Grand Theft Auto III

Grand Theft Auto III

Icesnake 2021 年 10 月 22 日 下午 12:09
New """"""remastered"""""trilogy graphics look like absolute horsesh*t
I couldnt believe to my eyes when I saw the newest trailer. The old artstyle was completely butchered. This trilogy looks visually closer to The Sims than its original GTA games. We lost the old GTA trilogy+open source mod for this full priced garbage? Gaming is f*ckn dead. Nice anniversary gift Rockstar.
最后由 Icesnake 编辑于; 2021 年 10 月 22 日 下午 12:10
< >
正在显示第 31 - 45 条,共 51 条留言
onoffon 2021 年 10 月 23 日 下午 12:50 
引用自 FR - Spl1t -
I actually agree. It looks pretty awful, which is why I'm still gonna play those games with the originals modded rather than this. It doesn't reflect any atmosphere from those games, at least visually. I'm sure it's gonna be ok for the rest... but what a mess they did with the graphics.

Everything looks like plastic dolls, with shiny reflections everywhere (why? that doesn't mean it's more "realistic"), the characters, especially the ones from VC are absolutely butchered, like they're made from Play'Doh for some, even the skin of the characters doesn't seem correct. There's a big uncanny valley vibe when you look at those games. Even SA sometimes, but it's the best one to look at in my opinion.

I don't know, doesn't sound good. Especially since the devs are the ones responsible of the SA remaster, which was a complete disaster.
I just simply dont get why these graphics need a 4gb GPU. 🥶🥶🥶🥶
V I D A L 2021 年 10 月 23 日 下午 2:13 
引用自 Masterpanos
Something you havent brought up and i'd like to hear your opinion on it as well, is the mood/tone of the games that has changed in the trilogy. GTA3 was hit the hardest from the 3 and went from having an overal late 90s depression mood, a matrix like bluegreenish pallete when it rains and a feverish dream ghosting trails option, to look like a discount GTA 4 in terms of aesthetics.
Vice city now looks a bit over saturated but its acceptable as an improvement.
San Andreas is missing its epic orange tone and now the city looks like its wearing a terrible graphics mod.
I absolutely noticed this immediately and agree with it. I will excuse the ghosting trails of GTA3 and VC... but the colour pallet is something that I always thought it was a big part of the visual identity of GTA3 and SA. VC was somewhere in the middle.

I immediately noticed this in the trailer on the GTA3 car rain scene. GTA3 for me is very iconic for that blueish hue on top of the game as well as SA with the organge.

In SA original you normally can't even see a blue sky, because they yellowish/orange hue on top makes the sky slightly green.

This is gone due to a more realistic physics render lighting system of Unreal. Bummer they didn't take the creative liberties of adding that artistry detail.

However, let me remind you that the orange hue was entirely missing on GTASA PC port anyway... 1 of the many ways the PC port was butchered compared to the PS2 original.

In any case I already have a solution up my sleeve. Reshade. I pretty much apply reshade in every game I play for some reason or another to adjust things to my liking. It's going to be pretty straight forward to bring those colours back to these games on my end. So I'm not too concerned about.
V I D A L 2021 年 10 月 23 日 下午 2:19 
引用自 Masterpanos
People,(including me) complaining mostly because nobody realy asked for a remastered gta trilogy since the original trilogy has aged like fine wine and because there was no need for the old versions to be removed from steam and open source devs to be bullied like this.
That's not quite true.
First, yes.. everyone have been asking for these 3 games to be remastered since remastering games became so common place last generation. It has been brought up non stop for years.

Second, it's not about how it aged.. it's about how completely broken these 3 versions were. For me, I would be ok if they had not changed anything in the graphics at all... but they still needed a modern version/patch/remaster what have you. They are simply unplayable out of the box, requiring extensive modding to get them working.

The best authentic solution we had was the Reversed Engineering project, which I tried but it was full of bugs. Ran great, looked great, but the bugs prevented me from keep playing it.

The thing is.. there would be no way Rockstar would be able to please everyone. If they had played save and only update the game to have modern OS support, widescreen, upscaled HUD and menus etc.. people would say they were lazy and didn't do enough.
Icesnake 2021 年 10 月 23 日 下午 4:02 
@V I D A L I agree on the original trilogy being broken on pc. I remember I always had mouse issue with San andreas and vice city and I remember the pc shaders to be not as vibrant in San Andreas. All these can be fixed with mods, but that does not change the fact that the vanilla pc versions are broken.
I guess modders may try to restore the original aesthetics on the remastered version in the future, so not all hope is lost on that.

