Sonic vs Garfield vs This

[Hawk Tuah]

Which one makes the better stock stuffer to play with a group of friends?

[Paratech2008]

I'd say Sonic Transformed is the best game. The Garfield games aren't bad and can be found dirt cheap on Fanatical quite often.

Nickelodeon isn't bad. I just dunno about online as it's dead and I have reservations about how long it would interest a group of people.

I play single player and topped 100 hours on the first 2 Sonic Racing games, not caring much for the Team Racing Sonic.

Garfield racing games netted me over 25 hours each and I'm over 10 hours on this game.

[supermichael]

Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed is the best racing game so far, while
Garfield Kart: Furious Racing is the 2nd it is still a good game.

This game Nickelodeon Kart Racers 2: Grand Prix is the worst, I can't progress since my game data decides to erase when it wants.

Sonic and Garfield are both positive games, while Nickelodean is a negative game.

[joesephjOSEPH]

garfield is funny. you feel kind of dopey playing it with friends if you are older and that makes it funny to me. its also the cheapest of the bunch on sale.
sonic transformed i still come across players in ranked- its been the best kart racer on steam for years. $5 on sale its always the best choice. tons of content. the flying and boat modes make it far from just a mario kart clone

nick all star racing is a really good game and has a cool load out system, items and battle mode. online is "dead" but with effort you can find people and connecting with friends through online is easy and really clean. i put it right up there with the other two sonic racing transformed just edges them out on content and active players.

if you only plan to play local with friends super indie karts i have the most fun playing out of everything. its not finished but over the years its seen lots of cool updates and will be getting another big one soon with more tracks characters and modes. maybe in the distant future it could see an online mode. if it had that i'd put it above sonic all stars transformed as its more of a true kart racer only and transformed is its own thing in a lot of ways

[Bouma]

Sonic Allstars Racing Transformed HANDS DOWN.

[NoodlePunk]

As a fan of most nickelodeon and spongebob games on consoles, this game is the worst of them all. Not because it is racing but because its rushed, broken, and a mess. It feels and looks like they slapped it together to cash grab. The ps1 Spongebob Racing game is better than this. If you liked games like x-men legends and marvel nemesis the Nicktoons Smash games are pretty fun.

[Sharki]

sonic is the best one bro

[Sam]

I'm not even a fan of Nickelodeon but I 've played Gardfield, Sonic and I can honestly say this one is way better. Hands down !!!

[MonK]

Sonic Allstars Racing Transformed is by far the best kart racer game you can get on PC. It's as good (if not better) the Mario Kart. The rest of the kart racer games on PC are Mario Kart wannabees

[Azucarilla]

Sonic Allstars Racing Transformed is more complex and elaborate, I think it is better like serious kart game. I was suffer to get everything. But maybe I prefer Nickelodeon Kart Racers 2: Grand Prix to enjoy and continue playing and have fun with friends, easily, who don't have any experience on the game. I dont like Garfield, I prefer with no doubt Coffin Dodgers, I have spectation for second part. I recomend to you to playing.