Nightmare's Kitchen problem

[Hans Olo]

Hey, I am having issues with this achievement. I have not unlocked all cooking recipes, and am trying out different ones that I have not unlocked, but no matter what I do it always creates Pet Food, and thus not getting the achievement. What am I doing wrong, or is it just bugged?

[spielerinchen]

you have probably discovered all recipes & thus there is no new to discover
to get that achievement you have to set up a new save manually
io to do that, save your current game manually, disable Steam Cloud Save, then start a new game under a different animal. then go through the tutorial up till you get to the kitchen there, since you don't have any recipe discovered yet with that save, so you can take eg 2 eggs & make the Sunny Side Up recipe

[JVC]

Try looking through the list on the wiki if there's something you haven't discovered.

https://no-place-like-home.fandom.com/wiki/Cooking

And you need to make sure that the cooking station says you're doing an experiment. On the highest tier station, I think it is the right hand part of it.

I just got it by discovering poached peach (= peach + honey). It doesn't even have to be one of each, I added 10 of each of those and got a full stack of the new dish.