My Boss Ratings

[Heck]

Otto = C-
Intro boss? Nothing much else to say. Basically a trash mob later for farming large nuggets. Hes basically the soldier of godrick for this game.

Pieta = B+
Good boss to get you warmed up. Im pretty sure A LOT of people struggled on this one

Scourged Sister = C-
Basically a mini boss and later trash mob in endgame

Mistress of Hounds = D
Not great. Another mini boss that later becomes a trash mob

Congregator of Flesh = D-
Just a big boss that has huge aoe melee just to be annoying

Hushed Saint = B
The first boss that actually gave me some trouble. He can cover distance crazy fast.

Ruiner = C-
Imposing mini boss that later becomes a trash mob. Some attacks surprised me. Not a fun walk back though.

Infernal Enchantress = D-
Basically a trash mob later in the game thats a spongy glass cannon. Nothing special

Spurned Progeny = A+
NOW this boss really caught me off guard. I wasnt expecting a multi sequence fight. Took me some getting used to but overall remember-able over all the crap before it.

Skinstealer = C
Another trash mob later in the game. Only reason I rate it higher is for its chain attacks.

Lightreaper = A-
Tough fight once you face him after lighting all the beacons to get to Bramis. All his other optional encounters are the same difficulty so you can really beat him anywhere.

Kinragnr Guardian = F
Basically a sub boss with a bunch of trash hounds protected by a parasite and a pond. If you get thrown into the umbral you have to deal with another mini boss in the same arena. Just a bad boss overall. Im sure this one annoyed people

Hollow Crow = B+
Redeemed the last crap you had to face. Kind of a weird boss but overall a pretty cool design

Abbess Ursula = D
Spongy glass cannon that was more annoying than difficult

Judge Cleric = A
Noticing a trend that all the beacon bosses tend to be pretty good. This one is no different. Decent difficulty with multi phase.

Blessed Carrion Knight = C
Meh? It was ok. Nothing special to write home about.

Tancred = C+
Probably the lowest rated beacon boss for me. His two phases remind me of Artorias and Sif if both were combined.

Sundered Monarch = D
Ehhh? Big guy big AOE. Nothing else. Done in one try.

Adyr = F
Final boss fight is crap.

Only optional notable is Harrower Dervla which is like an A for me only because its basically a rehash of the Twin Princes

[eDo]

Yes Judge Cleric def but for me best fight is Elianne

[Kim]

Elianne FTW !

[Phantom Limb]

You know that you can call the boss only those who has rememberance right? Everyone else is just a miniboss not worth mentioning?
You also miss those npcs who become hostile one way or another like Andreas of Ebb?

[Heck]

Originally posted by Phantom Limb:

You know that you can call the boss only those who has rememberance right? Everyone else is just a miniboss not worth mentioning?
You also miss those npcs who become hostile one way or another like Andreas of Ebb?

I didnt follow any NPC questlines so I never ran into any of them.
Well actually Demarose but only because I DIDNT follow her questline

Im on my second run so im following the umbral quests right now
Some people summoned me for Elianne and shes brutal. Probably A tier

[I_come_in_peace]

Yeah I very much agree. Liked Tancret a bit more. Sundered King felt like they had to rush him. Very limited move set. No second phase. Very disappointing - you don't finish a game on a low.
Didn't mind Adyr fight so much, was more like an after credits scene. Did it very quickly with claws which had a Wolverine feel to it. Could also have used a second phase where you actually fight him.

[I_come_in_peace]

I liked optional Huntress. Different moveset and quick. Also liked fighting her later on. Her fight and Skinstealer had cool upbeat music, too. Bit of a Tarantino feel.

[Exdeath]

Yeah if the Walls on the fire giant wouldnt have dark souls 2 savezones this fight wouldnt have been that bad, but on my first try i hid behind a wall and still got oneshotet, so i didnt try it anymore and died a million Times before i got lucky with a roll right infront of a wall when he did his fire bs.

I only realized After i watched my Video of that fight that the Walls where in fact savezones but just with bad hitboxes