Guild Wars 2
BoT Hitman 12 ABR 2023 a las 7:03 a. m.
Low playerbase
Why is only ~3-4k active players on steam? Smell's like dead game with expensive dlc
Publicado originalmente por Nibbie:
Publicado originalmente por ah_puch:
ESO has 22,251 and FFXIV has 17,786. Keep in mind, ESO also has thousands of PS and Xbox players so the total playerbase is much, much bigger than GW2 from what is seen here.

The excuses can be endless. However, what they were never able to answer once was why the game only peaked at 8k players and failed to even come close to it for an already humiliatingly low number of players.

Are you sure they were never able to answer, or do you just refuse to understand the answers? Because there are several reasons, and they are pretty easy to understand.

The most obvious and important is newness. FF14 released on Steam in 2014. ESO was also released in 2014. They've had nearly a decade to build a playerbase; GW2 has had less than a year. The steam release has also come much later in the lifecycle of the game, so fewer existing players are willing to transition over.

For some more accurate player count comparisons, when FF14 came out in 2014, it had 7000 players on Steam. That was its peak for more than a year, only beating that with the release of Heavensward, which peaked at 12,000. It wasn't until Stormblood, 2 years after that, that it got any higher.

Likewise, ESO only had about 4000 people when it released, peaking at 7000-8000 after new releases. It only got higher than that after a free week took place 2 years after it came out.

Seeing as GW2 has been out for less than a year and hasn't had a major release in that time to draw players in, I'd say it's doing just as well if not better than your comparisons. Of course we will have to see how it goes over time, but the Steam playerbase has remained very steady since October.
< >
Mostrando 61-75 de 254 comentarios
ah_puch 14 JUN 2023 a las 7:41 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por IAmBadAtThisGame:
this one was the biggest ♥♥♥♥ up i think. seeing 100$ price tag on the "complete" experience definitely scared off alot of players, especially those that cared about doing the story because if they bought the expansions by themselves, they probably wouldn't be able to get wtf is going on without LWS chapters or looking it up online.

Exactly. Even worse, some new players didn't even notice and just bought the $50 edition or whatever then realized a huge portion of the game is still locked behind another $50 paywall.

They tried to ask what's that all about in several forums and met with the hostile playerbase who told them "you should have read" or "they were free on release, you should have logged in years ago" or "it's still a good value, pay the $50 best game in the world". In the end, it was a big fat "Nope".

They felt cheated and yeeted off the game.
Última edición por ah_puch; 14 JUN 2023 a las 10:19 a. m.
Tuathaqin 14 JUN 2023 a las 7:47 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por ah_puch:
Steamcharts is actually a great way to measure population trends.
Only for games that are Steam exclusive. None of the MMOs you like mentioning is.
Assuming anything about non steam population is literally useless since no one has access to that data.
Correct. And yet, your very next sentence:
Even 20% on Steam means GW2's entire concurrent population sits somewhere in 10-15k which is well, tiny to say the least.
I hope the irony doesn't go over your head.
So, how did you come to that 20%? And why would 10-15k be tiny, if at all close to actual numbers?
plan9 14 JUN 2023 a las 1:17 p. m. 
Publicado originalmente por AuldWolf:
Steam is the biggest storefront and indicative of how things are doing. If you don't have visibility and MAUs on Steam, you're not doing well.
Just curious. Are you saying the game wasn't doing well for all of the first 10 years before Steam because there were 0 players on Steam?
Tuathaqin 14 JUN 2023 a las 1:46 p. m. 
Publicado originalmente por plan9:
Publicado originalmente por AuldWolf:
Steam is the biggest storefront and indicative of how things are doing. If you don't have visibility and MAUs on Steam, you're not doing well.
Just curious. Are you saying the game wasn't doing well for all of the first 10 years before Steam because there were 0 players on Steam?
That's an angle that always strikes me as funny. For a decade the game cultivated a large playerbase. It's longevity alone should be a testament to the health of its community. But now that you can also play it through Steam, it's suddenly a dead game because StEaMcHaRtS...
Laughable.
Última edición por Tuathaqin; 14 JUN 2023 a las 1:47 p. m.
plan9 14 JUN 2023 a las 3:34 p. m. 
Publicado originalmente por Tuathaqin:
Publicado originalmente por plan9:
Just curious. Are you saying the game wasn't doing well for all of the first 10 years before Steam because there were 0 players on Steam?
That's an angle that always strikes me as funny. For a decade the game cultivated a large playerbase. It's longevity alone should be a testament to the health of its community. But now that you can also play it through Steam, it's suddenly a dead game because StEaMcHaRtS...
Laughable.
Lol, so it's doing amazingly well on Steam, going from 0 to what, several thousand, almost immediately. :)
Dydzio 14 JUN 2023 a las 11:53 p. m. 
First of all - some popular reviews discourage from playing via steam and many non-tech-savvy and other people do not mess with "provider: portal" thing. People were saying on "gw2 reddit" dead game, then they suddenly shut up when expansion was released. And 4th expansion was also teased soon after last one released and people still talk about "game dead" crap
amarrminer 15 JUN 2023 a las 12:16 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por Dydzio:
First of all - some popular reviews discourage from playing via steam and many non-tech-savvy and other people do not mess with "provider: portal" thing. People were saying on "gw2 reddit" dead game, then they suddenly shut up when expansion was released. And 4th expansion was also teased soon after last one released and people still talk about "game dead" crap

