Age of Empires IV: Anniversary Edition

Age of Empires IV: Anniversary Edition

View Stats:
Best Age of Empires for Single Player: AoE2 or AoE4?
I want to play only Single Player, being campaigns very important feature for me. As now we are on sales period, could you please suggest me an option AoE2 or AoE4? Im not interested in multiplayer, only playing with AI. Also Im new to Age of Empires, never played it before.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 31 comments
erb Dec 22, 2024 @ 7:46am 
Age of Empires 2

Base game has more single-player content. Most of their DLC adds single-player content as well.

The AI is also better.
Last edited by erb; Dec 22, 2024 @ 8:08am
Depends on what you like, I like AoE2 more. There's a lot more campaigns and many more different cultures.
HistoryPlayer Dec 22, 2024 @ 12:37pm 
what about DLCs?
erb Dec 22, 2024 @ 12:54pm 
Expansions
AoE2 The Last Khans (2019)
AoE2 Lords of the West (2021)
AoE2 Dawn of the Dukes (2021)
AoE2 Dynasties of India (2022)
AoE2 Return of Rome (2023)
AoE2 The Mountain Royals (2023)
Aoe2 Victors and Vanquished (2024)
AoE2 Chronicles: Battle for Greece (2024)

https://ageofempires.fandom.com/wiki/Campaign_(Age_of_Empires_II)

There's so much content in AoE 2 focused on singleplayer. If you get all DLC it has 37 campaigns, and that's excluding Art of Wars, Historical Battles, and one off scenarios.

AoE 4 has one DLC, The Sultans Ascend. It has 5 campaigns with that DLC included.

It doesn't even come close, unfortunately. This is something many of the AoE 4 players would like to have!

As a long time age series fan I have played through the campaigns in every title. If you had to pick one over the other for singleplayer content, it's AoE 2 hands down. But in my opinion, if you like one you'll like them all. You'll probably end up growing your collection soon enough anyways 😉
Last edited by erb; Dec 22, 2024 @ 12:56pm
HistoryPlayer Dec 22, 2024 @ 1:16pm 
Ok very good, thank you for the info, do you think more DLCs are expected for AoE4 in the future?
erb Dec 22, 2024 @ 1:36pm 
Next expansion releases in Spring 2025. Nothing official yet, but there's been some small hints dropped in the patch notes.

Normally we see DLC drop in the fourth quarter (October-December), but it was delayed because of the release of Age of Mythology: Retold.

In general, we get DLC once a year. It normally includes new civilizations to play as in skirmish and multiplayer, and has single player content in the form of campaigns or scenarios.
Last edited by erb; Dec 22, 2024 @ 8:43pm
Large C Dec 22, 2024 @ 2:19pm 
by far 4 if you can run it, anyway aoe2 is excellent if you have older pc
Sylvester Sirloin Dec 22, 2024 @ 7:41pm 
Age of Empires 2 is better for campaign/single player.
grraf (Banned) Dec 22, 2024 @ 10:19pm 
One more thing that needs to be said&highlighted as well : with the return of rome dlc you also get to play a good chuck of the single player campaigns from AoE I ... this dlc sort of bundles up AOE I civs&content(separate game mode) into AoE II.

When it comes down to single player content AoE II DE is the way to go if you want the best bang for your buck...
On the multiplayer side of things one can make an argument in favor of AoE IV especially if you are into spastic rush tactics and would like to raze an opponent to the ground no later then the second age(unlocks access to siege and a fair few civs can construct it in the field without the need to have it made from a building) as opposed to AoE II that puts a bigger emphasis on economic development&strategic planing(for instance high ground control offers a bonus to the attack and durability of units&buildings standing on it unlike in AoE IV where it does f all... also projectile weapons can miss in AoE II unlike AoE IV where everything defies the laws of physics and course corrects mid flight to always hit the intended target(yes it is that mechanically retarded of a game) where as in AoE II it takes a fair bit of time(need to advance to the third age to construct any siege engine(from an actual building) before you can raze an opponent.
Last edited by grraf; Dec 23, 2024 @ 1:25am
Lotor13 Dec 23, 2024 @ 4:13am 
Originally posted by Sylvester Sirloin:
Age of Empires 2 is better for campaign/single player.

Age of Empires 2 DE has more campaigns than any other RTS game on the market..

But there is one "but" - most of the AoE2 DE campaigns are horrible balanced - one mission is super easy and second is super hard, difficulty setting is broken - in many cases, standard (bronze) is too easy with passive AI, and moderate (silver) is very hard with super effective AI, in many scenarios..

Achievment rate for AoE2 campaigns are very low due to this
-----------

On the other side, the last AoE2 DLC is very good & properly balanced / designated

https://store.steampowered.com/app/2805520/Age_of_Empires_II_DE__Chronicles_Battle_for_Greece/
Modragor Dec 23, 2024 @ 6:10am 
Originally posted by HistoryPlayer:
I want to play only Single Player, being campaigns very important feature for me. As now we are on sales period, could you please suggest me an option AoE2 or AoE4? Im not interested in multiplayer, only playing with AI. Also Im new to Age of Empires, never played it before.

