IGN review

[Machine Spirit]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qopVt6V-TTk&ab_channel=IGN

They highlight a lot of technical issues.

[Litwick]

Echo の投稿を引用：

Metacritic score is already 72/100, could be a 7/10 but I think 6 is a fair score. Too much IGN hate here. Their recent game reviews are mostly okay. It's funny when people don't like an IGN review and immediately start talking about Alien Isolation review.
Why you arent also talking about PC Invasion's 95/100 score? Do you think this game is a 95/100? Lol be realistic please.

You can't really review a live service game, especially one built with co-op in mind. It would've been like calling Fortnite a flop in 2017. Everyone is going to have a wildly different experience depending on their friend group, and how the developers respond to community feedback in the coming months. I'm sure the day one patch is already going to solve half the issues the reviewer experienced anyway.

[Rilgar55]

Echo の投稿を引用：

Metacritic score is already 72/100, could be a 7/10 but I think 6 is a fair score. Too much IGN hate here. Their recent game reviews are mostly okay. It's funny when people don't like an IGN review and immediately start talking about Alien Isolation review.
Why you arent also talking about PC Invasion's 95/100 score? Do you think this game is a 95/100? Lol be realistic please.

Its not as much the score as it is the downsides they give, like "repetitive objectives for victims", but then they give dbd a 9, and tell me dbd isnt repetitive as ♥♥♥♥ as survivor, i dare you

[Nota]

The devs obviously didn't bribe IGN's reviewers with enough gift baskets when they got the test build.

[Machine Spirit]

DBD is basically repairing gens and then opening a gate on the surface but there is also looping and the chase, which is where DBD excels in giving players those highs and frustrating lows. TCM has chase potential but the looping seems very one sided unless two killers team up. Aside from the technical issues I am concerned about the fact you need 7 players per game and how lopsided will it be if just one killer player drops. We know there will be rage quitters, there always is with these games.

[Echo]

Rilgar55 の投稿を引用：

Echo の投稿を引用：

Metacritic score is already 72/100, could be a 7/10 but I think 6 is a fair score. Too much IGN hate here. Their recent game reviews are mostly okay. It's funny when people don't like an IGN review and immediately start talking about Alien Isolation review.
Why you arent also talking about PC Invasion's 95/100 score? Do you think this game is a 95/100? Lol be realistic please.

Its not as much the score as it is the downsides they give, like "repetitive objectives for victims", but then they give dbd a 9, and tell me dbd isnt repetitive as ♥♥♥♥ as survivor, i dare you

Their review is from 2021 and game is launched on 2016. They also did similar re-review thing with Sea of Thieves and gave higher score to it 2 or 3 years after launch. Honestly even with released ton of a DLC content I wouldn't give 9 to DBD, I'm not trying to defend them but to me it's not an unfair score for this game. 6/10 means "okay". It doesn't mean bad.
95/100 from PC Invasion is more ridiculous and unrealistic to me.

[Scream, Queen!]

Machine Spirit の投稿を引用：

Aside from the technical issues I am concerned about the fact you need 7 players per game and how lopsided will it be if just one killer player drops. We know there will be rage quitters, there always is with these games.

Victims can survive solo pretty easily, teamplay is not needed to win so rage quiting should only affect the game if it happens at the very beginning. I cannot see a reason a Family member would rage quit unless the match already ended anyway (ie. people are BMing at the exit or exploiting the game in some way).

But like... people will always find a reason to rage quit. A lot of people, especially kids have a very short temper.

Also this is a party game, like F13th, majority of players played for fun not to destroy the oponents by any means necessary so hopefully the same mindset will cary over to this game too. When people rage quit in F13th, it was when they died or were getting bullied. Everyone still got their XP, everyone moved on, no hard feelings mostly - there will always be someone who takes this all too seriously, that is a given in games like this.

I am 100% sure some kind of penatly will be implemented if the playerbase is big enough and the devs see data that suggest this is actually hurting the game.

[TyresTyco]

I just saw the video since damn.. I want the f13 experience again. And I gotta say. Nope. I could live with bugs. I could live with no content.

But I can't live with the most fun escape objective. The car. That was the most fun thing in f13 for me and they ofc didnt include it here.

But the incredibly boring gen spam. it is. Ridiculous.