To make a remaster or not especially on a beloved game that carries lots of history on its shoulders, is a difficult question to answer. Sometimes its best not to make a remaster at all; only apply some fixes and preserve it for the future gamers.
Half Life 2, as someone mentioned above, may feel now outdated, but its a well made product of its time and the limited graphic fidelity/gameplay is a vessel that may take a modern gamer back to the past and therefore does not need a remake.
On the other hand, even though I throw lots of crap to nuBlizzard, I gotta partially give it to them for Starcraft Remastered. The game's visual transition to the modern era was done almost perfectly but, nublizzard being nublizzard, they have messed up on modernizing the online aspect.

I will admit I was a bit hasty to say that nobody wanted a remastered gta trilogy. Im sure that some people do want this, but I believe if you ask every rockstar fan, they will say that they would prefer to have a new next gen gta game instead. I know I would. I got sick of seeing gta v getting re-released for the 2nd time. Time to see a new gta game.

This remaster will definetly divide the gta community and only time will tell if people will end up loving or hating it.
As for me, my mind has been made. Personally, the visuals are a major deal breaker but I respect that lots of people are digging it.
I just had to let it out, since I love rockstar games and that trailer kinda shocked me.
最后由 Icesnake 编辑于; 2021 年 10 月 23 日 下午 4:14
V I D A L 2021 年 10 月 23 日 下午 7:03 
You can be sure that this remastered trilogy does not get in the way of GTA 6 existing. That has a lot more to do with them being busy creating content for GTA Online non stop for years than anything else.

They haven't spoke about it, but more often than not, remasters and remakes are done by other teams. Rockstar North may not even have anything to do with it. Who knows?

Me personally, am a big fan of the type of remaster Nightdive studios does. It's almost like an update, They keep most assets, animations and visuals untouched and simply polish the textures and lights and that is what I was expecting from GTA Trilogy. They went above and beyond and I'm happy with that.

I've tried GTA SA modding before.. It's just not enough. No amount of modding can really bring those games to modern standards even with all the graphical updates, there are quality of life improvements the trilogy will bring that it's beyond the scope of modding. Like modern gameplay overhaul.

I also suspect that the fade to black we see when entering buildings might be gone. In one of the screenshots of SA, I think I can see the inside of CJ's house, which may indicate you will be able to walk in without a black fade.

Lastly, regarding mods.. this may look like a step back.. but there are two steps forward in exchange. As much as Take Two don't like mods anymore, Unreal Engine 4 is far more accessible than Renderware ever was. It's modern, it's freely available to EVERYONE to play around with and far more programmable and flexible. It's literally designed to be modified.

Just as an example.. Skyrim remastered.
The community was pissed when Skyrim remastered was announced as it was no longer going to be compatible with any existing mods. But, the original Skyrim was 32bits, the remaster was 64bits and that modern update open the doors for modders to push Skyrim modding far beyond what was possible before. Highly modded Skyrim today looks insane thanks to the improvements the remastered provided.

They can't stop mods and I think the modding scene will only expand. Games on Unreal Engine 4 often receive dozens of modes all around. Guilty Gear Strive had mods day one.

In a couple of years, the modding scene will be far more impressive than the originals ever were. U4 also supports real ray tracing and you can bet the mods will flow in out of control.
最后由 V I D A L 编辑于; 2021 年 10 月 23 日 下午 7:08
Iggy Wolf 2021 年 10 月 23 日 下午 8:00 
^There was actually a lot of interiors in GTA SA that went unused. But they were in the game. They were just hidden in the "Hidden Interiors Universe". I wonder if they'll somehow incorporate them now, since loading times hopefully won't be an issue anymore. Hopefully it's not TOO many interiors for the game to handle at once. Big Smoke's Crack Palace alone is 4 floors. And then of course there's the casino and Sherman Dam.
Icesnake 2021 年 10 月 24 日 上午 2:40 
If Unreal proved to be a better ground for modders, then this remaster might turn out to be good in the end. I'd love modders to recreate a fan made remastered version, just like some vc videos I have seen on youtube. In the end of the day, the old gta games are enjoyable only if you mod them but I still find no reason to buy this remastered trilogy any time soon.
From what I have gathered, the guys behind this remaster are a small team that is responsible for rockstar's mediocre android ports. Lets hope these unused interiors to make an appearance here.
V I D A L 2021 年 10 月 24 日 上午 3:11 
More importantly.. We haven't really seen the game yet. All the trailer does is to show a bunch of cutscenes and some sporadic city views from cinematic cameras. I wonder how it will really look like during real gameplay.. on foot walking around or driving, shooting and everything in between.

Will Rockstar really release the game without ever showing us gameplay? Even the screenshots are from those cinematic angles.

I want to see at least one screenshot straight up from gameplay. Behind the character with hud on screen etc.

