bastard sword is OP

[joonkimdmd]

It has crazy amount of base damage + decent crit range.
And then if I double the crit range from 19~20 into 17~20, I get to do crazy amount of crit damage.
I think weapons are unbalanced.
Do you see a reason to pick a different weapon?

[Gandalf The Queen]

Roleplay, not wanting to take the exotic profic, magic items of a different type.

[Mr Fred]

Every weapon dmg pretty much end up the same once enlarged plus its not that special of a crit range. Its a niche weapon decent on a magus swapping between 1 hand plus spell combat and 2handed power attack pretty much.

[erian]

Originally posted by joonkimdmd:

It has crazy amount of base damage + decent crit range.
And then if I double the crit range from 19~20 into 17~20, I get to do crazy amount of crit damage.
I think weapons are unbalanced.
Do you see a reason to pick a different weapon?

Estoc is plain better. Rapier,falcata and scimitar are comparable.

[joonkimdmd]

Originally posted by erian:

Originally posted by joonkimdmd:

It has crazy amount of base damage + decent crit range.
And then if I double the crit range from 19~20 into 17~20, I get to do crazy amount of crit damage.
I think weapons are unbalanced.
Do you see a reason to pick a different weapon?

Estoc is plain better. Rapier,falcata and scimitar are comparable.

How about dagger vs rapier?
My woljif has daggers but I think rapier has wider crit range and higher damage output. The only downside is dagger is light so I can duel wield without penalty but I think that's about it.

[Gaarthar]

Scimitar has a higher crit range, which has a good synergy with effects that happen when you crit.