Fishing side quest (BUG?)

[Abuelo Taravangian]

I caught all fishes except the crab. I have been fishing so many times but I can't see the crab. It's RNG or bug???

[Raptimist]

Maybe it's a bug. I have been fishing for 50 days, but I still haven't caught the lobster. Only lobster...

[King Puro]

Originally posted by Raptimist:

Maybe it's a bug. I have been fishing for 50 days, but I still haven't caught the lobster. Only lobster...

it rng trust me i had to get a doctorine that made my odds better when it actitive to catch a lobster it stupid rng there even another fish minus them they just dont have you catch it so it just stupid rng

[Joolin]

for me its the octopus

[King Puro]

Originally posted by Joolin:

for me its the octopus

huh just try and aim for the big 1s i got a octopus 90% of the time from them the other 10% a squid if that dont work that may be a bug if im being honest if you dont get either of those from the very big 1s

[TimsGamingDen]

Just wait till you get the fishing ritual, it will give you LOTS of extra fish (crabs, lobsters etc) and they will will also be pulled with the little fishes ;)

I got all fishing achievements in one such fishing ritual run :D

The Fishing ritual goes on for 2 days, with the fish i get from 2 fishing session i can feed 15+ followers for few days (or sell the big ones for extra gold if needed)

[Zero Grim]

I've done every other quest in the game except the fishing one, I literally got 3/4 of the fish types on my first fishing day and throughout the entire run I have never seen a lobster, though the achievement for "all fish" was awarded to me.

Seems pretty likely to be a bug.

[CptOmnom]

use fishing wonder the you have them prety fast

[Dats SUS Bro]

Yeah its a bug I think, on one of my saves I have needed a lobster since early game and I am on day 114 on that fishing every day no lobster, yet a second save I have I got all four items to give the fisherman within the first two days, don't know the exact specifics but doesnt seem right one gamesave cant get it by 114 days and the other gets it on the second day fishing all completed

[CptOmnom]

Originally posted by Not Sus:

Yeah its a bug I think, on one of my saves I have needed a lobster since early game and I am on day 114 on that fishing every day no lobster, yet a second save I have I got all four items to give the fisherman within the first two days, don't know the exact specifics but doesnt seem right one gamesave cant get it by 114 days and the other gets it on the second day fishing all completed

its not bugged its rng

[.♬• Mr.Fear •♬.]

Originally posted by Raptimist:

Maybe it's a bug. I have been fishing for 50 days, but I still haven't caught the lobster. Only lobster...

same

[Cursed Hawkins]

Originally posted by CptOmnom:

Originally posted by Not Sus:

Yeah its a bug I think, on one of my saves I have needed a lobster since early game and I am on day 114 on that fishing every day no lobster, yet a second save I have I got all four items to give the fisherman within the first two days, don't know the exact specifics but doesnt seem right one gamesave cant get it by 114 days and the other gets it on the second day fishing all completed

its not bugged its rng

And the size of the shadow doesn't matter at least that's how it seems because I've gotten a few of the other requirements with the other shadows instead of just the large.

[Zero Grim]

Originally posted by CptOmnom:

use fishing wonder the you have them prety fast

I didn't take it, because fishing was so boring I didn't want to lock in a ritual I'd never use more than once.

[Bunny]

I got a crab on my first go, so I think it's just bad RNG. I haven't found the other things at all for the guy's quest at all outside that one.