I'm not to worried about this being developed by the same team that did the Androind version.. Those ports were made 10 years ago for cell phones. Considering that, they were quite impressive. The real shame was when it got ported to Xbox360 and PS3.. that was a big dumb mistake. But as 10 years old phone games, they were quite decent. I did buy GTA3 for Iphone 4 back in 2011 and I was quite blown away to have it on my freaking phone.
最后由 V I D A L 编辑于; 2021 年 10 月 24 日 上午 3:14
Captain Morgan 2021 年 10 月 24 日 上午 3:18 
By the way, the people behind the remastered Trilogy, are the ones responsible for the broken, hot garbage, remaster of GTA San Andreas. Their illustrious work is already discussed in detail and presented nicely:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jhVdb4K1M-M

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTxY_S0XD8E&t=1065s

Compare, contrast, calculate, estimate. Good luck with the new cashgrabs err, i mean gems!

Grove Street Games, formerly known as War Drum Studios... Straight bustas
Nakatomi 2021 年 10 月 26 日 下午 1:24 
Well theres rumours going around that the Switch version will have GTA3 on cart only the other 2 need to be downloaded.
Sanctuary 2021 年 10 月 26 日 下午 2:34 
here is how mafia definitive edition looks like, a complete faithful remake, made by people who care about art and quality. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfwfA_iTOng
in your face
get some
get some
最后由 Sanctuary 编辑于; 2021 年 10 月 26 日 下午 2:40
V I D A L 2021 年 10 月 26 日 下午 3:08 
引用自 NO UWU
here is how mafia definitive edition looks like, a complete faithful remake, made by people who care about art and quality. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfwfA_iTOng
in your face
get some
get some

Not a fair comparison.
First of all.. It's a remake. A complete remake.
"Faithful" to what degree you mean? It tells the same story mission by mission.. but everything was heavily redesigned. Completely different character personalities, different actors, different music, completely different gameplay, systems and everything else. It's a full remake.

That's not what GTA DE is, nor what the majority wanted.

I know all of you kids whose first GTA was GTA V and you have been playing nothing but GTA Online for 8 years, wanted this remaster to be a remake to look just like GTA V.

But the rest of us boomers wanted as little change as possible. Remastered graphics, some quality of life improvements and that's it. Don't touch anything else.

I'm buying this to relive the nostalgia of the originals. Not to have a brand new experience.

最后由 V I D A L 编辑于; 2021 年 10 月 26 日 下午 3:09
Icesnake 2021 年 10 月 26 日 下午 3:33 
@V I D A L Honestly as a fellow boomer I wouldnt mind a complete realistic remake of the GTA trilogy. Resident evil remakes were proven to be very successfull. I do not like these "few" changes that GTA definitive edition has that rockstar uses as an excuse to charge full price. Either go the whole way or not at all. Besides with all these changes,(gameplay mechanics, new engine, new coat of graphics, new lighting system etc), GTA DE can be labeled as a "poor man's remake".
最后由 Icesnake 编辑于; 2021 年 10 月 26 日 下午 3:35
Sanctuary 2021 年 10 月 26 日 下午 3:34 
引用自 V I D A L
Not a fair comparison.
+15 rockstar social club credits
Both are named definitive edition. Rockstar has much more money, so yes, not a fair comparison. David defeated Goliath.

I am wondering why I see you everywhere on steam forums defending anti-customer ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥, are you paid for it, or you just feel good for being a loyal fanboy?
How do you have so much time to be present everywhere?

You feel alright defending a halfarsed job, despite you should demand QUALITY from a company that has all money of the world? Because it is in your best interests, as a consumer, to get a product as good as possible.

Why me, a "kid", should teach you, a "boomer" about such simple things?

Mafia Definitive Edition is as good as possible.
GTA Trilogy definitive edition isn't.
最后由 Sanctuary 编辑于; 2021 年 10 月 26 日 下午 3:44
Iggy Wolf 2021 年 10 月 26 日 下午 3:44 
Perhaps he's just defending people's right to like the game, since apparently anyone who likes it is labeled a "fanboy" or "paid troll". And that he's fair to point out that this game was NOT going to be a remake. Why is that such a problem? Did you also complain when COD MW was merely "remastered" as opposed to remade? Or perhaps the recent Alan Wake REMASTER? Or Assassin's Creed 3 Remastered? Should they have ALL been remade just because people THINK it should have been remade?

Well, companies don't work for free and they sure as hell don't waste time, effort, and money remaking something if they don't think said time, effort, and money is worth it. Especially if the intention to retain the original aesthetic is part of their goal and mission. If you don't like it, no one forces you to buy it. Move on and stop ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ about it. I swear, it's like all the idiots and trolls that kept ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ about the price and quality of the SR3 Remaster, even though they had no intention of buying it anyway.

If you don't care about it, why are you still here complaining then? It's the SAME ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ THING EVERY TIME a remaster comes out. People act like the companies are stealing their wallets and forcing them at gunpoint to play the damn things. I don't even remember this much vitriol for the Sleeping Dogs Definitive Edition, and if anything would be considered a "lazy remaster", it would be that and Mafia II.
< >
正在显示第 31 - 45 条,共 51 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

发帖日期: 2021 年 10 月 22 日 下午 12:09
回复数: 51