Postgame use for Eye of the Witness?

[cygnia]

So I'm rekilling the 4 Gods to put them to their proper rest. And one of the witnesses respawned as well afterwards after I killed Leshy again. And he dropped another Eye. Can I turn it in for a DLC fleece at Plimbo?

[Cursed Hawkins]

Originally posted by Eldin:

You should be able to yes. Post game is there to unlock everything.

Each eye turned into Plimbo grants a Talisman Fragment meaning to get all the fragments you do need to turn in all four eyes, for each version of the quest as I'm convinced that if you miss one eye for one version of the quest then that's a permanently missed Talisman Fragment.