[Magnate]

Honestly, I never take any reviews from companies like IGN seriously.
Only thing I maybe will at least take with some concern is mention of technical issues, I want to assume it's the case of they got an early version that didn't fix these issues and they'll be fixed on launch, but time will tell and that's why I'm waiting till last day to buy and then- well try it out myself and either refund it or keep it depending on experience.
Otherwise honestly most of the review is just- describing the game, terrible potshots and probably other stuff I forgot since I watched it at 2x speed.

It's why I'd rather watch streamers for it, get to see actual gameplay and it's state, then go from there to see if it's worth buying.
Unfortunately no streamers to actually 'showcase' this launch, so I'm just going to wait till last day before it's released, buy it and go from there, refund hopefully possible if it hits the fan, but I'm hoping it doesn't.

Echo の投稿を引用：

Metacritic score is already 72/100, could be a 7/10 but I think 6 is a fair score. Too much IGN hate here. Their recent game reviews are mostly okay. It's funny when people don't like an IGN review and immediately start talking about Alien Isolation review.
Why you arent also talking about PC Invasion's 95/100 score? Do you think this game is a 95/100? Lol be realistic please.

Probably because it's a good example of how one shouldn't entirely base their expectations of a game on a reviewer, especially when they can just be bribed to give it a better score despite the game being ass. Or underscoring literal good games, which might be why people bring up Alien Isolation but, I don't care enough to play that game so I remain uncaring.
Honestly, the whole review score system is stupid anyway since it doesn't really mean much other than some guy gave it a number rating. Just show me gameplay footage instead, even if the 'reviewer' is ass at the game, or better yet drop the reviewers and just let streamers play.

[Rilgar55]

They gave an 8 to evil dead, i mean, i liked evil dead for 50 hours, but even i saw from the start that demon was basically thecsame no matter the class you chose, and it was pretty survivor sided from the get go

[Ragnar]

if the ign review just roasts the game then why is there a ign exclusive trailer on store page?

[<3]

Ragnar の投稿を引用：

if the ign review just roasts the game then why is there a ign exclusive trailer on store page?

i feel it personally that they roast games. and my opinion isn't special. thts just something i felt.

[Grimzy]

Like any of these reviews even matter.....seriously ....they complain the game only has "3 maps" ....like...what do you expect? This is a game based on a movie, they will not be adding 20 other maps like DBD which isnt based on anything.
That ignorant / narrow view itself shows how all those reviews are literally pulled out of their asses.

[<3]

Grimzy の投稿を引用：

Like any of these reviews even matter.....seriously ....they complain the game only has "3 maps" ....like...what do you expect? This is a game based on a movie, they will not be adding 20 other maps like DBD which isnt based on anything.
That ignorant / narrow view itself shows how all those reviews are literally pulled out of their asses.

Yeah. i support this game all way despite what people say about it. all that matters is, if u like it or not nothing else really even matters.

[TheFinalDude]

Echo の投稿を引用：

Rilgar55 の投稿を引用：

Its not as much the score as it is the downsides they give, like "repetitive objectives for victims", but then they give dbd a 9, and tell me dbd isnt repetitive as ♥♥♥♥ as survivor, i dare you

Their review is from 2021 and game is launched on 2016. They also did similar re-review thing with Sea of Thieves and gave higher score to it 2 or 3 years after launch. Honestly even with released ton of a DLC content I wouldn't give 9 to DBD, I'm not trying to defend them but to me it's not an unfair score for this game. 6/10 means "okay". It doesn't mean bad.
95/100 from PC Invasion is more ridiculous and unrealistic to me.

Well considering the writer stole his ending statement from this very forum: See "Dead by Daylight is done" post, I wouldn't trust the 95/100 either. What a hacky thing to do.

But I also don't trust IGN's review since they can't get ♥♥♥♥ right that you could research in 5 minutes.

[<3]

Mormoth の投稿を引用：

Echo の投稿を引用：

Their review is from 2021 and game is launched on 2016. They also did similar re-review thing with Sea of Thieves and gave higher score to it 2 or 3 years after launch. Honestly even with released ton of a DLC content I wouldn't give 9 to DBD, I'm not trying to defend them but to me it's not an unfair score for this game. 6/10 means "okay". It doesn't mean bad.
95/100 from PC Invasion is more ridiculous and unrealistic to me.

Well considering the writer stole his ending statement from this very forum: See "Dead by Daylight is done" post, I wouldn't trust the 95/100 either. What a hacky thing to do.

But I also don't trust IGN's review either since they can't get ♥♥♥♥ write that you could research in 5 minutes.

lmfaoo, agreed.