Fight Night Champion from 2011 is way better than this copy cat of a game

[Stoney]

Only good thing undisputed has is better graphics and thats it nothing else comes close unfortunatley

[Khuros]

Publicado originalmente por Rdizz:

Publicado originalmente por Khuros:

are you insane?

I mean lets boil it down, Sure the detailing is better on the fighters in undisputed, but fight night had a lot more going on. The crowd looks better, it had a ref in the ring, corner men that had animations and did things, more blood and facial visuals for damage, replays that looked pretty good.... I mean for how old that game is Undisputed isnt really offering much more here.

FNC is a full complete AAA game. OFC it has that stuff. Undisputed isnt complete yet.

[Boomshanka]

Publicado originalmente por Khuros:

Publicado originalmente por Rdizz:

I mean lets boil it down, Sure the detailing is better on the fighters in undisputed, but fight night had a lot more going on. The crowd looks better, it had a ref in the ring, corner men that had animations and did things, more blood and facial visuals for damage, replays that looked pretty good.... I mean for how old that game is Undisputed isnt really offering much more here.

FNC is a full complete AAA game. OFC it has that stuff. Undisputed isnt complete yet.

Doesnt matter about any of that, if they dont switch to dedicated servers the game is finished already. Its like putting lipstick on a corpse

[Sledge]

Publicado originalmente por Khuros:

Publicado originalmente por Rdizz:

I mean lets boil it down, Sure the detailing is better on the fighters in undisputed, but fight night had a lot more going on. The crowd looks better, it had a ref in the ring, corner men that had animations and did things, more blood and facial visuals for damage, replays that looked pretty good.... I mean for how old that game is Undisputed isnt really offering much more here.

FNC is a full complete AAA game. OFC it has that stuff. Undisputed isnt complete yet.

Undisputed is also one of the more expensive Early Access products and nowhere near as feature complete as other Early Access products on the market currently, many of which are close to £10 cheaper. Forget FN Champion for now, it's not doing the rounds against other EA projects imho, regardless of genre.

I routinely pick up EA games because I want to support good, solid indie projects. Undisputed has a good foundation but lacks a huge amount of depth in numerous key areas.

The only thing worth doing at the moment is engaging in the online, ranked or unranked meat-grinder and there's nowt else to do, unless you enjoy daily, one-off prize fights for some XP.

Game even has a storefront on the first page. Says "coming soon" sure, but it's hilarious that the store was even thought of for a game this incomplete. Wonder how long it'll be before SC turn around and say they need more money to support development, thus new fighters going forward will cost money.

Talking about Champion, I'm pretty sure I picked up FN Champion for £40 on launch day, this is £15 less than that and nowhere near as complete, absolutely wild.

[HunteRetnuH]

Publicado originalmente por adan3891:

It scares me that for more than a month the developers have not been able to do normal damage. After playing for a month, I realized how terribly everything is implemented here. I was hoping they would fix this quickly, but instead they are wasting their time on some obscure new fighters. The game is not yet playable and you are wasting time on content. I'm back playing Fight Knight. I got great pleasure even from Fight Knight round 4. FN4 is better than Undispudet. There I can finish fights up to 4 rounds, and not suffer with Wilder all 12 rounds. I stopped playing Wilder in Undipudet because I hate running 12 rounds. I'm playing Ali now as he can win up to 4 rounds. Did the developers ever wonder why they have Ali as a puncher and Wilder not as a puncher? It should be the other way around! In Fight Night Champion, the damage is almost perfect. One accurate hit and the fight could end in the first round. Just like real boxing. Why can't Wilder knock out in 12 rounds in Undispudet?

This game has a long way to go and I think people are mistaking racking up wins on Undisputed to think that that equals the game being good.

For me, I'll put it like this way: I was regularly playing games like UFC 4, in spite of its flaws and I also have played/still play the older Fight Night games too. After giving disputed a good amount of time and effort, both during the beta and early access, the game is just not enjoyable in its current state.

Because the game is so sluggish and because feints don't work as they should, reactive play goes completely out the window. Strikes are rarely felt, and their attempts to 'fix' spamming means that I can through a strike (that I wasn't spamming) but someone the game thinks that I've thrown it 10 times in a row, so it slows my strike down. The game is completely underwhelming and has somehow gotten worse.

Now I am back on UFC 4 and even though that game definitely has its flaws, you can actually still enjoy the game because it is slick, you 'feel' the strikes (which Undisputed lacks), and moving backwards, forwards, sideways and feints are all clean and I can actually control HOW I want to fight. Undisputed has a long way to go and like you say they need to seriously prioritise fixes.

[B_TUGS_5]

Nope

[TripleJay]

Fight Night Champion from 2011 is way "more complete" than this "early access" of a game.

I corrected your title, Sir :)

[Khuros]

Publicado originalmente por Mountain Man:

Publicado originalmente por Khuros:

FNC is a full complete AAA game. OFC it has that stuff. Undisputed isnt complete yet.

Undisputed is also one of the more expensive Early Access products and nowhere near as feature complete as other Early Access products on the market currently, many of which are close to £10 cheaper. Forget FN Champion for now, it's not doing the rounds against other EA projects imho, regardless of genre.

I routinely pick up EA games because I want to support good, solid indie projects. Undisputed has a good foundation but lacks a huge amount of depth in numerous key areas.

The only thing worth doing at the moment is engaging in the online, ranked or unranked meat-grinder and there's nowt else to do, unless you enjoy daily, one-off prize fights for some XP.

