Sadly worst game of the serie

[MacHorz]

The puzzle/Riddle kinda too tough. there is often no logic way to solve it. Sometimes its random to solve them.

[Apathetic]

can we be fair and say game 1 is the worst.
I dont even think there is 1 puzzle in the first one that you need help with

low key you can spam random stuff and be done with it

[Dimanor3]

Originally posted by MacHorz:

The puzzle/Riddle kinda too tough. there is often no logic way to solve it. Sometimes its random to solve them.

Lol, I don't think a single one of these games were bad at all. Can you name a puzzle that had no logic because from what I recall my friend and I were able to solve each puzzle with logic...

[MacHorz]

Originally posted by Dimanor3:

Originally posted by MacHorz:

The puzzle/Riddle kinda too tough. there is often no logic way to solve it. Sometimes its random to solve them.

Lol, I don't think a single one of these games were bad at all. Can you name a puzzle that had no logic because from what I recall my friend and I were able to solve each puzzle with logic...

the sunken mine: there are pieces of maps and some pipes to turn for 1 person. but not really clear what map and pipes have common. other then that pipes gives the other person air to breath under water. But its not clear what pipes to turn and when.

[Dimanor3]

Originally posted by MacHorz:

Originally posted by Dimanor3:

Lol, I don't think a single one of these games were bad at all. Can you name a puzzle that had no logic because from what I recall my friend and I were able to solve each puzzle with logic...

the sunken mine: there are pieces of maps and some pipes to turn for 1 person. but not really clear what map and pipes have common. other then that pipes gives the other person air to breath under water. But its not clear what pipes to turn and when.

I'll guarantee you're wrong, not far from each pipe is a symbol of sorts, when you've located that symbol the person with the map should be able to roughly pinpoint it and use that information to pipe the air to the right place. It took my friend and I a while to figure it out, but when we did we were able to consistently pipe air to wherever we needed it to go.

Anything else?

[Jack Hawklight]

Originally posted by MacHorz:

the sunken mine: there are pieces of maps and some pipes to turn for 1 person. but not really clear what map and pipes have common. other then that pipes gives the other person air to breath under water. But its not clear what pipes to turn and when.

Like the above guy says, just takes a little bit of time and logic to figure it out. My brother and I managed to figure it out pretty quick anyway. There are also those weird animal markers in addition to the symbols as markers to figure out where the person is and needs to go.

[Quaiv]

Definitely feels a bit tryhard but still a good game overall.

[Nibbie]

The underwater section was definitely the most unclear puzzle in the game, but still had several clues. Both pipes with symbols on them and animal statues would inform the other player of where you were and what you needed.

[ᵀᴴᴱ Uʟₜiᴹₐᵀᴱ ᴰᴱᴳᴱᴺᴱᴿᴬᵀᴱ]

I agree, even if half of puzzles are great, the other half can be boring, too easy or unclear.

[Dimanor3]

Originally posted by Ultima:

I agree, even if half of puzzles are great, the other half can be boring, too easy or unclear.

Well, none of the puzzles were unclear, they all just required you to play around a bit before discovering what was going on. Easy? Sure. Boring? That's an opinion, I found all of the puzzles to be fun personally.

[gamecreator]

All the puzzles make sense in hindsight. Everything is presented clearly and you should always know why you did something by the end.

As for easy/fun/boring, that'll vary from person to person and then puzzle to puzzle.

[Zombra]

My favorite game in the series so far. Each new release is better than the last in my opinion.

[thekins]

my wife and i are playing and ive found quite a few puzzles to be frustrating to get through

When you talk to the kraken without having her just hand me the headphones to listen that would have been an absolute SLOG to go through

uhhhh the place people on the benches in the church was SLIGHTLY clear but also kinda up in the air for a long time

playing the piano its not explained that you go through every single piece one by one and the order could be pretty much anything with the switcharoo it does on 1/3 so you just brute force it cuz theres no way to know which is first

[Dimanor3]

Originally posted by thekins:

When you talk to the kraken without having her just hand me the headphones to listen that would have been an absolute SLOG to go through

Naw, it was pretty easy to do it without having to run through both tasks with only one player. There are different sets of sounds that are organized and you roughly have to sound it out to the other player until the translation is complete.

Originally posted by thekins:

uhhhh the place people on the benches in the
church was SLIGHTLY clear but also kinda up in the air for a long time

Well ya, that's the fun part of this game in my opinion, nothing is explained but clues are all over the place and you have to run around looking for the clues and hints until things start getting pieced together.

Originally posted by thekins:

playing the piano its not explained that you go through every single piece one by one and the order could be pretty much anything with the switcharoo it does on 1/3 so you just brute force it cuz theres no way to know which is first

Of course nothing is explained, clues are all over the place and need to be used in order to solve these puzzles. Also, there are clues that tell you the order the sheets need to be played in, each player gets half of a piece of paper that tells you the order the notes need to be played in. Was fairly easy once we realized what was going on.

[Zombra]

My partner and I found the kraken sound puzzle to be fun and creative. One of the more memorable moments to be honest. It required us to find a new way of communicating information, and isn't that what this series is all about?

That said, sure, if there's a puzzle you absolutely hate and wouldn't have fun figuring out, it's your choice to look things up or otherwise cheat. There's no cash prize for playing it "honest", and sometimes even if you do tough it out, you don't feel satisfied at the end. My friend and I like a challenge and for us getting through the frustration is all part of the fun. (Some of those puzzles took us HOURS but I wouldn't change a thing.) YMMV

[ThisWasSparta]

Worse than WWH:Together? Lol no.