Dont buy this game. Its going to be removed from steam for copy paste steal

[Purpleetea]

Im here to watch worl is burning
https://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/11p89p5/it_seems_soulslike_bleak_faith_forsaken_is_using/

[amrulez]

The dev replied to these issues on discord

[Chacheya1G]

Originally posted by amrulez:

The dev replied to these issues on discord

And nothing they said clears them of the consequences.

[GloriousZote]

Originally posted by amrulez:

The dev replied to these issues on discord

You should look up what the definition of "lying" is.
Because the devs do a lot of it.

[Corgi-Beast]

Originally posted by amrulez:

The dev replied to these issues on discord

Which one was it?
They flipped flopped too many times.

"akhsually it's just rotoscoping"
"akhsually miyazaki outsources animations too!"
"akhsually you can only do that many axe animations"

(implying they're just similar by nature, because of weapon type, meanwhile same studio darksouls1 vs darksouls 2 all animations are different while elden ring vs bleak faith are 1:1 identical in model bone movement
That means someone making animations had to attach all movesets to every models bone perfectly, that includes how ankles/knee/hips/torso/shoulders/elbow/wrist etc. moves together in sync (yes, it is impossible, unless you ripped off original animations and files> and copied them))

[Alligator]

If the animations were bought from the Unreal marketplace then the only one who could get sued is Epic.

[Kashra Fall]

Originally posted by Alligator:

If the animations were bought from the Unreal marketplace then the only one who could get sued is Epic.

Wrong, the moment the developers resold it, they are also at fault. If it was used for a mod, then you'd be right, but reselling copyright material is well, against the law. There would be three parties at fault here, the seller, the distributer and the buyer, all because they used them in a game and sold it.

Also, no law in the world will save you if you claim simple negligence. They'd simply say you should of did a bit more research before buying it. It's the same as you buying a TV from someone. If the TV was stolen, you still lose the TV and have the possibility of getting in trouble for possession of said TV etc.

[Alligator]

Originally posted by Kashra Fall:

Originally posted by Alligator:

If the animations were bought from the Unreal marketplace then the only one who could get sued is Epic.

Wrong, the moment the developers resold it, they are also at fault. If it was used for a mod, then you'd be right, but reselling copyright material is well, against the law. There would be three parties at fault here, the seller, the distributer and the buyer, all because they used them in a game and sold it.

No, the buyer has no obligation to verify if the animations were stolen. How would they even verify it, are the developers supposed to play every game ever made to make sure that every asset that they legally bought from a marketplace wasn't stolen?

[Meztelen (猪虼螂)]

"Dont buy this game. Its going to be removed from steam"

That's it, you convinced me, I'll buy it before it gets removed (*cough* as if *cough*) from the store. Thanks for triggering a FOMO in me and making the choice easier.

[GloriousZote]

Originally posted by Alligator:

Originally posted by Kashra Fall:

Wrong, the moment the developers resold it, they are also at fault. If it was used for a mod, then you'd be right, but reselling copyright material is well, against the law. There would be three parties at fault here, the seller, the distributer and the buyer, all because they used them in a game and sold it.

No, the buyer has no obligation to verify if the animations were stolen. How would they even verify it, are the developers supposed to play every game ever made to make sure that every asset that they legally bought from a marketplace wasn't stolen?

If you buy a stolen car, you don't get to keep it if it's found to be stolen.

[Kashra Fall]

Originally posted by Alligator:

Originally posted by Kashra Fall:

Wrong, the moment the developers resold it, they are also at fault. If it was used for a mod, then you'd be right, but reselling copyright material is well, against the law. There would be three parties at fault here, the seller, the distributer and the buyer, all because they used them in a game and sold it.

No, the buyer has no obligation to verify if the animations were stolen. How would they even verify it, are the developers supposed to play every game ever made to make sure that every asset that they legally bought from a marketplace wasn't stolen?

Lol are you serious? You do research before you purchase something. Please, PLEASE try to do something like this and have it hold up in a court of law. Waste your money and your time. Negligence is not something the law would forgive, especially something for something like copyright.

[Alligator]

Originally posted by GloriousZote:

Originally posted by Alligator:

No, the buyer has no obligation to verify if the animations were stolen. How would they even verify it, are the developers supposed to play every game ever made to make sure that every asset that they legally bought from a marketplace wasn't stolen?

If you buy a stolen car, you don't get to keep it if it's found to be stolen.

Well it's certainly complicated, but if the devs are forced to remove the animations then they could likely sue Epic for damages from selling them these stolen animations.

[Alligator]

Originally posted by Kashra Fall:

Originally posted by Alligator:

No, the buyer has no obligation to verify if the animations were stolen. How would they even verify it, are the developers supposed to play every game ever made to make sure that every asset that they legally bought from a marketplace wasn't stolen?

Lol are you serious? You do research before you purchase something. Please, PLEASE try to do something like this and have it hold up in a court of law. Waste your money and your time. Negligence is not something the law would forgive, especially something for something like copyright.

What did the devs neglect? If you buy an asset from the Unreal marketplace you can legally use it in any Unreal engine project. There is literally no way for you to verify if the asset you bought wasn't stolen from somewhere and obviously you're not legally obligated to verify anything because it would be impossible to do.

[Alligator]

Btw the animations are still being sold by Epic: https://www.unrealengine.com/marketplace/en-US/profile/PersiaNinja?count=20&sortBy=effectiveDate&sortDir=DESC&start=0

[GloriousZote]

Originally posted by Alligator:

Originally posted by Kashra Fall:

Lol are you serious? You do research before you purchase something. Please, PLEASE try to do something like this and have it hold up in a court of law. Waste your money and your time. Negligence is not something the law would forgive, especially something for something like copyright.

What did the devs neglect? If you buy an asset from the Unreal marketplace you can legally use it in any Unreal engine project. There is literally no way for you to verify if the asset you bought wasn't stolen from somewhere and obviously you're not legally obligated to verify anything because it would be impossible to do.

They made a soulslike game, and "accidentally" bought assets connected to extremely memorable bosses of three Fromsoft franchises, sorrynotsorry, but X for doubt.

[soso]

The most embarrassing statement was how they suddenly knew the inner workings of FromSoftware and accused them of outsourcing their own animations which is pure ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥.