. I like Dark Souls 3 probably the best, then Dark Souls Remastered, and finally Dark Souls 2. LotF is a fun game but I would probably rank it after Dark Souls Remastered. It's definitely better then DS2.
#14
Wushiba Nov 23, 2023 @ 4:16pm 
Originally posted by D. Flame:
Elden Ring was a joke,

Originally posted by BillDrat:
whats funny? Tell me whats funny, please. Elden Ring is the game to look up to. Its the game to emulate. Its the best Video Game.

Please do the arguing about Elden Ring in private xD I am more interested in knowing more about Lords of the Fallen. I am considering getting it. If we are going to talk about Elden Ring then do it in a fun way at least:

D. Flame list the things Lords of the Fallen does better than Elden Ring.

BillDrat list the things Elden Ring does better than Lords of the Fallen.

Go.
Last edited by Wushiba; Nov 23, 2023 @ 4:17pm
#15
< >
Showing 1-15 of 87 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Lords of the Fallen > General Discussions > Topic Details
Date Posted: Nov 23, 2023 @ 1:00pm
Posts: 87

Discussions Rules and Guidelines