help with the guild of assasins

[Grimm]

so i am in angel path and i am trying to make good choices, but there is a moral dilema, should i kill the guild of assasins? or should i let them live? they are assasins but so far the only thing that i saw them try to kill are demons, whadya think?

[アンジェル]

That is less a question about assassins and more about opporturnists and mercenaries. If you kept Greybor or Wenduag as angel, then you can let them live as well.

[Aradon]

I felt that lawful would be to take them down (unless you rationalize that such organizations are part of an orderly society in the Abyss, which is fair). Good has more flexibility- you can take Ember's approach to good as 'do no harm,' and just try and keep them from doing evil and not working directly with them, or you can take the Paladin-style "Good fights all evil."

D&D is a bit weird- if it has an evil subtype or alignment, righteous warriors are generally justified in fighting them on that basis alone. But there are other philosophies too. Shelyn, a good deity, would try and win them over as long as it's possible, while Iomedae probably wouldn't mind a fight, so you get to choose your own preference.

[Grimm]

good point, thought wenduag is ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ dead by now, and greybor is sitting just acumulating dust over the corner

[Grimm]

Originally posted by Aradon:

I felt that lawful would be to take them down (unless you rationalize that such organizations are part of an orderly society in the Abyss, which is fair). Good has more flexibility- you can take Ember's approach to good as 'do no harm,' and just try and keep them from doing evil and not working directly with them, or you can take the Paladin-style "Good fights all evil."

D&D is a bit weird- if it has an evil subtype or alignment, righteous warriors are generally justified in fighting them on that basis alone. But there are other philosophies too. Shelyn, a good deity, would try and win them over as long as it's possible, while Iomedae probably wouldn't mind a fight, so you get to choose your own preference.

what do you think that a sarenrae follower would do?

[Grimm]

probably something about spare them and let them live, since if they are dead they can't repent, and since there are no demons there too...

[Grimm]

by the way should i tell greybor to join them?

[アンジェル]

Originally posted by Grimm:

by the way should i tell greybor to join them?

It would make him a happy dwarf.

[Grimm]

happy dwarf is better than grumpy dwarf