if it really was dead, then they would prolly shut down the forums too. but it is going
nowhere. its another niche mmo. and that is sad, because they had the foundation to something much bigger. the levelling process was better , than in any other mmo.
but that is followed by the worst endgame i have ever seen.
ah_puch 15 JUN 2023 a las 3:51 a. m. 
1,781 players on Steam
AuldWolf 15 JUN 2023 a las 4:07 a. m. 
You can't get away from the numbers on sites like MMO Population. They're right there. I understand denialism but the truth is is that the game is suffering. I've played many MMOs, and do you know what happens when a community turns to toxic, aggressive, hateful denialism in face of the truth? The game dies, because no one is holding the developer accountable. The developer becomes a perfect saint who can do no wrong, so their practises become increasingly more exploitative until their game is finally put on maintenance.

So long as money can be wrung out of a game, it'll never be "shut down," they won't shut down the forums or the game for so long as they're getting more money out of it than they're putting in. This is why maintenance mode becomes a thing, since the profits from those who still play the game are greater thant he server costs. It's not about revenue, it's all about profit. If, after server costs, you still see enough profit? They keep it going.

That's what happened with WildStar for a long time, before the server costs rose above the profits and it was shut down. WildStar was published by NCSoft, same as Guild Wars 2, so I don't doubt that GW2 will be sunsetted one of these days, but it's going to have a protracted period of maintenance first so they can wring out every last penny.

If even a small amount of shop cosmetics are selling to a tiny community, that's still enough for the profits to rise above the server costs.

The game is dying. The MAUs are 340~k players, including Steam's 2-4~k. Which places it in 11th as MMO populations go, only right above ESO which is also suffering at the moment. Of course, the prominent difference is that ZeniMax has openly admitted that ESO is suffering and they've pledged to do something about it, because their community kicked up enough of a fuss.

So ESO might be saved where WildStar wasn't. Why wasn't WildStar saved?

Everything is fine! 8D

That's what the rats scream while the boat sinks.

The WildStar community did exactly what the GW2 community is doing now: aggressive, toxic denialism. Instead of pressuring ArenaNet to improve the situation to draw in new players, ANet has ascended to godhood where they can do no wrong. Which makes it very, very easy to exploit the remaining players—just as WildStar did—until the game is no longer profitable.

I'm likely a bigger Guild Wars 2 fan than any of the toxic denialists here, which is why I want to admit this is a damn problem and push ArenaNet to do something about it. Their new player experience is awful, their marketing is awful, and their community is a toxic mess. If you look at all three of these factors? It's clear why the game is dying.

And this aggressive denialism looks like dead game to anyone dropping by.

Yes, it does.

Think about every time you've checked out an old MMO. If you saw the community being aggressively toxic in denying that the game is doing poorly, despite the facts (the actual, real numbers that we have)? What would that say to you? "These guys are desperate, this looks like a dying game."

Guild Wars 2 is dying. 11th place, 340~k users and dropping, horrible new player retention as shown by Steam metrics. It's a fact that Guild Wars 2 is dying. So what are we going to do about it? We need to get ArenaNet to take their thumbs out of their butt and fix the worst problems so that the game is more appealing to newcomers.

And the community needs to stop being so aggressively toxic with their denialism. It doesn't look good to anyone dropping by.

And to reiterate? Claiming Steam isn't important is moronic. If that was true? You wouldn't be here. That you are here shows that you believe that Steam is important, so ignoring Steam metrics is just yet more denialism.