AoE 2 is a dated game with copy + paste civs, ugly graphics, no different units for every civ like AoE 4 has, no different buildings for every civ like AoE 4 has, no deeply worked out civs which really represent the history of the real civs like AoE 4 has.

All AoE 2 has are dated strategies which have been played already 20 years ago like the Red Bull Wololol tournament showed again: scout-skirm rush, champ flow and so on - how creative. And the 20 year old abuse of patrol trick was also on board, nothing really changed in decades of "so good" AoE 2.

AoE 4 and AoM wipe the floor with AoE 2 in every aspect.
FloosWorld Dec 23, 2024 @ 7:48am 
Originally posted by Modragor:
Originally posted by HistoryPlayer:
I want to play only Single Player, being campaigns very important feature for me. As now we are on sales period, could you please suggest me an option AoE2 or AoE4? Im not interested in multiplayer, only playing with AI. Also Im new to Age of Empires, never played it before.

AoE 2 is a dated game with copy + paste civs, ugly graphics, no different units for every civ like AoE 4 has, no different buildings for every civ like AoE 4 has, no deeply worked out civs which really represent the history of the real civs like AoE 4 has.

All AoE 2 has are dated strategies which have been played already 20 years ago like the Red Bull Wololol tournament showed again: scout-skirm rush, champ flow and so on - how creative. And the 20 year old abuse of patrol trick was also on board, nothing really changed in decades of "so good" AoE 2.

AoE 4 and AoM wipe the floor with AoE 2 in every aspect.

Dude, I know you don't like AoE 2 but your reply is not at all related to OP's question.
OP said he's not interested in MP, so why do you bring up tournaments in your copy-paste reply?
Modragor Dec 23, 2024 @ 7:55am 
Originally posted by FloosWorld:
Originally posted by Modragor:

AoE 2 is a dated game with copy + paste civs, ugly graphics, no different units for every civ like AoE 4 has, no different buildings for every civ like AoE 4 has, no deeply worked out civs which really represent the history of the real civs like AoE 4 has.

All AoE 2 has are dated strategies which have been played already 20 years ago like the Red Bull Wololol tournament showed again: scout-skirm rush, champ flow and so on - how creative. And the 20 year old abuse of patrol trick was also on board, nothing really changed in decades of "so good" AoE 2.

AoE 4 and AoM wipe the floor with AoE 2 in every aspect.

Dude, I know you don't like AoE 2 but your reply is not at all related to OP's question.
OP said he's not interested in MP, so why do you bring up tournaments in your copy-paste reply?

Because he has to know about the dated design of AoE 2 to make the right decision and buy AoE 4 or AoM. It´s not nice of the AoE 2 community to deceive players to buy their game that´s clearly fallen out of time in every aspect of modern RTS games.
FloosWorld Dec 23, 2024 @ 8:04am 
Originally posted by Modragor:
Originally posted by FloosWorld:

Dude, I know you don't like AoE 2 but your reply is not at all related to OP's question.
OP said he's not interested in MP, so why do you bring up tournaments in your copy-paste reply?

Because he has to know about the dated design of AoE 2 to make the right decision and buy AoE 4 or AoM. It´s not nice of the AoE 2 community to deceive players to buy their game that´s clearly fallen out of time in every aspect of modern RTS games.

It's funny how you use "modern" and "AoM" in the same sentence whereas Retold is at its core the old 2002 game with some QOL (so, essentially like AoE 2 DE) and some of the AoE 4 players trashed it on reddit for the fact that it's old.

As I said in my other reply in German, it doesn't hurt refreshing your AoE 2 memories bc it also doesn't hurt to extend your horizon outside your comfort zone. :)
Modragor Dec 23, 2024 @ 8:32am 
Originally posted by FloosWorld:
Originally posted by Modragor:

Because he has to know about the dated design of AoE 2 to make the right decision and buy AoE 4 or AoM. It´s not nice of the AoE 2 community to deceive players to buy their game that´s clearly fallen out of time in every aspect of modern RTS games.

It's funny how you use "modern" and "AoM" in the same sentence whereas Retold is at its core the old 2002 game with some QOL (so, essentially like AoE 2 DE) and some of the AoE 4 players trashed it on reddit for the fact that it's old.

As I said in my other reply in German, it doesn't hurt refreshing your AoE 2 memories bc it also doesn't hurt to extend your horizon outside your comfort zone. :)

AoM was, is and will always be superior to AoE 2 because of its asymmetrical civ design, its extra layer of hero and myth units, its battle changing god powers, its Titans and its overall fun factor.

Even today this are creative and modern elements an AoE 2 will forever miss, so there is no problem with calling AoM modern, compared to the rather basic design of AoE 2.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 31 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Dec 22, 2024 @ 6:11am
Posts: 31