Game even has a storefront on the first page. Says "coming soon" sure, but it's hilarious that the store was even thought of for a game this incomplete. Wonder how long it'll be before SC turn around and say they need more money to support development, thus new fighters going forward will cost money.

Talking about Champion, I'm pretty sure I picked up FN Champion for £40 on launch day, this is £15 less than that and nowhere near as complete, absolutely wild.

So go buy another EA boxing game... Oh wait.

[highkingcasey]

Publicado originalmente por SecularSmoker:

Publicado originalmente por Boomshanka:

Whats to learn? , its terrible.

Judging a game by early access isn't the greatest thing. Look how garbage Baldurs Gate 3 was in the beginning?

Ya I agree. The game needs work but it does have potential imo. Baldurs Gate 3 is still garbage though it's a Divinity game with a Baldur's Gate theme. Ruined it for me. And I like Divinity games but I was expecting this to be at least a little bit different. Even the UI and the colour palette is the same as Divinity, like they didn't even try to make it different.

[RoiHans]

Publicado originalmente por jclover1:

Publicado originalmente por Braveheart:

Only good thing undisputed has is better graphics and thats it nothing else comes close unfortunatley

this game is about 300% better than FNC.

best joke of the year

[Oggmeista]

yep judging from the torrent of negative rants queries etc on here i'm pretty confident that fnc is considerably better than this at the moment and running on an emulator with gfx scaled up hugely i doubt it looks that much inferior either...though i still have an issue with seeing physical damage , not had one fight stopped on a technical decision, and I've played around with the settings a lot..but ignorant people will just assume that because it's 12 years old etc, that this automatically has to be inferior and look poor.. yeah of course they "know" without ever playing it, p

[Sledge]

Publicado originalmente por Khuros:

Publicado originalmente por Mountain Man:

Undisputed is also one of the more expensive Early Access products and nowhere near as feature complete as other Early Access products on the market currently, many of which are close to £10 cheaper. Forget FN Champion for now, it's not doing the rounds against other EA projects imho, regardless of genre.

I routinely pick up EA games because I want to support good, solid indie projects. Undisputed has a good foundation but lacks a huge amount of depth in numerous key areas.

The only thing worth doing at the moment is engaging in the online, ranked or unranked meat-grinder and there's nowt else to do, unless you enjoy daily, one-off prize fights for some XP.

Game even has a storefront on the first page. Says "coming soon" sure, but it's hilarious that the store was even thought of for a game this incomplete. Wonder how long it'll be before SC turn around and say they need more money to support development, thus new fighters going forward will cost money.

Talking about Champion, I'm pretty sure I picked up FN Champion for £40 on launch day, this is £15 less than that and nowhere near as complete, absolutely wild.

So go buy another EA boxing game... Oh wait.

Amazing how your only rebuttal to any of my talking points is to go

"hur dur buy nuva ea box game den oh wait".

If you have nothing meaningful to add to the discussion, even if it comes from a place of praise for the game, perhaps you should stop talking entirely.

[Khuros]

Publicado originalmente por Mountain Man:

Publicado originalmente por Khuros:

So go buy another EA boxing game... Oh wait.

Amazing how your only rebuttal to any of my talking points is to go

"hur dur buy nuva ea box game den oh wait".

If you have nothing meaningful to add to the discussion, even if it comes from a place of praise for the game, perhaps you should stop talking entirely.

It's the only thing i need to add. This is it for boxing games. I love it.

[lieutenant General Piss]

Publicado originalmente por Boomshanka:

Publicado originalmente por verlorensquirrel:

Having a day job and loved ones does not disqualify somebody's opinion on a video game.

Who said they had a job or family? What are you smoking dude? Go check the threads and look at all these real low rank steam profiles that are also private, all of them. defending this game. Its no coincidence mate, the game has lost most of the players who bought it already.

Imagine talking about steam rank , I don't play a lot of games but the game I do play I have a major interest in, I have over 150 hours played of this game , I'm undisputed rank , with over 350 ranked games and probably 50 quick games , I've played every boxer in every weight class multiple times , I was also a top 500 rank in fight night champion and still played up until undisputed release with probably 1000s of hours played , so I think I'm qualified to give an opinion on Undisputed.

When I say learn to play I mean actually put some hours into the game before coming on and giving you crap opinion.
The game is more complex than fight night champion so trying to play it like fight night and complaining it not like fight night is pretty dumb, you can just stand toe to toe with your block up and spam punches , this game rewards using movement to avoid punches and time and use my your blog cl smartly , it rewards working the body( a bit too effective at the minute )and playing smart , winning rounds and picking your shots. The fighters have specific strength which means you have each fighter is played different to be the most effective. This game is requires you to box rather just spam punches. I could go on but ther s a lot to learn :D

[Arthur]

I have to agree, they should have not released it in the state they did. Not with the price tag they did at least. I was very happy when the game came out but now I just switched back to fight night, that game is better in every single way than this(mins footwork).

Putting EE tag on a piece of ♥♥♥♥ does not make it any less ♥♥♥♥♥♥. And considering the amount of work that was put into the game from the start I don't think anything will change.

The worst thing is that devs don't say anything. They should at least announce what is their main focus

[Khuros]

Publicado originalmente por Arthur:

I have to agree, they should have not released it in the state they did. Not with the price tag they did at least. I was very happy when the game came out but now I just switched back to fight night, that game is better in every single way than this(mins footwork).

Putting EE tag on a piece of ♥♥♥♥ does not make it any less ♥♥♥♥♥♥. And considering the amount of work that was put into the game from the start I don't think anything will change.

The worst thing is that devs don't say anything. They should at least announce what is their main focus

the roadmap.