END GAME SPOILERS - Who I accused at the end

[StormCloud]

So I have seen some threads going on about who is guilty of what, so I decided to tell who I acussed of what and the reasons for doing so

The End To End All Crimes - I accused Dainonigate. He literally confessed to doing so, he had the murder weapon, was at the scene of the crime.
I didn't acussed the Killer Demon because I assume that since he is dead, the Council manage to kill him before they were killed.

K. HX is Missing - I accused Yuri Night. K. HX had Yuri's ring in his hand, Yuri closed the boat ride early near where the body was.

Henry's Demonic Possesion - I accused Yuri Night. He had access to the library, he accessed the restricted vault where the demonic books are kept.

Who Killed The Holy Seal Marshals? - I accused Grand Marshall Akiko 14. She removed two prisoners from the barracks, she didn't allow Doctor Doom Jazz to examine the bodies, her sword matched the murder weapon used in the bodies.

The Second Holy Seal - I accused Lydia Day Break (Sam Day Break ended up accused too, because he admited helping her and going through the seals). Her car left tyre tracks near the obelisks area, the space helmet had her perfume, her tablet had the keys from the obelisks.

Henry's Escape - I accused Grand Marshall Akiko 14. The prison bars had military grade explosive trace in it, she had broke procedure and went to kill Henry alone, her time line was impossible.

Who Opened The Third Seal? - I accused Dainonigate (Sam Day Break ended up accused too, because of his other crime). His blood was at the lock, he is Eyes Kiwami son so his blood can open the lock.

Who Breached The Fourth Holy Seal? - I accused Dainonigate (Sam Day Break ended up accused too, because of his other crime). He has The Crying Grudge blood fused in his body.

The Mystery Of The Dead Killer Demon - I accused Witness. His phone unlocked the crate, he used the bunker at the Dead Zone as a illegal lab and there were posters there of the Killer Demon, he was asking all around the knownledgable ones about demonology.

The Murder Of Grace Bloodlines - I accused Carmelina. She told Akiko to leave the room, Grace's murdered had a wedding ring and Carmelina was married at the time.


At the end the only non suspects for me were:
- Crimson Acid - She was cool, helped me a lot and was way to easy to be blamed for not having an alibi. I ended up sleeping with her
- Doctor Doom Jazz - He was friendly, gave a lot of assistance with my evidences, was just lazy to not fix the door. I also slept with him
- Henry Division - He cursed a lot and I appreciated it, he was honest, he was only being used. Would have slept with him if given the chance
- One Last Kiss - She was weird and a ghost and gave me basically no help with my cases.
- Shinji - I loved him and wouldn't accuse him even if given the chance.

[Minuano]

Same as me. Although I hear that you can get Witness convicted without ever implicating Lydia and Sam if you want to.

[StormCloud]

Originally posted by Minuano:

Same as me. Although I hear that you can get Witness convicted without ever implicating Lydia and Sam if you want to.

Yeah, I heard that too, but I decided that if I wanted Perfect 25 to be perfect, every one conect to the Council murder should pay for it

[Tale]

Same as me, though in retrospect I wish I'd avoided accusing Sam and Lydia. It might have let Witness get off, but I could always execute him afterwards. They deserved freedom.

[Tizoc]

I still have my save data from before starting the trial, so I'll see if I can get the Day Breaks spared.

[Waffles]

You can just accuse Yuri or Dainonigate of breaching the seals and if you've done enough investigating you'll have plenty of evidence to convict Witness without Sam & Lydia's confessions. The Judge was surprisingly uninterested in how the box got there for me.

[JSNLV]

I was really hoping that the revelation that Witness's conspiracy was taking form two days earlier meant you'd be able to implicate the involvement of Syndicate members who'd already passed to the next island, particularly once One Last Kiss pointed out the flaw in Perfect 25. (The flaw being that by making the landscape immune to demonic corruption, the Citizens are going to be possessed a lot more frequently, so it's going to be another miserable island full of crime.) No such luck, though. I guess technically any understanding we have about involvement of folks like Isiah and Madam Complex is only available to us as players, not to Lady Luck Dies herself (at least at this point).

[K1ttenface]

Originally posted by Minuano:

Same as me. Although I hear that you can get Witness convicted without ever implicating Lydia and Sam if you want to.

I thought I had every bit of evidence in the game when i started the trial but I didn't manage it. Accusing Witness just said there was insufficent evidence and the accusation defaulted to Henry.

[Renoehe]

I did a second go of the trials and yeah it's possible to convict Witness w/o implicating the Daybreaks. The key evidence seems to be linking the phone number on the Killer Demon's box to Witness making a call at midnight.

[yonsito]

Originally posted by Tale:

Same as me, though in retrospect I wish I'd avoided accusing Sam and Lydia. It might have let Witness get off, but I could always execute him afterwards. They deserved freedom.

For breaking all of the four seals and secretly placing a large box with -supposedly unknown- contents in the council room? You think they thought they were delivering party treats?

[twitch.tv/lolisamurai]

I felt like the doctor was still somewhat responsible. It was likely him who wiped the birth records and he had to know what he was doing, so I ended up exiling him. man it sure felt bad sentencing all these fun characters to death but justice is justice. this game was one hell of an experience

[tm080201]

I just finished the game and I need to talk about it. I did all the same as you, but I did not accuse the daybreaks. Considering their pasts as professional assassins, I didn't think it was plausible they'd leave all that evidence behind. I was able to successfully accuse Witness without implicating them. I figured they had been set up, but that also may have been me overlooking evidence because of how much I liked them.

I didn't exile anyone. I felt like the remainder were genuinely innocent. Maybe Doom Jazz should be for his negligence, but who knows.

I love that in this game I'm pretty sure I pursued the truth, but also I'm not 100% sure and I'm still thinking about everything. God, I hope they do a sequel.

[honeyvenom]

I got the same results as OP (including who I slept with). I really hope they make a sequel as well - I can't describe how much I loved this game. I never get so into a game as I did with this one!

[Nemorov]

This game was great. I really hope they make a sequel. I came to the same conclusions as OP, even though I REALLY didn't want to throw Sam and Lydia under the bus Hard agree on your did/would do list OP . I had a back up save where the judge goes with just Witness. That does seem to work if you have the connection with the phone and the box. I also got unreasonably attached to both Henry and Shinji and I don't know what that says about me.

[gabagool]

I was the same, except I accused Yuri Night instead of Lydia Day Break, just for the sake of consistency and going into Perfect 25 with my "friends". It worked well, Yuri Night still confessed stuff and went further into accusing Carmelina for the conspiracy. The only accusation I didn't feel so good about was Witness with the Killer Demon. Like, he was the only one the evidences pointed to, but it still felt kinda empty. It was part of another conspiracy entirely, which was kinda left unclosed even after killing him. After the trials, I didn't execute nor exile anyone. Henry Division was a dangerous individual but as a civilian he wouldn't come with us to Perfect 25 anyway.

[Bookish]

Originally posted by Nemorov:

This game was great. I really hope they make a sequel. I came to the same conclusions as OP, even though I REALLY didn't want to throw Sam and Lydia under the bus Hard agree on your did/would do list OP . I had a back up save where the judge goes with just Witness. That does seem to work if you have the connection with the phone and the box. I also got unreasonably attached to both Henry and Shinji and I don't know what that says about me.

Well, you're not alone, because I also got attached to Henry and Shinji. I liked that they didn't try to talk around or excuse what this society did in its pursuit of "perfection." If I could have, I'd have saved them both from the island's destruction, although I doubt either one of them would have appreciated it. Not to mention they were both sort of walking corpses.