Coral Island

Coral Island

View Stats:
LiLRotum Nov 22, 2023 @ 5:52am
Ring Toss Minigame
This is the only minigame (thus far) that requires 100% perfection to win, which seems antithetical to a game that's supposed to be laid back. Add in that you cannot skip the mini game once you fail (and are thus forced to throw all six rings before you can restart), and you have all the makings of a miserable experience. Please rework this minigame.
< >
Showing 1-9 of 9 comments
kittykat0510 Nov 22, 2023 @ 8:02pm 
I would have to agree. If you got 1st if you tied with the top score it'd be a little better. But the minigames should be fun little things to do in between your farming and right now most of them aren't. I could probably count on one hand the minigames I actually found fun.
Roland Nov 22, 2023 @ 8:20pm 
Originally posted by kittykat0510:
I could probably count on one hand the minigames I actually found fun.

Oh man, I'm so sorry to hear you lost four of your fingers! Was it some sort of industrial accident? ;-)

Joking aside, minigames vs computer opponents are pretty much never fun. Mario Party with friends can be fun. Mario Party as a single player game is the worst. Mini games are just too simplistic to be fun when you aren't playing with friends and that goes for any game-- even games that are 100% made to be just a collection of minigames.

The only minigames that I've found even slightly amusing vs computer controlled opponents are rhythm games to catchy music and even then you pretty much know when the computer is letting you win because it's impossible to obfuscate the AI making planned mistakes since the games are so simplistic. It's fine that this game has minigames but people should expect them to be on par with every other minigame that exists in the universe: Fun vs friends but horrible vs computer.
Last edited by Roland; Nov 22, 2023 @ 8:23pm
Melfix Nov 22, 2023 @ 8:35pm 
The swimming mini-game during the Beach Clean Up festival I found infuriating.

One of the contestants (Sunny) never stops. He just moves on with not a care in the world. The rest of the contestants have varying degrees of stamina, with the one to the far right stopping about 4/5th of the way to the finish line.

But Sunny? Nope, he's apparently an Olympic Gold swimmer with how he's not stopping for a second.
peter.melb Nov 22, 2023 @ 10:07pm 
I don't enjoy the button-mashing of any of the festival mini games.
Calico Witch Nov 23, 2023 @ 5:19am 
The only mini game I liked and won was the Curling. The rest were just frustrating.
ashlyn_61 Nov 23, 2023 @ 5:35am 
I believe I read somewhere that the devs posted on the discord that they were working on updating at least some of the minigames? So hopefully we'll see an improvement soon!

Everytime I do the main event in a festival and it says 'Are you sure? There's still fun games to play!" I think "What fun games? They must be in another game because they're not here lmao". I love the rest of the game, but I was so hoping for an overhaul of the minigames from EA to 1.0. The stuttering makes the sack race very difficult (I'll hit the button when I see the meter is at perfect but due to lag it's actually off perfect and I'll fall down) and with many of the others it's wildly hard for me to beat any of the NPCs. The only one I actually won 1st was the swimming minigame weirdly enough. The Animal Festival is very cute but my first playthrough I wasn't able to unlock pets or buy the barn/coop in time so I basically could only play the rodeo minigame (which was...uh........), meaning it was kind of just a wash my first year. In my 1.0 playthrough I'm spending Spring rushing to buy and unlock things so I can actually participate, and it definitely kills some of the cozy atmosphere.

It's definitely possible I may be just bad, but I did win at and really enjoy all the Roots of Pacha minigames so I can't be too awful.
LiLRotum Nov 23, 2023 @ 8:09am 
I'm so glad to see that I'm not the only one feeling frustrated by the mini game(s).

Originally posted by ashlyn_61:
I believe I read somewhere that the devs posted on the discord that they were working on updating at least some of the minigames? So hopefully we'll see an improvement soon!

Everytime I do the main event in a festival and it says 'Are you sure? There's still fun games to play!" I think "What fun games? They must be in another game because they're not here lmao". I love the rest of the game, but I was so hoping for an overhaul of the minigames from EA to 1.0. The stuttering makes the sack race very difficult (I'll hit the button when I see the meter is at perfect but due to lag it's actually off perfect and I'll fall down) and with many of the others it's wildly hard for me to beat any of the NPCs. The only one I actually won 1st was the swimming minigame weirdly enough. The Animal Festival is very cute but my first playthrough I wasn't able to unlock pets or buy the barn/coop in time so I basically could only play the rodeo minigame (which was...uh........), meaning it was kind of just a wash my first year. In my 1.0 playthrough I'm spending Spring rushing to buy and unlock things so I can actually participate, and it definitely kills some of the cozy atmosphere.

It's definitely possible I may be just bad, but I did win at and really enjoy all the Roots of Pacha minigames so I can't be too awful.

I do hope that this is true! It'd be nice to feel as if our voices have been heard.
syzara Nov 23, 2023 @ 8:25am 
The vast majority of these mini-games are infuriating, and they managed to make the swimming *worse* on release.

All the button smashing is just annoying, frustrating and the opposite of the rest of the game. Who asked for all these twitchy bits anyway.

/and i say that while also having won the rodeo thing during animal festival... the fact that i can sometimes win it does not make it a nice experience
Last edited by syzara; Nov 23, 2023 @ 8:26am
ashlyn_61 Nov 23, 2023 @ 10:00am 
I decided to try playing the sack race in 1.0, to see if it had been improved at all since EA, and unfortunately it has not. Going to stop my playthrough in the hope the devs do decide to update the minigames, because I really, really want to love this game.

Going by online discussion on the sack race, I believe this is because you need more max stamina to succeed in it (since even when I had no misses, I was still behind the NPCs waiting for my stamina to refill). Okay, so I think that the idea is for a minigame that's extremely difficult to win the first year, but by second year you'll have more max stamina and a much better chance. Not a bad idea, it means players want to keep going to festivals after year 1.

But then I looked at the rewards for winning the sack race, and the reward for 1st place is $1000, 5 candies, and 100 merit points. Merit points are useful, but you get them anyways just for going to every festival. And by second year spring in just my first playthrough I was raking in thousands per day and had access to cooking so the money and candy would be virtually worthless to me. The time that reward would actually feel like a major reward would be...first year Spring, when a player is starting out and needs money/energy items. So this is a minigame extremely difficult to win the first year, with rewards that would have the most value the first year? It just feels like a no win scenario for the players.

I would love if they made the games more possible to win, especially in the first year. I know mods will come out that will probably give you autowins/infinite stamina/etc., but I wouldn't think that the devs put so much effort into making a wide variety of games just for people to skip or autowin them. I imagine they want players to find the games fun and rewarding, not unfair and frustrating. So I have my finger crossed that, after all the bugs are fixed, this is something that also sees a hotfix. This is really the only major issue I have with the game, so if it's fixed I genuinely think it could be one of my favourite games.
< >
Showing 1-9 of 9 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Nov 22, 2023 @ 5:52am
Posts: 9