If you don't want to face up to that? Have fun being the next WildStar.
Última edición por AuldWolf; 15 JUN 2023 a las 4:10 a. m.
takeshi miike's gozu on dvd 15 JUN 2023 a las 4:20 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por AuldWolf:
You can't get away from the numbers on sites like MMO Population. They're right there.

while i agree about denialism part, mmo population is literally a worthless, ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ resource. https://mmo-population.com/about/ literally on their website, they use reddit as their basis and most recent publicly known player count for their calculation. it's especially ♥♥♥♥♥♥ up with the blackouts because the data isn't updated rn. the same website rn shows that GW2 is at 350k~ players https://i.imgur.com/KUxjpKI.png

even stats on games like roblox are incorrect despite giving live player count. https://i.imgur.com/541Z9He.png vs real numbers https://i.imgur.com/BNIat8K.png

even ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ wildstar is on the list with active players despite having closed servers few years back
takeshi miike's gozu on dvd 15 JUN 2023 a las 4:24 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por IAmBadAtThisGame:
Publicado originalmente por AuldWolf:
You can't get away from the numbers on sites like MMO Population. They're right there.

while i agree about denialism part, mmo population is literally a worthless, ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ resource. https://mmo-population.com/about/ literally on their website, they use reddit as their basis and most recent publicly known player count for their calculation. it's especially ♥♥♥♥♥♥ up with the blackouts because the data isn't updated rn. the same website rn shows that GW2 is at 350k~ players https://i.imgur.com/KUxjpKI.png

even stats on games like roblox are incorrect despite giving live player count. https://i.imgur.com/541Z9He.png vs real numbers https://i.imgur.com/BNIat8K.png

even ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ wildstar is on the list with active players despite having closed servers few years back
ALSO, there's marvel heroes on the list which closed down in 2017, tera which dies this or last year, spiral knight apparently has 12k active players despite having 100 players on average on steam charts.

there are few more titles on that list like this but my point is, don't use ♥♥♥♥ resources like this to prove your point. steam charts n official numbers are pretty much the only resources that you can trust
Tuathaqin 15 JUN 2023 a las 5:57 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por ah_puch:
1,781 players on Steam
Enough with the news. How about the weather?
ah_puch 15 JUN 2023 a las 11:04 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por IAmBadAtThisGame:
ALSO, there's marvel heroes on the list which closed down in 2017, tera which dies this or last year, spiral knight apparently has 12k active players despite having 100 players on average on steam charts.

there are few more titles on that list like this but my point is, don't use ♥♥♥♥ resources like this to prove your point. steam charts n official numbers are pretty much the only resources that you can trust

It goes to show how badly they wanna believe a fake source and deny the real numbers because reality of the situation is far worse than anticipated. Also, that last studio update was the weakest one yet.
Última edición por ah_puch; 15 JUN 2023 a las 11:05 a. m.
Tuathaqin 15 JUN 2023 a las 11:17 a. m. 
Publicado originalmente por ah_puch:
It goes to show how badly they wanna believe a fake source and deny the real numbers because reality of the situation is far worse than anticipated. Also, that last studio update was the weakest one yet.
Who has denied that real number of yours?
plan9 15 JUN 2023 a las 12:19 p. m. 
Publicado originalmente por AuldWolf:
Everything is fine! 8D

That's what the rats scream while the boat sinks.

You ignored my perfectly polite and reasonable question, now you're reversing quotes that have been around for hundreds of years. You don't make a lot of sense.

"The idiom like rats fleeing a sinking ship, used in reference to people abandoning an enterprise once it seems likely to fail, has [...] been in regular use for over four hundred years."
Take a look: https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/like-rats-fleeing-a-sinking-ship-history

Publicado originalmente por AuldWolf:

Their new player experience is awful [...] and their community is a toxic mess.

And this aggressive denialism looks like dead game to anyone dropping by.

Are you a new player? I started last October and *didn't* have an "awful experience" and the game definitely *didn't* look "dead" in the Steam forums, the web forums or, especially, in game.

On Steam, I mostly payed attention to the friendly, helpful posts and kinda chuckled at the trolls. Did you count how many times you said "toxic", "denialism" and "dead". If there's toxicity going on, it's long, predominantly angry and negative posts like yours.

I, certainly, don't mind if you bring up problems with the game, but what I saw was a lot of attacking the community. That puts people in a defensive mode, which you think is denialism. That's not denialism, that's pushing back against *your* toxicity.

"You catch more flies with honey..." ;)
< >
Mostrando 61-75 de 254 comentarios
Por página: 1530 50

Publicado el: 12 ABR 2023 a las 7:03 a. m.
Mensajes: 251